I know fair few guy running start ups, and some who got into YC. I can say they are not the type of people who aspire to working in IB's with perfect resumes from elite universities. One got fired a few times, because he could not cope with the lack autonomy, and ended up in arguments with senior management. His doing quite well now. I can say his attributes that made him fail there, made him a success in someway with his own co-founded startup.
I say this as someone who did go to an elite university.
Some have top-tier resumes, some are drop-outs, some have a huge amount of domain expertise in their field and some are complete newbies. Many are somewhere in between.
It's bad for the startup community to push "founder-stereotype" myths because it discourages people who don't fit the stereotype and that's bad for everyone.
But as it gets more popular(and competitive) I think diversty of startup founders will be smaller. And something will be lost because of it.
If we're not careful every startup founder will be from an elite background, from an elite family. Undiscovered talent will never be discovered.
Accelerators are going with the safe options, rather than potentials.
Start ups were one of the few ways people not from elite background could achieve massive success.
The people running EF are also elite, investment banks and management consultants. Which is probably why they hire, who they hire.
As usual though, successful founders must find their own way, and if they are dependent on being given a shot by some gatekeeper they probably never had much chance to be a successful entrepreneur anyway.
None of your examples were investment bankers.
Bezos and Khan worked at hedge funds. Thiel worked as a derivatives trader. Wales was a trader. Schacter was a quant trader.
Pincus was an investment banker.
For example see the Wikipedia article:
(for that matter Jimmy Wales of Wikipedia, Joshua Schacter of Delicious and Sal Khan of Khan academy are all ex-investment banking as well)
The scrappy drop-out risking all to start a startup narrative is cute, but only represents a small fraction of successful startups. Many startup founders had significant financial success before founding their startups.