Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by dang on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @10:22PM
(#7563811)
Substantive posts of intellectual interest are always welcome on Hacker News.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by tokenadult on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @10:59PM
(#7563919)
How substantive is an n=1 anecdote about some biomarker interventions with no hard endpoints?
Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by dang on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:12PM
(#7563959)
It's not a peer-reviewed controlled study, of course, but HN isn't a scientific journal. In my view the post is clearly substantive enough for a general interest site.
There's such a thing as a substantive anecdote, and self-observation and self-experimentation have a long and noble history. It's wrong, of course, to draw hard scientific conclusions from such a piece, but it's not wrong to read one, nor to write one, nor to do this kind of experimentation, nor to find it interesting. Plus there's a hacker angle in the DIY aspect.
That's my take on it, anyway. I thought it was cool, and I hope that HN readers are smart enough not to draw the obvious bogus conclusions.
Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by jamesbritt on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:28PM
(#7564006)
One of the upsides to such posts is they can trigger comments that reference more rigorous sources. While I don't think this is intentional it feels like a variation on the trick of getting an answer to a question by either saying something can't be done or by posting obviously wrong or otherwise flawed code.
Basically, xkcd 386.
Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by tptacek on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:11PM
(#7563956)
statistically powerful stories ⊂ substantive stories
Re:My experiments with preventing heart disease
by tokenadult on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:26PM
(#7563999)
Thomas, in relation to my question and Daniel's answer, could you kindly explain the direction of the subset relation you are talking about there?