I guess you caught me. On the other hand, at the time I started using StartSSL, the cheapest non-free certificate provider I could find charged something like €70 a year, which was more than it was worth to me. Just two days ago I happened to look for cheap certificates again and found one for €9, and I'd totally pay that as long as my real name can stay anonymous (like now with StartSSL, my name isn't included in the certificate).
So it also has much to do with how much you charge. Free is a special price and may make people ask for unreasonable things, but if the choice is between nothing or more than it was worth, that choice is very easy. Then when shit hits then fan...
FWIW, GoDaddy didn't charge me anything to rekey my certificate.
I also have a certificate with StartSSL, but on finding it would cost $25 to revoke, I purchased a new one from namecheap for $10. I know this leaves the StartSSL cert potentially floating about but it's only for a personal site (no real valuable data) so que sera sera…
I mean, are there cases where the pathological customer is a justifiable cost of doing business? Is StartSSL one of those cases?
Meanwhile, look at all the nonsense that e.g. GoDaddy (who also charges for revocations) is not getting right now. Because the folks with altered understandings of reality got scared away by the $20 or whatever it costs on year 1, and are plaguing StartSSL instead.