Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by devindotcom on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:10PM
(#7550298)
It may not logically follow, but in the real world it is not a strange thing to trust an actual expert on these topics over, say, a writer at the Daily Mail. Why object?
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by fleitz on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:18PM
(#7550341)
It's even better to examine their argument sans credentials.
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by calinet6 on Monday April 07, 2014 @07:37PM
(#7550436)
It's even better to do both, and embrace a complete and holistic argument.
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by na85 on Monday April 07, 2014 @08:34PM
(#7550658)
>You know that claiming to be a professional violinist is an appeal to authority rather than a logical argument, right?
Am I on reddit or something? You know that starting a statement with "you know that..." sounds pretentious as fuck, right?
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by fleitz on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @02:43AM
(#7551786)
Yes, I did know that.
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by na85 on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @03:53AM
(#7552019)
So you don't think that I, a lousy trumpet player who hasn't picked up an instrument in almost a decade, have reason to give a professional violinist the benefit of the doubt when she said she could pick out the Stradivarius?
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:13PM
(#7550835)
"Appeal to authority" is a shorthand form. The thing people object to is more formally known as "appeal to false authority" (think "I'm not a doctor, but I play one on TV").
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by dragonwriter on Monday April 07, 2014 @09:25PM
(#7550876)
Improper appeals to authority are not limited to appeals to false authority; appeal to authority to dismiss evidence are also fallacious.
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by thaumasiotes on Monday April 07, 2014 @10:04PM
(#7551006)
This is not so; we rely on authorities because we can't judge everything ourselves. If you show me some new evidence on the role of free protons in the aging process or whatever, it's not a mistake for me to say "I'll ignore that until such time as <someone I trust> addresses it". I might be wrong as to reality, but I can't avoid using that exact strategy in almost all of my life.
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by dllthomas on Monday April 07, 2014 @11:17PM
(#7551247)
But that's not an appeal to authority, really, is it? That's your relying on an authority to inform yourself, rather than pointing to authority as why others should believe what you do. These strike me as subtly different, though there's clearly some overlap in considerations...
Re:What Really Happened in that Double-Blind Violin Sound Test
by dragonwriter on Tuesday April 08, 2014 @10:01AM
(#7553437)
There's a difference between using authority status as a filter to find likely-to-be-valid arguments and using "so-and-so says X is not true" alone as a rebuttal to evidence that X is true. The former is a pragmatic research tool, the latter is the fallacy of appeal to authority.
You know that claiming to be a professional violinist is an appeal to authority rather than a logical argument, right?
That said the study does seem to be massively misreported.