I wouldn't be that suspicious. It is not unreasonable that someone would want to do the trade in a public place, and not give out their personal address. And I typically don't think to ID people who are selling me something.
1. Meeting at the seller's place.
2. Seeing a receipt of original sale or some other evidence of ownership.
3. Seeing an ID so, if it's stolen, I'll know who sold it to me.
4. Checking against registries for stolen things. Not all stolen things are registered as stolen, but the thief isn't willing to take the risk.
Refusing #1 and lacking #2 is completely understandable, but if they also refuse #3 and #4, I'd be really suspicious. Fortunately, I've never had a seller do that.
Oh, and when it comes to expensive stuff, I really don't feel comfortable counting money in a coffee shop. It quickly attracts attention. It would be quite plausible if someone noticed the money, followed the seller, and robbed them (or just stole their bag).
Now I wonder why the idea didn't occur to me earlier: Meet at a bank. It's safe, secure, and it might even be possible to avoid using cash. I'll definitely consider it the next time I sell something on Craigslist.
I found some of the PO's personal information on the laptop. I called the local police department, and they weren't interested, they said to call the police department where it was (edit: maybe) stolen. I called that police department, they said they'd check their reports and call me back.
I called back the next day, same thing. Second day, same thing. Third day, same thing, so I called my local police again to see if they could speed things up. Still not interested.
All in all, we held on to it for a week before finally returning it to him.
I really hated to do that. I've had my stuff stolen before too, one of my friends had her laptop stolen. It sucks, a lot. I really wanted to at least make sure it hadn't been reported lost or stolen. But all of the authorities involved were totally uninterested, and I didn't feel right about doubting my customer enough to contact the PO directly, either.
http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/nevius/article/A-number-you-ne...
The only thing I can think of is trying to flip it on Craigslist. That would require an odd arrangement where the buyer didn't meet the thief at their home. I'd be very suspicious if a seller only wanted to meet at a coffee shop and, once meeting there, didn't show me an ID or Apple receipt (or show me the serial number in their iCloud account, etc).
With so many incentives against stealing these things, and such a tiny reward, I'm honestly confused why people do it.