News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by jcampbell1 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:10PM (#7528429)
Consider the following statements:

A) We live in a meritocracy

B) Meritocracies are fair

Most people accept that A is false. We all know a fucktard that managed to get rich by being manipulative and destroying value. The problem is that people then fail to realize that B is also false.

Meritocracies are not fair. Allocating wealth to the people that provide a large amount of entertainment, seems fair, but it is not fair in a broad sense of the word. Meritocracies reward those with good health, good luck, good parents who are encouraging, and the lucky gamete club who have high intelligence or exceptional physical skills.

Meritocracies are like democracy: "the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried."

Working hard on a startup doesn't really earn you anything. The best you can hope for is that hard work increases your luck surface area. Keep in mind, that there are people that came from better sperm and eggs who will work just as hard but have a much higher chance of success.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by brc on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:23PM (#7528496)
I read a lot of whining on this thread (and many other, recently as well). 'Fair' pops up a lot.

The world is not fair. You can either spend your time griping, or you can spend your time living.

I sense a lot of 'daddy' models of wealth swimming in peoples heads.

http://paulgraham.com/gap.html

If you didn't win the birth lottery it's not a death sentence. You can still win. Measure your progress against your own expectations, not against the lottery winners.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ACow_Adonis on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:02AM (#7529204)
While I agree with Paul Graham about a lot of things, its worth pointing out that the man's wikipedia page says he was born (in the US, sorry, in the UK, my bad), went to Cornell where he graduated at 22, then practically straight on to Harvard to do masters, and then a PhD, and is primarily noted for being rich because he was bought out by Yahoo. Something that cannot happen for the majority of people, merit or no, and if that black swan didn't happen for him, i imagine we'd have a significantly different opinion of him. Indeed, who is to say that Yahoo didn't make a complete mistake? We'll never know i guess because we can never see the opportunity costs of alternate futures we haven't experienced.

While its possible to end up being rich if you didn't win the birth lottery, its pretty obvious Paul Graham did win it, and you'd have to be numerically or statistically illiterate to not realize that where you start the game is basically the most powerful predictor of both riches and poverty...

Frankly, i wish we could just get over this nonsense of equating extremes of wealth and merit, since there seems to be such little empirical evidence of how to equate the two, or agreement on what merit even is...

One thing that does seem empirically obvious though. Rich people aren't "individually responsible" for wealth themselves. No one has walked out of the amazon forest in a loin cloth and already been a billionaire because of how much wealth they were able to create while there by themselves...

/no offense intended to Paul Graham, he was just used in the example, but from reading his essays I'm guessing he's not terribly insecure :P

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bootload on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:13AM (#7529249)
"... says he was born in the US, went to Cornell, then to Harvard, ..."

pg is a Pom, "is an English programmer," cf: ~ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_Graham_%28computer_program...

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ACow_Adonis on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:17AM (#7529264)
Just caught my error :P
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by brc on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:26AM (#7529840)
I respect pg for the quality of his writing (in fact, the piece I linked is what brought me to this site many years ago, I had no idea of his background at that point).

Going to decent universities, building a successful startup company in the web space is definitively NOT a 'black swan'. It's something that many people plan, prepare and work very hard at executing for. This concept that pg won some sort of birth lottery and had his path paved with luck is preposterous based on the autobiographical story that I have read.

The whole point of Y Combinator is to remove a lot of the luck component by providing guidance that detaches the need to made lucky decisions, and gets down to being able to execute on an idea making something people want. The whole thing is as merit based as it can get.

While lots of people want to say 'but what about a poor man in Africa' as some sort of reductio ad absurdum to prove a point - realistically what we are talking about here is someone born in a western democratic liberal country and the chance at a decent education. You also don't have to be a billionaire to achieve what most people would like to achieve. Drawing out the extremes of the argument makes the discussion useless for the audience of this site.

What I take umbrage at is a lot of people say 'waah it's not fair someone got lucky' and then spending the rest of their lives in this refrain, pointing out the inequities of the world and refusing to achieve. All this tiresome '1% unfair inequitable boo hoo not fair' whining is unproductive and self indulgent.

If you want wealth or success get out and try and achieve it. The percentages of succeeding are low. The percentages of succeeding are 0 unless you try.

I have not been as successful as Paul Graham. I certainly don't cry about it and moan about some priveledge he got and I didn't, as though that gives me an excuse and a moral hammer to bludgeon people with. My starting hand wasn't as good as many, so I have to play a better game. Whether I ultimately achieve a higher success is entirely within my set of choices, and I don't blame anyone in the world for that. It's my responsibility.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by marvin on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:38AM (#7530231)
I respect PG because he's a really good essayist and also a visionary in technology. Don't know why you seem to be attributing his fame to the fact that he's rich.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by sillysaurus3 on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:05AM (#7529786)
It doesn't sound like he won the birth lottery, except insofar as being born to parents whose primary language was English (his essays are what made him famous, so this extra few years of practicing English was important) and living in a situation where he could attend Cornell. Being accepted into Cornell probably took a lot of hard work. Getting into Harvard after attending Cornell also took hard work.

The most convincing argument that pg won any birth lottery that I can think of is that his parents were able to instill a desire into him at a young age to attend an elite university. My parents often spoke of the benefits, but they weren't able to get through to me about the reasons why it's important.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by anigbrowl on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:01PM (#7528928)
And then there's situations like this: https://www.secret.ly/p/feexnrnpunzjadkhinaegigziy

(HN auto-kills secret.ly submissions, but I'm willing to bet this will be a top story next week when verifiable details emerge.)

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by marvin on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:46AM (#7530251)
What the fuck, dude. That's just atrocious.

On the other hand, this is the most beautiful sex discrimination lawsuit I've ever seen waiting to happen. I really hope she has the ability, guts and staying power to move through with it.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by sizzle on Friday April 04, 2014 @06:48AM (#7530438)
"They gave me 10k- everyone else got 5m packages. "

I would be absolutely livid in this situation. This is truly a shame, hope they get something out of this when it becomes big news. Thanks for sharing.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by supergauntlet on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:53AM (#7529556)
Jesus, if that's as bad as it seems I feel really really bad for that lady. Obviously there's two sides to every story but that just seems terrible.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by joyeuse6701 on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:44AM (#7529526)
Yeah holy crap, talk about an injustice.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by supergauntlet on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:54AM (#7529560)
I just kept scrolling down and was thinking 'okay... maybe they weren't that great of a worker?' and then they claim that they both came up with the company idea and the UI/UX. If that's true that's all kinds of fucked.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by tim333 on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:49AM (#7529735)
I imagine if it becomes public Google would be shamed into doing something. It wouldn't make them look very good.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ericd on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:06AM (#7530131)
It seems like it's already becoming public.

But yeah, I'm not a fan of how acquihires work at all - if you own 20% of the company's stock, you should get 20% of the payout upon acquisition. Otherwise, those employment and investment terms are significantly less meaningful.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ac2u on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:39AM (#7530232)
This isn't just with acquihires though, the liquidation preferences set out in the term sheet for a round of investment in general could yield the same result in any sort of liquidation event. I suppose it's all the more reason to have a good lawyer and know what you're signing.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by barrkel on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:51PM (#7528605)
The world is not binary either, and that doesn't mean that we can't adjust society to increase or decrease the amount of fairness. It also doesn't mean that the adjusted amount of fairness in society and its rules (both laws and social norms) can't have positive or negative effects on overall total welfare.

Oh, and also: nobody wins. Some just take longer to lose.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by quasque on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:00PM (#7528643)
The world is not fair, therefore we should collectively just shut up and put up with this enduring inequality? The majority of the world's population are living in poverty, and well over a billion people are entirely destitute. Lacking food, water, healthcare, sanitation, education - can they still 'win'?
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by EGreg on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:41PM (#7529098)
Guys winning is relative to the game you play. Do you really think every game is going to be fair?

In the games which everyone MUST play - healthcare, food, shelter - there should be a minimum safety net for ALL. This can be achieved using Basic Income.

But fairness? What exactly does that mean? At the end of the day those who do better in the game will get a better reward and maybe do better in the future etc. Is this because they had more "talent"? Or got more lucky? What is fairness here?

At the end of the day, people want to be happy and healthy.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by koonsolo on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:47AM (#7529889)
If you can read and post on Hacker News, you've already won the birth lottery. Some babies are born in North Korean prison camps. If you live in the western world are handy with technology, you definitely won the birth lottery.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by narrator on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:01PM (#7528650)
The system isn't a democracy or a meritocracy, it's the system with all its ugliness, obfuscation, ambiguity, complexity and pettiness that comes with it being composed of lots of people seeking their own interests. Stop trying to turn it into an abstract philosophical concept. Just deal with it as best as you can, and if you really understand it well or just let dumb luck lead you down the right path you might even be able to hack it like the guy in this story.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by anatari on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:37PM (#7528545)
These things aren't binary. I believe the USA is more meritocratic than it's not. Also depends on what you define as merit. Is having capital a merit? In the eyes of the economy anything that has utility has merit, and capital certainly has very high utility.

B) Yes, meritocracies are not equal by definition, but again, I think it is more fair than not. Fair does not mean equal, it means being "thought to be right" so it will depend on each person's morality. I for one, certainly do not want to live in a world where good health has no advantages over bad health, even if I was unhealthy.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by FLUX-YOU on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:24PM (#7528757)
There was a blog post here recently that I can't find. It spoke about how someone starting from the bottom of the labor pool and getting promotions to middle management. The blog made the analogy that he'd climbed a mountain from the base to a certain height.

In another example, there's another person born with access to wealth, connections, and high-quality education. This one can reach the peak much more easily because he started higher on the mountain, but in both examples, the same amount of 'distance' was covered.

The second example could easily find a job as middle management and just coast through life. That's not really impressive given his starting conditions. He hasn't really moved much on the mountain if he decides to do this (maybe even going backwards).

In a meritocracy, the praise for this absolute progress is lost because the goal posts on the mountain are more-or-less sticky, slowly pushed higher as technology and social advances moves us towards bigger accomplishments. Also, the slope of the mountain is steeper when it's closer to the earth, which is often shaped by the powerful.

No one will likely give you a higher salary despite that you struggled through awful jobs, tight budgets, and many other inconveniences of not having wealth. They don't care how you acquired the 'skills' you have, as long as you have them.

This is fairly obvious stuff, but a meritocracy that ignores this other dimension of merit really irks me. America in particular (only because I live here) is a society that really doesn't reward this other dimension of effort but continues to use the feel-good narrative of hard work and long hours for whatever purposes.

Of course I'd have a completely different view on American meritocracy if we were in a real post-scarcity world.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by loup-vaillant on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:06PM (#7528673)
> * In the eyes of the economy anything that has utility has merit, and capital certainly has very high utility.*

Depends on your utility function. Capital can certainly prove very useful for whoever is wilding it, but the near-edge of this sword can easily cut us when the wielder happens to be a sadistic psychopath. Or when the power of money corrupts the wielder. Or when the costs of building that capital (externalities such as pollution, rip-offs, lay-offs…) outweigh any later benefit…

> Fair […] [depends] on each person's morality.

Luckily, we humans appear to have a fairly stable morality across individuals. (There are psychological experiments on moral dilemmas, and as far as I know, they indicate we agree on most of the important things. Though there are some "off-switches" in our moral systems —religion, "following orders"…)

> * I for one, certainly do not want to live in a world where good health has no advantages over bad health, even if I was unhealthy.*

There are two aspects you need to keep track of. On the one hand, the absolute advantage, and on the other, the comparative advantage.

Height for instance is a comparative advantage. We tend to look up to taller people, merely because they are taller. So they're more followed, they "get all the girls", better jobs, and so on. But if everyone was taller, it wouldn't change a thing. That's a purely comparative advantage.

Health on the other hand has an absolute component. If we were suddenly immune to all diseases, the world would be a significantly better place.

In other words, you wouldn't care if everyone was taller, but you would like everyone to be healthy.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by CJefferson on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:30AM (#7529675)
Look at many articles, including this one: http://www.economist.com/news/united-states/21595437-america...

I'm afraid the USA is much less meritocratic than Europe. In the USA, the class into which you are born is a more important factor in where you will end up than it is in Europe (which I realise is the opposite to most people's belief).

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by yummyfajitas on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:21AM (#7529821)
Unless you have evidence that merit is uncorrelated with class, your data does not support your conclusion.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by nhaehnle on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:22AM (#7529998)
Yeah, CJefferson probably expressed her/himself badly in what s/he was trying to say, but there are better ways to express that - your response comes across as snarky and trolling (and yes, I know who you are).

For certain definitions of "merit", it is obvious and plain for everybody to see that class has a great impact on "merit". From conception, the children of upper class parents have an advantage that ends up being visible in fairly objective measures of e.g. intelligence.

This is not what the debate is about, though. Actually, anatari already pointed this out; I quote: " Also depends on what you define as merit. [...]"

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by barry-cotter on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:51AM (#7531350)
Intergenerational social mobility is basically invariant across human societies. See The Son Also Rises, Gregory Clark.

Sweden, Britain, China, almost identical. Note, China, communism, cultural revolution and all didn't have any lasting effect on social mobility.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by quasque on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:50PM (#7528604)
I guess you're thinking of an unlikely "Harrison Bergeron" type of scenario. But if such a world was instead achieved instead via highly advanced medicine and universal access to health care, then why not? I would consider that a best case scenario for humanity's future.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by Crito on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:17AM (#7529265)
If everyone exceeds to their full potential, then those with greater potential will see greater success. That seems problematic to you, but what are the alternatives?

Those with less potential exceeding beyond there potential is nonsensical. If that happens, it only means that you incorrectly estimated their potential in the first place.

Alternatively if we limit success such that those with the most potential can never realize the full extent of their potential, how is that fair? Those people only get one life, you should not deprive them of their ability to live it to their fullest.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ericd on Friday April 04, 2014 @05:10AM (#7530150)
I've always liked this quote from Enemy at the Gates (set in the USSR during WW2):

I've been such a fool, Vassili. Man will always be a man. There is no new man. We tried so hard to create a society that was equal, where there'd be nothing to envy your neighbour. But there's always something to envy. A smile, a friendship, something you don't have and want to appropriate. In this world, even a Soviet one, there will always be rich and poor. Rich in gifts, poor in gifts. Rich in love, poor in love.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ekianjo on Friday April 04, 2014 @12:04AM (#7529212)
> Meritocracies reward those with good health, good luck, good parents who are encouraging, and the lucky gamete club who have high intelligence or exceptional physical skills.

I wonder what's the good luck doing in the middle of your argument... but it's plain not true. I know a ton of smart people who didn't end up becoming widely successful nor rich once they entered the job market (or tried to create something on their own). If at all, who YOU KNOW and relate to is more important than your own skills, that's why even dumbasses from university were able to get great jobs, because they were great at socializing and making the network work for them, while their own skills at doing anything were actually very poor.

And that's fair. Even people who are not highly intelligent can make it to the top of society (look at politicians, hehe). Look at all the immigrants from different countries who actually ended up being successful after starting lower than anyone else in society.

And I'm not sure what is your definition of fair. There are some people who assume stuff is not fair when they don't get their share of the cake at every party. That's not what fair means in a broad sense.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bluekeybox on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:31PM (#7528517)
Philosophical question (don't take offense, please):

Why should we be rewarding "unlucky" gametes?

Please note that I don't consider the likely answer "because they have something useful to contribute to society" as a good one because it assumes that one individual mind (with all its hopes and biases) can comprehend what is really good for society in the long run (think thousands or tens of thousands of years).

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by barrkel on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:43PM (#7528577)
ISTM you're approaching a social Darwinist (i.e. 20th century fascist) perspective there.

Take your philosophical angle: do you think society is better off in the long run for having had Socrates, Plato, Aristotle?

How many unlucky Aristotles are we wasting in poverty in Africa?

I can't directly address your question, because it doesn't seem well formed to me. Which "one individual mind" is comprehending, and what is it doing with this comprehension (is it a judge)? Why is tens of thousands of years important - is that because you explicitly want to discount intelligence and knowledge, and only look at the biological ramifications? By that metric, humans might be better off if we wiped out all mammals and devolved into flowers - you haven't established what good even means (it cannot be survival, since that fails Hume's is/ought rule).

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by hueving on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:53PM (#7528616)
>I can't directly address your question, because it doesn't seem well formed to me.

Let me see if I can take a stab at re-wording it. Why should someone who provides little value to society be rewarded the same as people that provide more value to society?

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by gress on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:01PM (#7528651)
That's a strawman - the alternative to a meritocracy is not necessarily communism.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by nikatwork on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:35PM (#7528808)
Although The Communist Manifesto rails against capitalism's devaluing of art, philosophy and anything else that can't immediately be converted into ka-ching.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by gress on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:45PM (#7528862)
Sure, the point is that meritocracy and communism are not the only options.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bluekeybox on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:41PM (#7528836)
Thank you for your response. You bring up some good points, but I would like to contest others.

First, I agree that humans should probably not "devolve" into flowers (although "devolve" is a funny word -- technically, evolution, like entropy, is a one-way process, where even parasites can be said to evolve in their own way).

Second, I agree that exceptional individuals like the Greek scholars you mentioned contributed enormously to the human progress in the past two thousand years.

Third, I agree that average human condition in Africa is currently deplorable compared to average human condition on all other Earth's continents.

Where we seem to disagree is in the way we frame our questions and our solutions. Assuming I am an individual of significant wealth with altruistic motives, I would like to produce as many Aristotles, Platos, and Socrates in as short of a time frame as possible. Africa seems like a terrible, terrible place to invest my money with that goal in mind. First, as an individual investor, I can only invest during a timeframe of no more than approximately 20-30 years. Second, even if I open a foundation in my name that would continue doing my work after my death for centuries, Africa still looks bad (the worst in fact) because what happens if, for example, the country I invest in is taken over by a dictator or a warlord some fifty years from now (of which there is an extremely high risk throughout the entire continent of Africa) who brings the country back to the Middle Age or worse, while taking advantage of the invested results. Dictators have a common tendency of "cutting the tall poppies" when they come to power, which means that the African Aristotle I invested into will most likely be imprisoned or dead before he even becomes anything close to Aristotle.

I (as well as my foundation) would get a much better return on investment in a country like Romania that is "almost there" in terms of development and whose political situation is kept secure by a strong supranational organization like EU or NATO.

Finally, let me explain what I mean by the difference between individual and supra-individual. If you look at humanity's history over the past 3000 years, you will see that our attitude to things concerning politics was very different throughout. We had had pluralistic societies like Ancient Greece which simultaneously condoned slavery. Aristotle, for example, believed that certain individuals are superior "by natural right", and that others were better off serving their superiors, i.e. he was anti-egalitarian. I consider myself more egalitarian than Aristotle was, however I do not believe that our current fashion of rather extreme egalitarianism represents some final development; to me it appears as more of a "moral fashion" that always occurs at a certain phase of an outward wave of what I call "literatization" (as opposed to "civilization").

So to an individual mind in the early 21st century some truths (such as that societies have to be structured in one way and not another) may seem to be self-evident, but that's because an individual is always anchored to his or her historical epoch. Moreover, the desire to structure the society in a particular way seems to follow one's biological idiosyncrasies. For example, the primary driver of intellectual activities of a tall person may be an internalized wish to arrange the society in such a way that tall people are not discriminated against. Similarly, the primary driver of intellectual activities of a department of economics of a country X might be a motivation that the elite of that country stays in power.

For that reason, I tend not to trust neither egalitarians nor anti-egalitarians when it comes to evaluating whether a particular society is good or bad. Unfortunately, the only truly useful measure of a society's success (its ability to spread itself while maximizing the number of potential paths of realization of its individuals) is somewhat beyond of what can be measured over one's lifetime. So I tend to prefer to stay close to natural laws, and assume that if a particular gamete is "lucky", it is perhaps lucky for some reason that is unknowable to me.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by anigbrowl on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:15PM (#7528989)
Aristotle should not be your only point of reference here. Socrates had his life cut off early by an intellectually intolerant cabal, but we're certainly much better of for having had him around for a while, even if not as much as we might have hoped for.

It's also arguable that breakthroughs (philosophical, technological, or whatever) often take place in less-than-ideal contexts, because adversity is often synonymous with necessity. In a society where the majority of the population has it pretty good, there's opportunity for many flowers to flourish but it's hard to say whether any of them are very tenacious since the soil and growing conditions are ideal. If you're on the lookout for a rare flower, you're not likely to discover it in a greenhouse.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by EGreg on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:47PM (#7529129)
How do you know Socrates even existed?

As an aside - Socrates and Jesus seem to have many things in common. Socrates never wrote anything himself, his teachings challenged the status quo, he was accused of "corrupting the youth" and executed for blasphemy by the religious ruling group from his own people...

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by cubancigar11 on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:24AM (#7529828)
> I can only invest during a timeframe of no more than approximately 20-30 years

What you have concluded in you comment can be summed up in one word - short-sightedness. The only way to defend that position (which, in fact, you use) is to say that most people are and historically have been short-sighted, hence it is 'natural' ergo correct. You further imply that this... process... is out of our control.

This is disingenuous, and I will tell you why. You question egalitarianism because historically societies can be seen as contrarian among themselves. But you whitewash over the fact that we ARE in fact much much better-off than most people who have ever lived. We are better off than Aristotle himself and a large part of it can be attributed to the fact that he existed. He obviously didn't foresee the future and how he is going to literally effect it, but he did contribute to it because he was egalitarian.

But you already agree that you want more Aristotles, Platos and Socrates. What is disagreeable that you want them in a short of time frame at the cost of everything else because of 'particular gamete being lucky' or some other factor you don't know. In short, you are looking for profit and explaining away the lack of moral imperatives by invoking Darwinism. But:

1. There is no immediate pressure on us to produce Aristotles et. al. because they are not going to bring immediate benefit. We CAN plan for a long term future, though, and that means we can improve our chances of survival.

2. Darwinism requires diversity. Hence it is simply better to invest in disadvantaged, if you were egalitarian.

Let us be honest - the truth is that you are coming from a position of an individual with significant wealth who is looking for next Aristotle to increase his personal wealth by taking his, and you don't really care about Aristotle or his effect on anyone else. All the arguments are simply dressings to make that short-sightedness and greed look good.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bluekeybox on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:17AM (#7529981)
> What you have concluded in you comment can be summed up in one word - short-sightedness.

No. My conclusion was predicated on a belief that it is better that we have our Plato, Socrates, and Aristotle in the next 100-200 years rather than in the next 1000-2000. If you have budget of several tens of billions and you want to be judicious where you invest, it is unrealistic to expect to create magic in Africa over 100-200 years. In that situation the best you could hope to achieve for that continent is to invest in medicine aka what Bill Gates is doing, and hope that it will help turn the continent from 3rd world to something like Mexico (which is still far from great). And then what hope do you have that once all the work is done that people there won't elect someone like Chavez and start beating up students at local universities with baseball bats?

> you whitewash over the fact that we ARE in fact much much better-off than most people who have ever lived

Perhaps yes, but not if you listen to egalitarian vanguard. Just talk to OWS participants if you don't believe me. Though if we are indeed better off, how much of that is a function of technology rather than egalitarianism?

> you are looking for profit

What do you mean by "looking for profit"? As I said, my (hypothetical) motives are purely altruistic. I have fifty billion dollars and I am willing to spend them all to the last penny. All I want in return is the next Plato/Aristotle/Socrates within the next 100-200 years. Is that too much to ask? How do you interpret this motivation as "profit"? Who profits?

> There is no immediate pressure on us to produce Aristotles et. al. because they are not going to bring immediate benefit

First of all, it could be argued that someone like Plato has made a huge contribution to Greek and Roman civilizations. Aristotle was the personal tutor of Alexander the Great for God's sake. These individuals contributed tremendously, both within their lifetimes and in the millennia after. Second, even if you discount the influence these people had in the Ancient world, and assume that the majority of it is felt 1000 years after their death, then still it is better to have them sooner rather than later. For that means waiting 1000 years for the next step in our civilization rather than 2000 years.

> Darwinism requires diversity. Hence it is simply better to invest in disadvantaged

Why not invest in diverse but advantaged then? How is it that you jump from one proposition to the other (i.e. that diversity equals disadvantaged)?

> the truth is that you are coming from a position of an individual with significant wealth who is looking for next Aristotle to increase his personal wealth by taking his

No. We both agree that the next Aristotle probably wouldn't be the next billionaire. He will probably not be a poor man, but it is highly unlikely that he will turn my fifty billion into fifty trillion.

> All the arguments are simply dressings to make that short-sightedness and greed look good.

There! Just add that I'm a Zionist homosexual free-masonic Illuminati overlord. Perhaps you are that OWS supporter I mentioned above? In which case, I don't even have to invoke one as a literary device!

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by cubancigar11 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:25AM (#7530006)
> There! Just add that I'm a Zionist homosexual free-masonic Illuminati overlord. Perhaps you are that OWS supporter I mentioned above? In which case, I don't even have to invoke one as a literary device!

I wasn't being personal, instead I was referring to 'Assuming I am an individual of significant wealth with altruistic motives' part of your comment. But since you have taken it personally so it is better we stop here. I will clarify one thing, though: I am not from USA so I don't know anything about OWS. I don't even know you or what pushes all the wrong buttons in USA. I saw a bent towards the ugly side of Nietzsche in your comment which is why I felt compelled to reply.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bluekeybox on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:41AM (#7530058)
I didn't take it personally, was just having fun with words and certain populist stereotypes.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by hueving on Friday April 04, 2014 @07:23AM (#7530547)
>Let us be honest - the truth is that you are coming from a position of an individual with significant wealth who is looking for next Aristotle to increase his personal wealth by taking his, and you don't really care about Aristotle or his effect on anyone else. All the arguments are simply dressings to make that short-sightedness and greed look good.

Ah! A personal attack... what a wonderful way to dilute an otherwise decent argument.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by tim333 on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:58AM (#7529761)
If by 'rewarding "unlucky" gametes' you mean helping out the less bright and similar, we do it because it's nice and most people prefer it that way. An alternative of weeding out the unlucky gametes was tried by Hitler but proved unpopular.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by rhizome on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:51AM (#7529546)
Consider a different angle: can luck be created for others? Is it already? Is there a benefit in expanding the amount of luck in the world? Consider the possibility that a subtext of a lot of these discussions is the hoarding of luck.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by WalterBright on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:13PM (#7528691)
Hard work actually has very little to do with success. Effective work is what matters.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by marincounty on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:27PM (#7528770)
Who you know, and a wealthy father will take you far in life. This is Always conveniently left out of the speeches. I guess out of some kind of denial. i've only heard one wealthy person publicly admit his wealth and opportunities in life was because of their father. Yea, there's a reason the wealthy stay rich--generation after generation. The man who spoke the truth was George Soros. Growing up in Marin I have seen the process first hand. If you are a poor kid trying to make it in America, keep your wealthy friends close, if you can stomach it--I couldn't. I guess today it's called networking. Ugh!
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by WalterBright on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:02PM (#7528933)
85% of Americans are self-made - see the book "The Millionaire Next Door."
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by username223 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:47PM (#7529133)
You might want to read Piketty and Saez. Facts kinda matter.
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by duaakshay on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:30AM (#7529487)
Expanding on: "Meritocracies are like democracy: "the worst form of government except all the others that have been tried.""

Assuming the goal of any system of government (e.g., democracy) or marketplace (e.g., meritocracy for society, opportunity etc.) is the advancement/ progress, a meritocracy fails where the value it attaches to certain events/ attributes is flawed. It rewards something more than it contributes to progress, and insufficiently rewards something that brings greater value.

Bringing it back to the original post, I have often shared the opinion that currently providing entertainment, is rewarded more than it deserves in the current state of our meritocracy. One could contribute more to the advancement of society e.g., by improving energy efficiency but the person would not really be rewarded as disproportionately for doing so.

I find it sad therefore that so many smart people are driven to game development and not solve other more pressing problems. Or probably that society currently attributes so much value to entertainment.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ekianjo on Friday April 04, 2014 @01:54AM (#7529557)
> I find it sad therefore that so many smart people are driven to game development and not solve other more pressing problems. Or probably that society currently attributes so much value to entertainment.

Nobody is driven to game development, it's an individual choice. And your perspective that there are more pressing problems is an illusion. The more pressing problems are from your own point of view. From someone else's, making a living may be their top pressing problem before caring about anything else. And there are people who are genuinely good at making games, and they should keep doing it as long as they can bring good games on the market, because it benefits gamers as well. Gamers don't buy games to throw their time and money away, they do it also because they have fun with it, it stimulates them, makes them excited or relaxed, or in other words make them live in more ways than they would usually live. Not talking about flappy bird here, but there's a number of games that have depth and where you learn stuff by playing that develop your intellect as well.

Entertainment is important, because for most people, daily work is NOT entertaining nor fulfilling.

[deleted]
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ekianjo on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:42AM (#7530061)
> How much entertainment does the market really need? For example, so many awesome books have been written already that you don't need any more books, you can live your whole life reading just the best of the best old books and not make a dent. Yet tons of people become writers.

Moot point. You already have had many more books that you could hope to read in a lifetime in the previous centuries - this is nothing new. This is even true for games - it's impossible to play all games that have been created, and this is a much more recent medium.

The reason why books/movies/games keeps getting made is because NEWNESS has usually more value than anything else. You know, every time you go to the movies, that it's very likely that the movie is NOT the best movie you'll have ever seen. Yet, you may be interested to go because it's something NEW, and newness is what drives curiosity (and sales).

So, it's actually very rational. Most readers are more likely to buy the latest ebook from whoever than to pick up Homer out of the blue.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by duaakshay on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:59AM (#7529765)
"Nobody is driven to game development, it's an individual choice" > Acknowledge this

"there are more pressing problems is an illusion" > disagree. As some on another comment pointed out that around the world enough and more people do not have access to food, shelter, healthcare, education, energy etc. You could also refer to Maslow's priority of needs (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maslow's_hierarchy_of_needs). Entertainement can't fit anywhere other than right at the top of the pyramid.

And yes, everyone has individual needs and those are the most pressing for them. I was talking more from a society perspective.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by ekianjo on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:30AM (#7530027)
> And yes, everyone has individual needs and those are the most pressing for them. I was talking more from a society perspective.

Right, but in a free society you can't impose to people what they should work on. This is a matter of individual freedom, and we should treasure it, no matter what the choices are.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bildung on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:52AM (#7529745)
> The problem is that people then fail to realize that B is also false.

Indeed. Interestingly, the term meritocracy also had a negative meaning when it was coined in the 1950s: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meritocracy#Etymology

That meritocracy is interpreted in a positive way is a relativly recent phenomenon.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by kartman on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:55PM (#7528626)
I like to think what we value drives our day to day actions. Often, the rewards for those actions are along another dimension and independent of your values.

If we are lucky enough to line up our values and the rewards we get for our actions, that might be a happy life :).

In this case, I speculate the guy wanted to build something fun, the reward came in $, so there is angst of values driving the action vs the reward of the action. It's great he is so aware of it though.

In a path dependent process like life, I feel a good way to measure yourself is % increase over your former self, along any dimension and quantification you see fit.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by baddox on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:50AM (#7529739)
For an argument that relies so much on the word "fair," you should really start by defining it. Does "fair" mean equal? Equality of opportunity? Equality of results?
Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by bane on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:59PM (#7528639)
> Meritocracies are not fair.

True, for a meritocracy to be fair implies there is a fair arbiter. In absence of a fair arbiter people use something else as a proxy, money is typical.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by loup-vaillant on Thursday April 03, 2014 @09:43PM (#7528576)
Nitpick: your quote about "the worst form of government" generally assumes we're living in a democracy. But the people don't rule. Money does. So it's not a democracy.

Or, the definition of the word changed, and 90%+ of the people still uttering it haven't got the memo. (I have few kind words for those who have.)

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by username223 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @11:56PM (#7529169)
> But the people don't rule. Money does.

That sounds like Meritocracy 2.0.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by sgift on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:17AM (#7529629)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plutocracy

"defines a society or a system ruled and dominated by the small minority of the wealthiest citizens." - sounds correct.

Re:The Guilt of the Video-Game Millionaires by VMG on Friday April 04, 2014 @02:16AM (#7529628)
It starts even earlier

A-1) There is such a thing as "fair"