Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by jimboyoungblood on Sunday August 09, 2009 @09:29PM
(#751681)
You're presuming that URL shorteners don't provide any benefits that may justify the cost of a more fragile system. E.g., bit.ly gives you nice analytics, and many links are otherwise impossible to pass via Twitter.
Your argument against shorteners (extra indirection -> more fragile -> bad) works just as well against DNS. The reason why we tolerate the extra indirection of DNS is because there's a substantial benefit to be gained.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by Volt on Sunday August 09, 2009 @09:45PM
(#751699)
DNS servers co-operate and the system has lots of built-in redundancy, whereas URL shortners have none of these properties. It's not just the indirection that makes them fragile.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by jimboyoungblood on Sunday August 09, 2009 @10:08PM
(#751731)
So if there existed some sort of federated url shortening protocol, all the complaints about shorteners would go away?
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by Volt on Sunday August 09, 2009 @10:35PM
(#751769)
Probably not. The only place they're really warranted is on Twitter, so if Twitter did it themselves that would go a long way. There is the whole URL masking annoyance as well, so ideally Twitter would support long URLs, but that might not happen because of the 140 character SMS restriction.
A federated protocol seems a little much for this one service which can handle the issue themselves, IMO.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by jacquesm on Monday August 10, 2009 @03:01AM
(#752125)
For plenty of fora they're handy as well, then there's IRC
Another good reason to have them is to be able to spell them for somebody over a phone line.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by anirbas on Monday August 10, 2009 @04:25AM
(#752221)
I've also noticed a local free paper (Metro) using tinyurl links in its web section.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by bjelkeman-again on Monday August 10, 2009 @03:03AM
(#752130)
Twitter should really, really provide a separate field for URLs. This would solve this whole thing.
What is the point of an SMS with a shortened URL if you have no internet access? To be able to access the web page you need web access. If you have web access then you can get at the longer URL in the web interface or via Twitteriffic etc.
Re:Tr.im is now in the process of discontinuing service
by thwarted on Monday August 10, 2009 @02:41AM
(#752100)
The inability to pass (some) links via twitter is the fault of twitter (or the "features" thereof), a fault that doesn't suddenly disappear because someone else provides what amounts to a workaround.
The argument is that it makes things MORE fragile, by interposing another party into the resolution chain. Given that it is both easy to do (thus there will be lots of competitors) and hard to profit at means that this party is more than usually vulnerable.
Anyway if the content dissapears, then it is gone. A url shortner failing means the failure could occur even if the content is still available.
Therefore, by definition, it is worse than the other situation.