News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by moron4hire on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:18AM (#7514566)
So was bringing Firefox into the argument, considering he had been CTO the entire time since Prop 8.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by kzrdude on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @06:43AM (#7514662)
I'm not very into this discussion, but I don't get how this has turned into something so big.

Has California divided into two tribes (from the relatively evenly split referendum) where everyone in one tribe is calling the other tribe bigots? And is that a reasonable way to view the world (now multiple years afterwards)?

Edit: I forgot, of course, the big group that didn't vote at all.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by moron4hire on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:01AM (#7514712)
That seems to be the case. If we're going to start calling for chief officers to resign because they hold views we don't agree with, I'm not sure there would be many companies left unscathed. Certainly half of the NFL and NBA teams would be eviscerated.

And who is the "we" who gets to decide what is agreeable? No, I don't agree with the view behind Prop 8, but neither am I comfortable drawing such a line. To me, drawing such a line is equivalent to Prop 8 in the first place.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by lenazegher on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:21AM (#7514774)
Would you feel the same way if he'd donated $1000 to a campaign to outlaw interracial marriage?
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by pdpi on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:56AM (#7514875)
Yes. Yes I would. More to the point: If the tables were turned and it had been a pro-gay marriage CEO in a conservative company, we'd all be bitching and moaning about corporate culture suppressing the dissenting opinion. Why aren't we doing so when we don't agree with the dissenting opinion?

Mozilla's mission has nothing to do with gay rights, it's all about what the web should look like. Eich's opinion on gay marriage is immaterial to his work as CEO.

Now, it just so happen that there's a far few queer and ally Mozillians. If Eich's personal opinion were to extend into company policy about those people (or, in general, if his governance were to massively disagree with the company culture in any way), I'd question his fitness to lead. But coming from a company built on inclusiveness and tolerance, the shitstorm they're making about a member's personal opinions seems quite hypocritical, to be completely honest.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by bakhy on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:04AM (#7514901)
"we would be bitching"? you too? :)

i'm pretty sure i have the right to protest what ever i want, regardless of how irrelevant my life problems may seem to you, and regardless of how easy it is for you to ascribe them all to matters of difference of opinion.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by pdpi on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:26AM (#7515305)
Despite the subtle ad hominem, yes, me too. Absolutely. I'm pro-gay marriage (or, more to the point, given that gay marriage is now legal in Portugal, the fight has moved on, and it'd be more relevant to say that I'm for gay co-adoption).

I think you're missing the bigger point here. There is one topic I definitely care about more than I do about gay marriage: The capacity to even discuss it, and the right to talk about and support that cause if I see fit. And this is very much a case of what's good for the goose is also good for the gander. If you're OK with blocking Eich's ascension to CEO due to his position, it's hard to justify how you'd then be against other people being blocked like this for holding unpopular opinions.

In my experience, stifling debate usually hurts minorities and makes it easier to maintain the status quo, so if you want to further a minority cause, you need to be able to have open discussion, so all in all I'd rather allow people to voice unpopular opinions — in some circles, I'll be the one doing it!

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by bakhy on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:47AM (#7515449)
OK, you got my upvote ;) not just because you're for gay co-adoption, but because you really make a strong case.

i was really not that upset about all this, until i read the interview today. he really turned out sleazy, equating himself with the future of Mozilla, hiding behind Indonesian people, proclaiming protests against Mozilla keeping him on as being anti-freedom... he truly came off bad.

edit: but it still kinda lingers, the question - does his behavior fit with Mozilla ideals?

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by kzrdude on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:22AM (#7514959)
well, we can all talk about what's a better way to move forward. I believe that just like the issue of "interracial" marriages, the issue of same sex marriage both share one thing: the march of normalization is strong. People get used to it, also those that didn't want to. For this reason I think the best way to go forward as a society is reconciliation, tolerance and not mobbing.

"Either you are with us or against us" is a harmful doctrine.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by bakhy on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:45AM (#7515070)
using such argumentation one can dismiss any protest one does not like. a protest is a perfectly legitimate form of political action, and is the only proven effective method of achieving change in this type of thing.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by kzrdude on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @01:13PM (#7517095)
I don't agree, because my argument applies only when: the battle is already won. Same-sex marriage is normal. I'm talking about how we should behave after the battle is won.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by bakhy on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:42AM (#7521437)
ah, ok. i understand what you mean now.

i would not say that it is already won, though. only a minority of US states recognizes gay marriage, and over 70 countries (if i remember correctly) worldwide criminalize homosexuality. and even when it is won, it will still take time for the people affected by the discrimination to simply relax and transcend it all. i would certainly not expect, not even today, that a black person be all reconciliatory with someone supporting an interracial marriage ban... it just doesn't work that way.

and, no offense, but try to consider what it would like to be to walk in my shoes. it is very easy to give advice to other people about how they should handle such problems, but it can easily come across as condescending. all of us in the LGBT community think about and discuss these things A LOT. and what we won so far, we fought for it our way, in a way that we found to work.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by moron4hire on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:51AM (#7515093)
Freedom of expression only works if we allow for and extend it to expression we find distasteful. That's the entire point of the 1st Amendment. There is no use for it otherwise.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by zimpenfish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:05AM (#7515171)
Except the 1st Amendment already has limits on freedom of expression for things that people find distasteful, does it not?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_excep...

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by zimpenfish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:01AM (#7514713)
There's a reasonable difference between being the CTO (responsible for technical direction) and CEO (responsible for all direction including, presumably, inclusivity of staff) though.
Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by moron4hire on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:05AM (#7514733)
I'm presuming Eich identifies as religious, some form of Christian to guess. Regardless, if he isn't, it doesn't matter to the principle. Any CEO who is has to "check at the door" his views on the religions of the world to work as the CEO at Mozilla, where there are undoubtedly many Muslims, Jews, and Athiests (not to exclude any religions, just naming the top four). If we can't expect Eich to leave his views about gay marriage behind, then how can we expect any CEO of any religion to be respectful of his employees and customers of differing religion?

No, I do not recognize your assertion that there is a "reasonable" difference.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by zimpenfish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @07:14AM (#7514754)
If you don't see the difference between being CTO and being CEO, we have a fundamental baseline disagreement that we're not going to resolve by arguing about the rest of it.

I think promoting him was a mistake; you don't. Such is life.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by moron4hire on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @08:46AM (#7515073)
It's not like we're talking about David Green at Hobby Lobby here. In any of these discussions I've read, nobody has suggested that Eich has worked to mold Mozilla into his personal political or religious vision.

Green--on the other hand--is actively trying to tell his employees how to use their compensation given for the work they've done for him. Would Green reach into his employee's pockets and take out greenbacks if he knew they were being used to buy condoms and booze? The proposition is more likely than Eich discriminating against gays in his role at Mozilla.

If Eich has actively discriminated against employees at Mozilla, then yeah, he needs to be kicked out. Show me where that has happened. But what he does in his private life (that he didn't advertise, which makes this an excellent case study in the need for privacy-even-for-legal-activities) has no bearing.

Re:Jwz and Brendan Eich discuss the origins of JavaScript (2... by zimpenfish on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @09:01AM (#7515144)
Eich hasn't had much of a chance to be discriminating yet - that's a big difference between being CTO and being CEO.

But the fact that he's mentioning places like Indonesia and their anti-gay-marriage stance as a bolstering rationale worries me. Then again, I have very little skin in this game.

And no, we're not talking about whatever Mr Hobby Lobby does - because that's wholly irrelevant to this discussion about Eich and Mozilla.