News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by DigitalSea on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:26PM (#7505782)
The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World authors website then proceeds to crumble because of traffic HN brings to said article. The irony is too much to bear. Is this an April Fools joke or is the article serious?

This is equivalent of saying, "The rise of organic farming is bad for non-organic farmers" or "The rise of solar panels is bad for the petroleum industry" or "Reddit is bad for Chrome and Firefox because it competes with bookmarks" it's all highly subjective and biased — it's hard to take articles that essentially say X is bad because of Y or I hate X because of Y seriously, especially when they don't even make a valid argument or back up their claims with an ounce of credible and non-biased evidence.

If it weren't for Hacker News I honestly wouldn't know what is going on half the time. You can't get the type of news and useful resources you come across on a daily basis on HN anywhere else in my opinion. /r/programming on Reddit might come close, but HN to me is always the penultimate resource for tech news relating to not only programming but investment, startups and other industries I wouldn't generally go searching for like biotech, medical research and other various areas of tech you would normally have to read several sites on to get.

Plus, you can't deny Show HN is also a great way for people to showcase cool things they've made as well. I've come across some great projects and resources in the years I've been using the site via Show HN alone.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by peterashford on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:40PM (#7505833)
HN is very useful, I don't think the author was denying that. The point he was making was that there is no community oversight into how HN works - which is important when it comes down to effectively censoring people's speech.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by pcmonk on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:13PM (#7505738)
Don't make accusations of favoritism without any shred of evidence. This post is completely unfounded except for a couple of anecdotes.

I think most people here realize that the content here is not simply whatever gets the most upvotes, there are fairly complicated rules and penalties that get applied (many of them automatically). If you want democracy, there are plenty of other venues for it. The value in HN is that the quality of content is high, and the moderation is a large reason for that.

I challenge you to show me another site that has as good a combination of quality articles and quality comments. I'm sure improvements can be made, and if you're paying any attention you'll note that improvements are being made (see the recent publication of the name of the main moderator so that we can ask him questions).

What HN is doing works. If you've got a better idea, show it to me.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by joelrunyon on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:29PM (#7505788)
I was surprised he called out jl. I thought she was being conscious about the fact that she's "thin-skinned" and going to avoid areas that might be sensitive & OP turned it into a "she might get vengeful one day" negative.

OP needs to give HN some credit. Building a good site is harder. Building a good community is harder. Until TechStars or someone comparable comes up with an alternative, complaining that one company decided to fill a niche that wasn't being filled seems really lame (it's not like HN is proactively squashing any other startup sites). People are here because it's the best tech news resource around.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by kzahel on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:32PM (#7505802)
I think lobste.rs has the right approach in at least being more transparent about moderation: https://lobste.rs/moderations
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by peterashford on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:41PM (#7505838)
Yes - clearly that is more visible and open for community comment
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by joelrunyon on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:11PM (#7505731)
> We need something better. Go forth and make it happen.

I'm always amazed by blog posts that say "xyz sucks" - someone should fix it and then offers no practical next steps to do so.

Complaining is easy. If you really want to change something - if it's important enough to you - then fix it.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by motbob on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:16PM (#7505750)
When a community is involved, it's not that simple. A slightly better Hacker News, released tomorrow, would not succeed. People wouldn't migrate. Seems to me that unless some catastrophe befalls HN, such as blatant mod abuse or chronic technical outages, nothing will replace it. At least for a while.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by joelrunyon on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:56PM (#7505894)
Maybe that's because it's doing a pretty good job at the moment?
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by null_ptr on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:19PM (#7505761)
> The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World

> 504 Gateway Time-out

Agreed, its appetite for destroying small web servers is unquenchable.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by vinchuco on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:26PM (#7505781)
irony is fun, not necessarily constructive

Link to cached article: http://bit.ly/O9W3qd

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by Aloha on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:23PM (#7505772)
Slashdot effect all over again
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by dang on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:49PM (#7505871)
Since someone's going to ask, this post fell in rank and eventually was killed because users flagged it. We didn't touch it in any way.

More generally, the truth is that we go out of our way to avoid censoring stories connected to YC. That was the very first thing that PG told me about HN moderation.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by bvrlt on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:34PM (#7505815)
The bad news for the Tech World is when people think Hacker News/Silicon Valley is the Tech World. There are 1000s of small companies and people who are part of the tech world, have never heard of Hacker News and are doing well. HN is just one community and it's serving its community well.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by Aloha on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:21PM (#7505977)
There are many things that could be considered wrong with HN - the stuff he is complaining about, IMO - are not really important - HN for the most part serves the interests of the community in which is operates.

That said, there are things that irritate the hell out of me about the community; banality, lack of relevance in posts, lack of clear context in posts.

To expand - the posts that I consider banal - 'New framework for X' or 'Blan, a X for Y.' - Relevance Posts, the post that was about the libertarian police force that briefly surfaced on the front page today - Context Posts that require you to know all about the subject before you can understand the posts content (the one about the game jam, or the one about keybase.io) in most cases I've never heard of whatever it is that they are posting about, and I need to try to glean context from the post - which is often missing.

I don't begrudge the above, its as much a part of the local flavor as anything else is - so I accept it as a part of being in one of the best places to get interesting tech news on the net.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by nichochar on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:24PM (#7505774)
I feel like there should be a "website is down" button. That would indeed improve HN. Thanks for the practical help!
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by harrystone on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:53PM (#7505886)
I've only known about HN for a few weeks so maybe this has all been covered before. But as an outsider looking in, it seems like an awful lot of time and effort has been expended to try to make internet comments into something they're not. If you don't want comments, just don't accept comments.

There is no algorithm that's going to change human nature. Sorry.

Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by peterashford on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:38PM (#7505830)
I love HN for the content. But I do find it ironic that people who value openness are content to have the control of people's speech to be done in private and without oversight from the community being controlled. Especially when there's no a priori reason to trust the body doing the controlling.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by ezrameanshelp on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:34PM (#7505814)
The part I thought was interesting: "If I vote down a story that you voted up, your vote should count less in my rankings of stories. And vice versa. The same holds for comments."
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by araftery on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:54PM (#7505890)
Yeah that caught my attention too. Personally, I really don't want my HN to be different from anyone else's. I come to HN not only to see stories that will interest me, but also to see what's captivating the community as a whole right now.
Re:The Rise of Hacker News Is Bad News for the Tech World by undoware on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:25PM (#7505777)
I just wish more industries had an HN.