The world would be vastly poorer if we limited every game mechanic to a single game that was allowed to express it. Can you imagine shutting down FPS clones after Wolfenstein 3D, or RTS clones after Dune? Despite not doing so, these categories are immensely profitable for game creators.
If Threes is so simple and so easily cloned then I would like to know two things:
1. Why do they deserve to profit from it and nobody else is?
2. How does giving the creators of Threes more money help produce more fun games with simple mechanics that are simple to make and easily cloned?
It is possible to limit boring clones while retaining a vibrant software market.
This is not a question of who deserves what. This is a matter of building a great software market for games, so that we can all play great mobile games at reasonable prices.
I'd also like to know how any restrictions are supposed to work, since 2048 was implemented as an HTML5 game that plays great on mobile.
As for the HTML 5 game, that's a different matter entirely. The Apple App Store is human-curated, so I can reasonably expect curation to promote useful behavior. I cannot demand that from the web.
Regarding the HTML5 game, I don't see how it's a different matter at all. My point is that you can access things beyond the App Store, and when it comes to small, casual games like this, HTML5 is a great platform. In fact, I wasn't even aware that there was a native version of 2048 on the App Store until I read this article. If you can't demand curation from the web, and if the web is a viable competitor in this space, then how can you demand curation in this space?
2048 wasn't a unique new game mechanic, it was a just free clone of the game that invented the mechanic.