I agree with you that it is ultimately not the most appropriate. However, for many people it is a big improvement over suffering alone and without help.
And in our world, the things that really can heal emotional problems -- psychotherapy, meditation, spiritual practice, hypnotherapy, therapeutic bodywork, breathwork, psychedelic therapy, etc. etc. etc. -- are much too "woo woo" for most people. They're too scary, or short of that, people's belief systems don't admit the possibility that such things can work.
Taking a drug, though, is something familiar to people. And the drugs do help people live with their problems, though not as well as the drug manufacturers would suggest. The unfortunate thing, though, is that people get the message that all they need to do is find the right drug and dosage. The drug can help them stabilize their lives, but then they need to start in on the emotional work. That's what can eventually get them to where they don't need the drug.
Mental illness's are disorders, that can be disabling to normal daily life. Our society accepting that things like OCD, Anxiety/Depression and Addition are diseases will allow us to actually address them. Your brain is not a magical thing that is beyond being ill, unfortunately it is extremely complex. I say this as someone who has been "sucking it up" for years until I finally hit a point that I sought help for depression.
http://www.hhs.gov/asl/testify/2010/06/t20100623a.html https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_depressive_disorder
Or you know, it will allow us to "invent" them, because we have drugs to sell, and because we have the luxury to overanalyse every whim.
You mince it up with nice words around the edges, but it boils down to this: you're part of the problem.
See strep throat for a counter example (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Streptococcal_pharyngitis). There's a five point diagnosis checklist that looks a bit similar to checklists you might see in the DSM for a mental illness. But there's also a gold standard test of actually culturing the cells, which is 90-95% accurate at diagnosing strep.
It may be just my ignorance, but I don't see comparably accurate tests for diagnosing mental illness. It's extremely common to see someone's diagnosis change over months or years from depression to bipolar to something else. This tends to undermine the scientific credibility of mental illness diagnosis, leading people to wonder how much diagnoses are influenced by fashions, drug companies, or the practitioner's whim.
Ninja edit: For the counter counter example, see the Rosenhan experiment (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rosenhan_experiment). There are huge confirmation bias problems in mental illness diagnosis.
Another problem with diagnosis: some illnesses haw a list of (say) 9 things, and the patient must match 5 of them for 6 months. So the patient is a good match of 3 and a weak match for 2 and a poor match for the other 4. But anyone seeing that patient will read the diagnosis and will apply all the criteria to everything the patient does. "You would say that. People with your diagnosis are {manipulative}" (even if the patient was a poor match for manipulative).
If that makes me part of the problem, I guess it's not clear to me what the problem is.
Imagine a friend is lying in bed and refuses to get up and go to work.
Let's go through some scenarios: 1) His pelvis is broken from a recent car accident. 2) He has a fever and fatigue from the flu. 3) He has testicular cancer and is recovering from yesterday's chemo. 4) He is depressed.
These scenarios are all fundamentally different. It's common for people to have sympathy in scenarios 1, 2, & 3: "Of course you can't get out of bed, poor fella'. Anything I can do to help?" It's common for people to be skeptical and annoyed by scenario 4: "Why won't you just get out of bed? What is wrong with you? Jesus, go for a walk or something. You need to get your act together."
These responses are caricatures, but they represent "the problem" that often results from people saying they believe "mental illness is fundamentally different." Mental illness is not identical to other illnesses, but to the sufferer, it is just as real and just as debilitating. The problem is that people treat it as less real – not a disease but more of a personal failing that needs to be overcome. You wouldn't tell a cancer patient to just get over it, but for many types of mental illness that is society's attitude.
Does that clarify anything?
Of course, because we understand how cancer works, enough to know that wishing it away, or meditating, is unlikely to address the problem, and has not been scientifically demonstrated to fight cancer.
There's a spectrum of severity and causes of mental illness. In some cases a patient needs to be medicated just to be able to get through a therapy session; in slightly less severe cases therapy can be tried first, but perhaps without medication the patient will never be normal. In a lot of cases, I think probably the majority, patients on psychotropic drugs could improve well into the normal range through therapy alone without meds. And there are cases where a particular social environment—like a middle class urban lifestyle, trying to make ends meet—may cause certain psychological disorders even when the same people in a different environment would be perfectly happy. Especially in that latter case, can that be called a "disease"?
If psychological intervention or environmental change is enough to turn someone normal, what does it mean to label them "diseased" before the intervention... particularly if the "disease" was due to bad prior psychosocial development (bad parenting and/or bad school/peer environments, generally), rather than genetics or something in the air or water? In other words, if the same person had grown up in a different social environment, or in a different culture, and failed to develop the psychological illness, can it be called a disease or illness at all?
(Of course, availability of professional therapy, or peers or parents who know how to intervene productively, may not exist in many cases. That's a separate issue.)
Psychiatry does not really distinguish the forms of psychological disease based on their likely cause, nor on whether they can be treated to acceptable norms without medication. I think that's what frustrates a lot of people who either object to, or are uncomfortable labeling DSM diagnoses as illnesses or diseases.
I've met people who had severe OCD but who had their life changed by talking therapy. I have no problem calling it a disease.
This mentality that its not a physical ailment literally has caused numerous suicides, spousal abuse, violent episodes, etc...
All completely avoidable if they were medicated and treated.
Thinking of mental disorders as fundamentally different leads people to fear seeking out treatment, which is the real problem.
However, people with your belief structure make it stigmatic to seek treatment, because they, like you believe that "its just in their head" that its just a "subjective experience".
The very idea that "its something wrong with you" as opposed to "being ill" is what makes people fear treatment. Very helpful and real scientific treatment for their ailments.
You are literally The Problem!
You're also misunderstanding the role that treatments for mental illness play. Psychoanalysis, meditation, medication, many of our current treatments for many mental illnesses do not cure you. Neither do most of the drugs we use for other, infectious diseases. It's akin to taking cough syrup when you have a cold; it just masks the symptoms until the disease goes away. Valtrax doesn't cure herpes, it just pushes it down and out of the way so the sufferer can live a more normal life. Cutting out cancer doesn't necessarily cure you of it.
The entire notion of "cure" is specious to begin with. There aren't any magic potions you can drink that restore your HP and get you back into battle. The only thing that makes sense to talk about is treatment. Treatment varies between all diseases, all patients, and over time for that patient.
For me, getting enough sleep, eating well, and staying hydrated properly are all parts of my treatment for depression and anxiety. They don't cure. I can have a bummed out day where I don't want to get out of bed even if I've been taking care of myself perfectly, just the same as I can still get a cold if I'm washing my hands religiously. But if I don't keep up with taking care of myself, it happens significantly more often.
The problem is that there are people who are suffering who could be treated and they are not seeking treatment because of social stigmas around treatment.
This is medical science. Its really not up for debate. If you are really questioning the entire field of medical science and the vast corpus of research on mental illness, the only people who will take you seriously are lay-persons.
And thats precisely the problem. While I trust you mean well, attitudes like yours are extremely dangerous because they increase stigma and disuade people from seeking medical help for treatable illnesses.
It's true that yes, biochemically, the brain's abnormal activity often correlates with subjective experience. But a) the subjective nature of the condition is what makes it so damn tricky and b) we don't know what's causing what. It could easily be the case that an individual (organism) in a bad (social) environment leads to a biochemically abnormal brain state. Treating the brain state is like playing whack-a-mole. There could also be complex feedback loops. We don't know. We're throwing shit at the wall right now.
Though there is good evidence for the basic nervous system strengthening properties of SSRI's, there's also very compelling evidence that SSRI's have absolutely zero impact in credible, controlled studies. From my personal experience and observations, I believe SSRI's can be good at 'stopping the bleeding', which sits well with why they are often known for having a dampening effect. But that will only get you so far, because there's no set way of determining what 'cured' is. There's no such thing as normal in the same way that it's normal to be free of strep throat. Functioning and succeeding in society has positive qualities, but can sometimes be at the expense of individualized growth and healthiness.
The point is, mental life is really complicated, and possibly wrapped up in broader, deeper things like spirituality, love, and economic and social conditions. Your bio-reductionist view (which isn't an insult, it's simply the view of much of the middle to upper middle class) doesn't match reality in my experience. I've found that most people suffer deeply with modern conditions (the less neurotic they are, the less they're aware of the causes of their malcontent) because there are fewer sources of authority, purpose, or truth. A la carte medicine and treatments won't solve that.
Besides all that, the drug industry just stinks of hypocrisy and deserves its popular skepticism. If a sufferer is to experiment with drug treatments, ayahuasca (and similar) should be legal and just as available as XYZ SSRI's.
Chicken Pox and alcoholism are both diseases. Seriously.
So if there's some "thing" that creates a mental health problem you'd call it an illness, but otherwise you'd call it, well, what?
That space of what to call it is problematic. Some people fill that gap with judgemental terms - sloth, laziness, weakness, etc.
And I'm not sure why you think treating MH problems as an illness is a bad thing - what are the negative consequences of doing so?
Grief is a normal reaction to death of a loved one.
Sadness for no reason, that persists for weeks or months or years, that interferes with your ability to live your day to day life is not normal.
Talking therapies help most people. Medications help some of the rest. For extreme cases ECT (electro convulsive therapy) might help. There are other extreme interventions being looked at such as vagus nerve stimulation.
Leaving people to experience these feelings of hopelessness because we do not want to interfere with their right to be depressed means some of them will die by suicide; or by neglect or alcoholism; and many of these people will not live their life to anywhere near their potential.
J.G. Ballard wrote a short story where psychiatry had been outlawed to prevent people having their rights to honest emotion interfered with. (I can't remember what it's called but it's good!)
Your response to this guy owning up to something taboo is to chide him on his use of terminology? What kind of priorities do you have, and why is you being right on the Internet ahead of respecting the vulnerable?
Some (most?), like OCD and BPD have extremely specific symptomatologies that are often counter intuitive and quite surprising similarities between people. The generalized, lay-person, conceptions of these illness miss these specific symptoms.
As such it doesn't make sense to call them anything but diseases.
"Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity."
At the same time, I don't think he is ill. While I don't doubt that he is suffering, I don't think it it is helpful to class his suffering as an illness. I don't think anyone argues that his symptoms are caused by an infection or a defect in an organ, so his disorder lacks the physical basis for a typical illness. At the same time, he has symptoms. And therapy, and possibly drugs, make him feel subjectively better. He chooses to engage in a regime of therapy which (presumably) has self reported benefits.
But I don't think it is helpful to think of his plight like we think of malaria or polio or heart disease. When we talk about 'emotional disorders', we implicitly take on an enormous amount of cultural context as well as normative judgements about how someone 'should' feel. And the danger is that one will come to believe that an unpleasant mental state in an otherwise healthy brain is something to be cured through the application of science.
That being said, I agree with the main point -- that there is no shame in his mental state. I suppose my point is that it is not necessary (and should not be necessary) to reclassify what a disease is in order for a class of people to maintain their dignity. And above all, I wish this man well and by no means mean to diminish his pain, or the courage it took to write this.