News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by datr on Thursday March 27, 2014 @12:20PM (#7481357)
Is Tarsnap going to drop prices in response to the AWS S3 drop?
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by cperciva on Thursday March 27, 2014 @02:45PM (#7482466)
I've been busy with bitcoin for the past few days -- I need to crunch some numbers on my AWS bills to see how much money this saves me; it's not as obvious as it sounds once GET/PUT costs and EC2 costs (which are mostly reserved instances, thus not affected by this price cut) are factored in.

But my first guess is that a price cut is very likely to be coming. ;-)

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by icelancer on Thursday March 27, 2014 @02:56PM (#7482544)
Please don't. Just pocket the margin. The prices should have gone up, anyway.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by patio11 on Friday March 28, 2014 @07:15AM (#7486431)
In addition to raising prices, please implement recurring payments as soon as reasonably practical.

This is what happens when one's pre-paid Tarsnap balance goes to zero:

You will be sent an email when your account balance falls below 7 days worth of storage costs warning you that you should probably add more money to your account soon. If your account balance falls below zero, you will lose access to Tarsnap, an email will be sent to inform you of this, and a 7 day countdown will start; if your account balance is still below zero after 7 days, it will be deleted along with the data you have stored.

I was N days from hitting a the 7 day warning, so 14+N days away from hitting "Lose all my business' backups for the last several years." It is possible that I would have gotten really lucky and seen those emails (which I was, by definition, not particularly expecting) rather than, oh, being on a business trip in April and finding about them after the fact.

I cannot put enough underlines under I Would Consider Losing All My Backups A Failure Mode.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by wheels on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:50PM (#7482949)
This is something that's repeated here, but I have a feeling mostly by folks that are backing up small amounts of mostly static data.

Even after de-duplication and compression, my company stores about 400 GB of data with Tarsnap. Tarsnap is a double digit percentage of our monthly infrastructure costs.

I think, perhaps, it's rather that the value that a business backing up a 30 MB database every day gets isn't radically different from the value that we get backing up several orders of magnitude more than that.

The question really is if straight utility pricing makes sense. I could imagine that a floor on the pricing, or a non-linear curve would probably do better than simply keeping the same model and raising the prices. There's also a question of distribution of total revenue -- if the revenue for the small accounts was increased by 10x, would it balance out a 50% loss of large accounts?

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by cperciva on Thursday March 27, 2014 @05:51PM (#7483766)
There's also a question of distribution of total revenue -- if the revenue for the small accounts was increased by 10x, would it balance out a 50% loss of large accounts?

No. You wouldn't be far off if you assumed that 100% of Tarsnap's revenue came from large accounts.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by runeks on Friday March 28, 2014 @06:10AM (#7486229)
> The question really is if straight utility pricing makes sense. I could imagine that a floor on the pricing, or a non-linear curve would probably do better than simply keeping the same model and raising the prices.

The question is if the costs of running tarsnap correlate exactly with the amount of data that is stored, or if the number of users also have to be factored into the equation, ie. if each additional user has an added cost. I would say that in a business like this, with a low barrier to entry, the price should reflect the costs as close as possible. So if there's a constant setup cost for each user, the price shouldn't be $X/GB, but $X/GB + $Y.

Ideally, Tarsnap should make the same amount of money from a single user storing 100 TB and 100×10^12 users store a single byte. If this is not the case, the pricing structure is suboptimal.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by computer on Friday March 28, 2014 @06:19AM (#7486254)
Suboptimal in what way? I doubt that would be optimal for profit.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by skrause on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:07PM (#7482626)
Why?
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by gburt on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:21PM (#7482734)
Tarsnap is extremely low cost as it is for the service it offers.

Edit: in most HNers opinion.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by geoffc on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:44PM (#7482908)
Agreed! I use a lot of Saas services and tarsnap is insanely cheap for the value it provides.

While I'm at it, a feature I would love to see in tarsnap is server side pruning of old archives so I can remove the delete permissions from my production keys and not have to setup a secondary pruning server.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by cperciva on Thursday March 27, 2014 @05:43PM (#7483716)
server side pruning of old archives

That's not possible -- the service doesn't know which old blocks are being reused in new archives.

Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by blairbeckwith on Thursday March 27, 2014 @12:24PM (#7481387)
Gosh, I hope not. If anything, they should raise their prices.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by sexmonad on Thursday March 27, 2014 @02:01PM (#7482053)
This is my question too. Tarsnap is cool, and Colin deserves to get paid for his hard work, but the cost differential is far too much for me to use tarsnap right now. If they cut their costs in half, I'd be able to afford to use them over raw S3.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by spindritf on Thursday March 27, 2014 @02:32PM (#7482351)
Tarsnap's deduplication makes it even cheaper than it would seem. Considering what you're buying, Tarsnap is already ridiculously underpriced.
Re:Tarsnap now accepts Bitcoin by wmf on Thursday March 27, 2014 @03:38PM (#7482850)
Is tarsnap's dedupe any better than bup or obnam? The competition has not stood still since tarsnap came out.