News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by derefr on Friday August 07, 2009 @12:15AM (#746978)
I don't think Lisp being opaque has anything to do with your ability to learn a particular PL such as Common Lisp, Scheme, Arc or Clojure. Rather, opacity is usually a term levied at a syntax, when it makes it hard to understand what the underlying semantics of the program are. Lisp has the least "syntax" of any programming language I know of, so if it's opaque to you (e.g., you can't take a guess at what "(+ 2 3)" means), you probably shouldn't be programming.
Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by copenja on Friday August 07, 2009 @04:50AM (#747309)
I don't understand the following point you made:

"so if it's opaque to you...,you probably shouldn't be programming"

So your saying that someone should not program if they haven't learned basic lisp ( 5 )?

Or are you suggesting that there should be some time limit... like if you program for X months but don't understand it you are forced to quit.

But.. further... What is the purpose of forcing these people to quit?

And.. What is the purpose of belittling these people?

Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by derefr on Friday August 07, 2009 @05:06AM (#747319)
I'm not talking about learning programming. The reference in the article was to people that already were programmers.

To put it another way: if you call yourself a programmer, and sell your skills as a programmer, but can't mentally decompose "(+ 2 3)" into an AST (basically the first, and easiest, step to understanding), even after Lisp's general syntax is explained to you, then you aren't actually a programmer.

Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by copenja on Friday August 07, 2009 @05:23AM (#747335)
Above, you said whether they could guess it, not whether they could understand it after explained.

"you can't take a guess at what "(+ 2 3)" means"

I can see your meaning if it was explained to someone and they still didn't grok it. But I would still kinda feel like encouraging them.

Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by copenja on Friday August 07, 2009 @05:14AM (#747332)
Nevermind this.. Posted under the wrong thread.
Re:Signs that you're a bad programmer by rjurney on Friday August 07, 2009 @12:21AM (#746991)
I see. Its not literally opaque - I got that far in the book, but I can't follow a real program's execution.