"Ayn Rand supporter" is the new "communist sympathizer" or "pinko."
are you better off if I give you $1k no string attached or $1k specifying down to the cent how you are to use it?
Generally speaking people know what their needs are and how to balance them more than complete strangers or even, often, friends. Yes, people have weaknesses, but to try to rule over their weaknesses is highly paternalistic and demeaning. Moreover because of the fungibility of money, in the end often the person will find a way to spend an equivalent batch of the same money in the way they would have anyways.
I would classify that as someone else spending money on you, with the superficial detail that the money happened to pass through your bank account.
It's not as black and white as you guys put it. Strings can exist, but how much they control you can vary greatly.
I agree with you that it isn't black and white. (This is simply a semantic argument.)
I've never read an Ayn Rand novel, yet I still agree with that statement. I guess if you call someone an Ayn Rand supporter, that is supposed to discredit them? It's a pretty basic economic principle. If you take $10000 from your bank account, you are less likely to impulsively purchase a new car than if someone walked up to your house and gave you $10000. Seriously, it's super simple, and has nothing to do with Ayn Rand.
> If people were so rational, everyone would go to college because the expected value of college still dwarfs the cost of college.
Many people get off fine without college. You are touting your preferences as the only "rational" set of preferences. There is more to life than the "expected value of college."