News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by jacquesm on Thursday August 06, 2009 @09:42AM (#745413)
Oh the irony. For years people have wondered how they could curb the power of Murdoch, now he does it all by himself.

Bring it on, I would like to suggest $10 / article as a starting price, then increase the price to maintain revenues on a monthly basis.

I give it a maximum of three months before he'll come to his senses.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by chez17 on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:05AM (#745456)
I'm not sure about that. I think thinks like the WSJ will suffer greatly but his big audience, the Fox News crowd, will pay to get that slop they call news. The Fox News/Noecon relationship is a lifestyle now, not just a political idea. I can see a lot of those people paying for the one news source that they have based their reality on.
Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by DannoHung on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:09AM (#745465)
Actually, I think the opposite is true. People reading the WSJ find the news contained there within valuable enough to pay for it. People reading Fox News just need something to make them angry, of which there are hundreds if not thousands of acceptable sites ready and willing to to provide sufficient rage material for free.
Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by chez17 on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:28AM (#745508)
>People reading the WSJ find the news contained there within valuable enough to pay for it.

I would disagree. I think that the people who would pay for the WSJ are already paying for it. I don't see why people who aren't paying for it now would start paying for it when there are so many other free news sites out there. Maybe they could hook up some subscribers with devices like Kindle, but I think the people who are currently browsing it for free will not see the value in paying for it. Just a thought.

>People reading Fox News just need something to make them angry, of which there are hundreds if not thousands of acceptable sites ready and willing to to provide sufficient rage material for free.

Good point. I don't know the level of dedication to Fox people like this have. Maybe they won't pay for it, maybe they'll go to who ever screams about gays and socialism the loudest.

Back to my original point, is there really that much information the WSJ has that other organizations don't? Couldn't your second argument apply to directly to counter your first?

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by DannoHung on Thursday August 06, 2009 @11:18AM (#745645)
Well, there's the Financial Times, but they already have a paywall.

Bloggers don't have as much clout in finance as they do elsewhere. Mainly because there are more security guards to kick them out and it costs a lot more to get into industry events. Also, if you're an insider and you blog the wrong thing, you can lose your job and get arrested.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by jacquesm on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:20AM (#745492)
Exactly. The last audience you want to target with a for-pay news site is the Fox News audience.
Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by CalmQuiet on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:57AM (#745587)
Yes. You can find gossip everywhere online.

And news that requires no actual research/journalism can_be/is replicated everywhere - and without Murdoch's overhead.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by matt1 on Thursday August 06, 2009 @09:52AM (#745430)
Don't you think they have spent a lot of time thinking this through, consulting with experts, and debating internally whether its been a good decsion? At least I hope they did.

If there's a chance they could successfully pull off a system where visitors pay a few cents for a quality article, why wouldn't it make sense for them to do it?

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by jacquesm on Thursday August 06, 2009 @09:58AM (#745444)
Because they're panicking.

Their business model is under threat from 'free' stuff and so their response is to do what worked in the past, close the gates and set up a toll booth. Only this time it won't work, there are 100's of little side roads now, and you no longer have to use the 'main' road to get the news you are looking for.

People used to be 'loyal' to their newspapers, that's why the payments rolled in. That loyalty is very low, as long as the writing is good I really don't care whether I'm reading my stuff in German, French, English or Dutch and from what newspaper or other outlet it comes. So many choices, it's a delight. The AP feed relaying to fill the newspapers was a clever idea to save some money at the time but in the long term it backfired, it meant that there was less reporting in general, not that the reporters that were freed up were used to go digging.

It's only a matter of time before google or some other large party will hire a bunch of reporters directly and gets them to make the missing element (quality editorial content) and with the trouble at the regular newspapers I'm thinking that it will be a buyers market when they do.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by nir on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:21AM (#745494)
WSJ charges for articles, seems to be working ok for them. Same with the New Yorker and IIRC Financial Times(?). I wouldn't be quick to dismiss this option.

As for the Google Times option, I think it'll bring about more problems than solutions. You don't build a quality newspaper by "hiring a bunch of reporters". There's a lot of accumulated knowledge in places like the NYT or WSJ. What we see from the web - from leading "reporters" investing in the field they're supposedly covering to opinion pieces by Jenny McCarthy and Jim Carrey - is far from encouraging.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by halostatue on Thursday August 06, 2009 @11:10AM (#745624)
WSJ and FT are specialized news and analysis that cannot be obtained elsewhere. Unless everyone in the newspaper industry starts charging all at once, the pay walls for other news sites will effectively go away.

IMO, this sort of thing is ultimately inevitable, and I don't think that the Internet is the ultimate cause (it's an accelerant, at best) -- I think that it's been getting harder for newspapers to compete with the depth of coverage provided "for free"* by television news organizations.

* When's the last time you paid a bill to CNBC or CNN? I don't pay an explicit bill for CBC Newsworld -- it's included in my cable package.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by nir on Thursday August 06, 2009 @12:03PM (#745742)
David Simon recently urged the NYT and WP to start charging, at the same time: http://www.cjr.org/feature/build_the_wall_1.php?page=all

The cable model is interesting. Perhaps such sites could work out deals with ISPs - you'd pay a few more bucks each month and in return get free account on WSJ, NYT etc.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by jacquesm on Thursday August 06, 2009 @12:09PM (#745758)
The 'at the same time' is telling. That's collusion.

AFAIK that is an excellent way to get into trouble with the law, and if it isn't then it should be.

You are supposed to come up with your price independently and without 'backtalk' in the boardroom.

If two gas stations get caught doing this they'll end up in serious trouble, I don't see why it should be any different when you're running newspapers.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by nir on Thursday August 06, 2009 @12:21PM (#745777)
Yeah, he's aware of that.. "And when the Justice Department lawyers arrive, briefcases in hand, to ask why America’s two national newspapers did these things in concert [..] you can answer directly: We never talked. Not a word. We read some rant in the Columbia Journalism Review that made the paywall argument. Blame the messenger."

Check out the article - it's the same guy who created The Wire, he's not a bad writer :)

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by jacquesm on Thursday August 06, 2009 @01:36PM (#745966)
To tell two people to collude does not give them any right to do so claiming there was no communication between them, effectively there was. They both could check if the other party was holding up their end of the deal on their respective websites. I highly doubt a judge would fall for it.

It's clever though, that's for sure. But like most typical layman attempts at 'hacking' the court system it would probably fail. Judges are not nearly as stupid as people seem to take for granted.

Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by nir on Thursday August 06, 2009 @03:34PM (#746222)
Sure, he's not really serious about that. But I think it's not improbable that many publications will start charging around the same time. The competition factor is overrated, IMHO - people who really want to read the Times will pay even when the Post is free, just as raising the print price to $2 increased revenues even though it's freely available online.
Re:Murdoch signals end of free news by quoderat on Thursday August 06, 2009 @10:37AM (#745534)
"Don't you think they have spent a lot of time thinking this through, consulting with experts, and debating internally whether its been a good decsion?"

Having worked at a few large companies, it's more likely that some executive got scared, hired a few toadies to tell him what he wanted to hear, then put in place a "plan" that he'd already decided and that is doomed to failure.

That's the way it works most places.