News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by rayiner on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:14AM (#7453620)
In don't think "zero sum game" means what you think it means. Lots of people in San Francisco engage in transactions, and lots of people in New York engage in reducing transaction costs. Neither are "zero sum" endeavors. Insurance is a great example. My office used to sit in the shadow of the Met-Life building. They don't make anything, so they must be zero sum. Wrong. Insurance enables transactions to happen that wouldn't otherwise happen, adding value to the economy. That's the crux of many of New York's economic sectors: finance, advertising, insurance, law, consulting. Its abstract, and service oriented rather than product oriented, but its not zero sum.

Now one can argue about the amount of value created by these industries, or rather how much of the value created is absorbed by the industries themselves. You can also question how much value is created by yet another web app getting funded in SV, so I don't know if you're on firm ground there.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wpietri on Sunday March 23, 2014 @04:49PM (#7455091)
Having worked in finance, I can promise you that a lot of people in finance are playing zero-sum games. All trading is basically zero sum. No trader goes home saying, "Hey, honey, I imperceptably increased global liquidity today; yay me!" They say things like, "I'm fucking awesome. I gutted those chumps in the LIBOR pit. Whores for everybody!" [1]

Anybody working for those people is also essentially playing a zero-sum game, in that their activity is just aiding in shifting value from one pocket to another. Which is why I no longer work in finance; I wanted to do something useful.

[1] Yes, I have actually heard traders say "Whores for everybody!" in the office. At least in the office they were joking.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by dennisgorelik on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:30PM (#7456169)
Even if some traders think that they are playing zero-sum game - it does not mean that traders actually play zero-sum game.

Benefit of trading is increased liquidity.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by wpietri on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:43PM (#7456410)
It matters entirely for the psychology of the industry's culture.

However, increased liquidity is of no direct value. It only matters if people get better prices, or get deals closed significantly sooner. For a trader's participation to be positive sum, the benefit of their capital has to be larger than the costs they impose. Given that every trader is working to make the opposite true, surely many of them are negative sum. Especially given that capital can be deployed to reduce liquidity just as well as increase it.

Re:Why San Francisco Is Not New York by cwp on Sunday March 23, 2014 @11:47AM (#7453725)
Sure, finance is valuable, up to a point. We reached that point about 100 years ago. Since then, the geniuses of Wall Street have been figuring out how to capture more of the value created by other people. That's a zero sum game.