Broad elevator-pitch-level ideas may well be of little value, but specific ideas about strategy for a given organization at a given time are hugely valuable. There is a significant difference betwen the ideas person who just spouts out 'x for y' type product ideas, and the ideas person who is always coming up more effective processes for getting work done and achieving goals.
Even those specific ideas have value only speculatively; specific case hypotheses are more easily testable, but they only have value, only provide benefit, when results of execution are realized.
That's the point, isn't it? Truly good ideas are rare.
(a-priori: for some reason I can't reply directly to you)
It's not quite a "no true Scotsman" since great ideas do happen and happen fairly often, in the grand scheme of things (there are over 100 Nobel prize nominees every year). The oft-repeated argument about ideas versus execution is that ideas are a dime a dozen, which is true, but most of them are not really all that great or original. The same can be said for any resource.
We're treading dangerously close to "no true Scotsman" territory here.
Only in that some intrinsically good ideas are fairly obvious. Others are not.
Re:Why I Never Hire Brilliant Men (1924)
by valarauca1 on Friday March 21, 2014 @01:42PM
(#7443576)
No True Scotsman's ideas are unique. /sarcasm
Even ideas as earth shaking and complex as Infinitesimal Calculus and Quantum Mechanics were developed in parallel initial by people with little to no communication between each other.