What is the alternative? Yes we are NOT all equal. Some of us are more rational and intelligent than others. But how would you go about determining one's intellectual and moral worthiness? (Education? IQ?) And who gets to decide the criteria for superiority?
If you were as smart as you think you are...you would have considered these issues before making such a shockingly elitist statement.
My original comment was to point out that "Democracy" is not some perfect utopia that every country should strive for.
Also, I can't tell if you're being facetious or if you truly believe we would be better of with dictatorships...because there are plenty of real-world examples to choose from and they're quite horrible.
YES - that's exactly what should happen. Your "political degree" gives you no right to decide for other people what's good for them. If I like my leaders to have nice eyes, then I am entitled to my vote just as you are entitled to yours based on your "political degree" nonsense that I don't care about. You don't get to decide if having nice eyes is important or not. If enough people think it's important - then it is important by definition.
Shop floor assistant at an Apple store gets the same say as the VP legal, about whether or not to sue someone for trademark infringement? One person one vote! yay democracy.
> If enough people think it's important - then it is important by definition.
Your logic is bad. If enough people think that vacinations cause autism, does that make it true? The majority is often wrong.
In a representative democracy, a clerk in the social security office doesn't have the same authority and scope of power in the day to day operation of government as the Attorney-General. They both have the same say in, say, electing a member of Congress, just as shop floor assistant and a corporate VP who both had equal holdings in the relevant company's stock on things that go to votes of the shareholders.
> > If enough people think it's important - then it is important by definition.
> Your logic is bad. If enough people think that vacinations cause autism, does that make it true?
Your logic is bad. You draw a false equivalence between a matter of objective fact (causality) and a matter of subjective preference (importance). The two are not parallel.
That's the point - in that logic, the amount of votes you get in a democracy would be tied to how much land you own. Which IMHO seems a probably better way to do things.
No, land is something you own subordinate to the nation, not an equity stake in the nation.
Though the idea that the problem with our government is that its not plutocratic enough is, well, amusing.
I have a Political Science degree, and I see no reason why this would be a problem. Could you clarify why you think this should not be the case?
Citizens of a country run by representative democracy are like equal-equity shareholders in a corporation.
> You wouldn't give a checkout assistant the same say in a company as the CEO.
You would in things done by vote of the shareholders if they were each equal in that regard. Of course, those kind of things are mostly (1) ratifying or rejecting certain major decisions proposed by other equal members or by management (like the initiative/referendum process in many US states and some national governments) and (2) choosing the board of director and certain officers (like the proces of normal elections in most representative governments.)
Which covers, pretty much, the things done by elections in most representative governments. So, no, I don't think the difference you claim is at all valid.