News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by jobu on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @10:47AM (#7428927)
Looking at the parts list I see the largest cost is the 2x 40-port SATA cards (aside from the drives). I wonder why they didn't decide to reduce the number of drives to 40 so they could just use one SATA card and save $688?
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by atYevP on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:18AM (#7429188)
Yev from Backblaze here -> Density is key! Our biggest need is to fit as much data as possible on each pod for as little price. The cost difference between removing 1 SATA card or removing 5 drives is negligible, but the added drives at another 20TB to the pod.
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by dpe82 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:45AM (#7429430)
Why not use a smaller card (or the motherboard's controller) for the last 5 drives?
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by atYevP on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:52AM (#7429482)
We're constantly tweaking the design, that might pop up in the future!
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by darkarmani on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:58AM (#7429540)
If density is your biggest issue, why don't you boot from USB and fit a 46th drive in there using the boot drive? Does that put you over heat or power budgets?
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by fragmede on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:59AM (#7429552)
or network/pxe boot
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by budmang on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:21AM (#7429221)
That's an interesting idea. We considered trying to get rid of the extra card by mounting 5 drives either on the motherboard or on another card (and hope to experiment with these paths in the future.)
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by jccooper on Thursday March 20, 2014 @11:10AM (#7435978)
Rack space is an ongoing cost while the hardware is a fixed cost. Presumably they've decided it's worth having a slightly higher fixed cost per GB in exchange for a reduced ongoing cost per GB. (There's probably other benefits as well, such as reduced workload and just getting the space online now.)

Let's take a look...

They do have an oldish post on hosting costs: http://blog.backblaze.com/2011/07/20/petabytes-on-a-budget-v...

A rack in 2011 cost them $2,100 per month (it's more now, guaranteed). Their racks look to hold about 11 machines. Each pod is then about $191/mo.

Each rack thus needs 1.375 extra pods at "low density". That's $262.50 a month. Since you now need about 10% more pods, you're paying about $29 more in hosting costs per month per pod.

Your savings are not $688, since you also need to construct 1/8 pod later. A low-density pod will cost about $2719, with is $340 split 8 ways. So real hardware savings is $348. Hosting costs eat that in exactly a year, and they are certainly expecting a longer life than that. (That's 2011 hosting costs, which are certainly lower.)

So it's worthwhile to spend a little extra for the additional drives. (Of course, if they could get the extra five in with more modest hardware, as seems quite possible, that would be a sure win. But sometimes ease of development/assembly/spare parts wins over hardware cost.)

Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by Vvector on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:54AM (#7429500)
That was my first thought. But the math backs them up. You lose 12% capacity per chassis. But you only save 7% per chassis ($688 off of $9305). So they would end up paying more for extra pods just to get the same storage. This doesn't include the rack space cost.
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by dcuthbertson on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @12:40PM (#7429866)
Nitpick: In addition to the savings of $688 for the SATA card, you also have to include a savings of about $1400 for the five 4TB drives that won't be included. That bumps the savings on the pod to just over 22%.

Still, at least 12% extra rack and floor space to get the same storage capacity would probably cost them more in the long run.

Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by greedo on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @01:19PM (#7430233)
In the article, they say the average cost of their 4TB drives is $160, so the savings from removing the five drives would only be $900, not $1400.
[deleted]
Re:Storage Pod 4.0: Direct Wire Drives – Faster, Simpler and... by kgermino on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @11:15AM (#7429155)
It's worth noting they only put 45 drives in the box so that extra $700 only gets you a 12.5% storage gain. However I suspect that splitting the drives between the two increases read/write performance and reliability as well.