An electrician is usually licensed, which means they are above a certain, fairly low bar. The average person is far more concerned with avoiding the worst electricians. Beyond that price is the biggest factor and the electricians are interchangeable. Give me the best price for soy that isn't rotten.
In coding jobs, employers are trying to identify the best, worst, etc. You can argue against this as a test of quality & qualities, but the net effect is not commoditization.
It identifies the most needy/desperate engineers.
Anyway, I for sure would not sign up for such a thing, it tells me the recruitment agency or potential employee views software engineering as "typing code skills", like hacker-typer.com. In my opinion a software engineer works more closely to the business and requirements elicitation than just implementation.
Like to me speed does matter, someone unusually fast at coming up with a solution would definitely get my upvote.
At least its an interesting idea to explain this growth in recruitment agencies and skype-interviews.
Big IT consultancies are probably your best allies in this campaign. They would definitely appreciate being able to order their rate cards for coders,licensed programmers & certified master programmers at different rates. They would also be glad to be on the certification and licensing committees. The shoddier schools would also be on board. "Recognized certification courses" has a nice ring to it.
Recruiters would also love it.
I agree that if homeowners are the judge, they might do something like speed of splicing a wire, or maybe wiring an electrical outlet, because that is all they know. However, we're talking about electricians being judged by other electricians in this situation. It's up to the sr. electrician to know what a quality electrician is and judge that effectively. If the sr. or hiring electrician cannot do so, you don't want to work for him/her anyway.
This tool is relatively meaningless without qualified people observing. If you threw them some code tests that were merely timed, I would agree with you.
Granted, this does not ensure that the electrician you hire won't screw up, but it at least provides some baseline of competency.
How fast you write code or how much code you write does not equal a good programmer.
I doubt licensed electricians remained licensed for long if they don't know the difference between hot and neutral wires.
Plenty of programmers have 2 year certificates or none at all.
That being said, I'd consider programming to be a 'creative' profession in many ways...
Imagine if you wanted to hire an electrician, but before you let them into your house, you ask to follow around to see them connect and cut wires? Then you would judge their skills by how fast they can cut and put back together a wire. Thats the level that this "screen sharing, watch him code" does.
Is this field that much hammered by pretends?
"Top coder" is repulsive.