Let's say Johnny wants to be a doctor more than anything in the world. He knows that he needs two semesters of Organic Chemistry on his transcript to get in to med school, and that if his grades aren't top notch he won't be able to compete. Johnny likes his Chem prof (and the grading is fair), but he's only managing B-'s on his exams. He sees his dream fading away. Sure, he could say, "Huh. I guess I'm not cut out to be a doctor." But don't you think some students out there would consider cheating under those circumstances?
Or maybe Johnny consciously chose to go to a college that has a strong culture of giving students a "well-rounded" education (by whatever internal definition) and insists that students take a wide variety of classes from different disciplines. That's not Johnny's cup of tea: he just wants a computing degree. He could easily have chosen a different school, but he didn't. Now he just wants to focus on his CS classes, so when he's stuck with a course in English or History he decides to cheat so he doesn't have to think about it. Do you really want to say that's the teacher's fault?
He has no intention of applying the knowledge he would have attained in the classes he cheated on.
Every student should be allowed to choose his own classes with as little requirements imposed by the school as possible.
That's not to say there couldn't be a list of recommendations preferably with an explanation why for students that have no idea what to take but forcing them is a bad idea.
Stop wasting students time with useless classes just so you can have a standard set of classes for each field.
But, thinking further, I do not really understand how the evaluation is done.
What does that A grade really means? It means he has a grasp of what benzene is, or that I can hire him for doing my syntheses?
The system is very broken. I hope one day we'll have some serious D&D-like rules in our instruction:
MD:
Org Chem >8
Surgery >14
Int >16
Char >14
OrgChemist:
Org Chem >18
Surgery >4
Int >15
Char > 3While it may be true that if classes were more interesting then cheating would be reduced slightly, that doesn't make it the problem. Similarly, if content creators didn't want any money for their content then piracy would be reduced. But it's pretty obvious that's not a realistic solution.
Calling it a service problem just enables the entitled attitude of pirates and cheaters (you aren't giving me exactly what I want for the price I want, so I'm just going to take it.)
There are classes that are important or required, but may be boring. You think that in life, you will love every single hour of whatever job you end up with? No, of course not. That doesn't entitle you to cheat your way through those classes anymore than you could skip shitty days at work.
Have you taught? I'm pretty miffed at the idea that you think professors should take students that cheat as their own failing.
I can assure you that most professors invest considerable time in trying to make the material interesting, relevant, accessible, etc. And even if they fail, or the course is an "irrelevant" required course, that does not justify cheating.
I do not, but my wife does. She is a professor of English and she relates stories to me of her classes daily. One thing that helps her classes is that she always explains why they need to learn something, and she never introduces a lesson that doesn't further her own learning outcomes that she has set up (for intro classes she structures such that students are ready for her upper level courses, and for those courses she structures such that students will be able to succeed not only in English but also in other areas as well).
One thing that's very common (check out the CCCC literature on the subject, and as a matter of fact my wife is presenting there this week) is trying to find ways to ignite student engagement. You have thousands of extremely bright people who expend countless hours simply trying to figure out how to make students care. That to me does not point to a failure of teachers. And on that let me recount my own college experience:
I was a shitty student for undergrad. I didn't go to class, I didn't do the reading, I didn't do the work, and I failed all the tests. And this isn't just for classes I dislikes, it was for all of them. There was no specific reason for it though my wife and I were broke the whole time, but really that's just an excuse I told myself. And so eventually I brought my GPA up from a .5 to a 2.6 so that I could graduate (it was very fucking hard to do that, the system is stacked against you mathematically). Then I decided to go to graduate school and I kicked ass and took names. I don't know what changed but I became "the surprise star of the class" (professor's words) multiple times and when I graduated I had a 3.9 (only because by the end I had 3 full time jobs as well as taking a full course load, so I phoned in a final assignment that was worth a huge chunk of my GPA in one class).
In all of those cases it had nothing to do with my professors. They were kind, entertaining, generous with their time, and worked very hard to try to keep me engaged. The turn around came when I decided to take ownership of my education and of my career afterwards.
Yep, and I guarantee you that unless she is teaching only electives she has students who would rather not have to take her class.
I was a professor of Physics for a decade.
I worked hard at it, was considered excellent and lively and all the good stuff. I also did what your wife does. Yet, there are students who didn't want to be there, pure and simple.
Sometimes it takes a little wisdom imparted by time to know what you should like, and many students don't have that maturity yet.
I hope everyone can find things to do in life that they love. But with anything, there are always going to be things you hate: changing diapers as a parent, some "boring" courses as a student, dealing with cheaters as a teacher...
Attitudes that completely disregard integrity will completely destroy the value of online degrees. It's a shame.
Then later when you have a boss who is looking over your shoulder at every step to make sure that you're not trying to get away with something... guess who is going to be complaining about trust?
For instance my degree is completely useless just because i have it from a different country.
Luckily that never prevented me from doing what i like regardless.
I might actually bother to take the time get the same degree in the country i currently live in but that's not because that piece of paper has any value it's just because I always enjoyed learning new things.
IMHO the real issue is that degrees are considered signals for employers - that blows up their value to much, much more than "just" the value of the courses added together.
This is true, but only for certain subjects. I largely agree with you when it comes to many Comp-Sci courses. Differential Equations, not so much.
Cheating in academia is exactly the same as piracy: It is a service problem. If classes taught useful information/skills in a non-boring way, cheating would be significantly reduced.
It takes a special kind of myopic/arrogant person to find out that students are cheating on their exams and think that the problem has nothing to do with them.