My sense is the end game should be encouraging long term research where there is a decent enough chance for success relative to the gains from it - the chances are hard to determine but somewhat based on the idea, and the team chasing it. Essentially this is a VC model for ideas that are too far out to generate attractive returns.
Require Journals to Publish the first 2 studies that try and reproduce a given result. Note: Publish need not mean include in the paper copy's just indexed and searchable online. This let's you create a reproducibility index which might not mean much until they have done a fair bit of research but still something there going to keep in mind.
Funding agency's would need to set aside a large amount to validate any study. However, as there is a lot of null results that the percentage is probably not all that high. More importantly as not doing so means the results are practically worthless in the first place it's still a good idea even if it takes 1/2 the overall budget.
Ideally you want a lot of incremental research(easy), using other peoples data (cheap), and showing something novel(fame lottery). While most of this is practically useless it still gets published because there are plenty of Journals and they all need to publish something every month.
That's not to say people are not still doing high quality research but rather the signal to noise ratio often low for a reason.