This has to do with the publishing process itself, and the poor peer review (closed, sloppy, even for "respectable" journals) of the current publishing system. Science nowadays generates large amounts of knowledge, not all of which is useful, but we lack even rudimentary tools to catalog and analyze that information.
Very few people have suggested ways to catalog science in ways that are useful to inform future research[1,2].
[1] http://www.kurzweilai.net/new-tools-to-manage-information-ov...
[2] http://www.silvalab.com.cnchost.com/silvapapers/S2Neuron2013...
However, I fail to see how "research maps" would improve our way to catalog and analyze information. What is shown in your ref [1] is a regulatory network. These models have been used for years to drive research into diseases ranging from cancer to neurodegenerative diseases. And, there is (at least in the biomedical sciences) a very vibrant community dedicated to that very job, the "bio-curators" [http://www.biocurator.org/] that directly or indirectly fill (relational) bio-repositories. "Research maps" like STRING, Reactome, PIR, BioCyc, or KEGG, to name a few, have been around for quite a while, too. So I think the claim in [1] that Silva has "invented" "research maps" is a quite some PR exaggeration, as this can be simply described as a "Reactome limited to Neuroscientists only".
You sometimes ask yourself: Would the public continue throwing their taxes at scientific research if they knew that most of their cash is just consumed to fuel the egos of professors?
Ideally you want a lot of incremental research(easy), using other peoples data (cheap), and showing something novel(fame lottery). While most of this is practically useless it still gets published because there are plenty of Journals and they all need to publish something every month.
That's not to say people are not still doing high quality research but rather the signal to noise ratio often low for a reason.
My sense is the end game should be encouraging long term research where there is a decent enough chance for success relative to the gains from it - the chances are hard to determine but somewhat based on the idea, and the team chasing it. Essentially this is a VC model for ideas that are too far out to generate attractive returns.
Require Journals to Publish the first 2 studies that try and reproduce a given result. Note: Publish need not mean include in the paper copy's just indexed and searchable online. This let's you create a reproducibility index which might not mean much until they have done a fair bit of research but still something there going to keep in mind.
Funding agency's would need to set aside a large amount to validate any study. However, as there is a lot of null results that the percentage is probably not all that high. More importantly as not doing so means the results are practically worthless in the first place it's still a good idea even if it takes 1/2 the overall budget.
Not most science, it looks like. Most science gives us false insights into the world, reenforcing our prejudices and the sales of dubious products.
>and of course births incredible technology.
Or at least it once did. We're at the end of riding Moore's law, which confused us into thinking that science was progressing, when it was just transistor density that was progressing.
But it might be worth it to take a step back and recognize what a brilliant process science is. After all, even with such waste, such bias, and such low rates of reproduction, science still gives us amazing insights into the world, enriches our understanding of the universe and our place in it, and of course births incredible technology. Through fraud exists, though scientists are flawed humans, though funding agencies can be so conservative or wrong-headed—still, science chugs along. It's so robust, so powerful, and yet so simple!
It's truly amazing to live in our world.