Re:Show HN: A new platform for meaningful, balanced debates
by anilgulecha on Friday March 14, 2014 @06:40AM
(#7397890)
I think it was a long time ago that I discussed a similar tool with friends (essentially a way of mapping out an argument, and listing out premises/arguments/conclusions). The feedback I got most often:
"Yeah that would be cool, but that feels like a chore, and I wouldn't really use it".
I wish sawsay the best of luck, and some points to perhaps keep in mind:
- Make the platform fun. This is going make or break the service -- at-least for popular use.
- Spend a lot of time iterating/evolving the UX so what is essentially a hard task, is broken naturally into very simple parts.
This is relevant, because it seems that the system you propose would make presuppositions very explicit, which would help people with different presuppositions to realize why they are disagreeing instead of just yelling at each other till they go hoarse. It sounds like a very cool system, and I'd love to see it in action.