News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by ekianjo on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:09AM (#7390407)
> * On February 22nd, aircraft 9M-MRO underwent maintenance. During this, or during a previous maintenance cycle, an empty oxygen bottle was installed by mistake for a full one, or a valve was jammed, or some other undetected fault rendered the flight deck crew's emergency oxygen supply inoperable.

That sounds extremely unlikely. Standard procedures for equipment checks in plane are usually done at 9 sigma standards, i.e. they involved numerous checks by different people. We're not talking about an amateur doing maintenance at home during the weekend. And I doubt there would be a single oxygen source in the cockpit since airplanes are usually built with multiple redundancies.

I don't really buy that one. Plus the plane did not make it to any military radar either - so where did it fly for 5 hours?

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by nostrademons on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:28AM (#7390455)
The other thing to consider is that there are roughly 90,000 flights/day and 365 days in a year, so even if such an event has a probability of 1 in a billion (that's roughly 9 9s reliability), you'd expect it to happen once every 30 years on average. Extremely unlikely events become plausible when large numbers are involved.
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:35AM (#7390470)
You're showing one botched flight deck O2 tank per 30 years? That's how I read it but I may be wrong.

What are the odds that that one botched O2 tank happens to be on a flight with high altitude decompression?

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by akiselev on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:38AM (#7390637)
If the cause of the accident is in any way related to "human error" instead of unpredictable failure (unpredictable as in photons causing a bit flip that can't be caught in error correction, not something like a part with a 15 year life span being used for 20), chances are that error is the result of an institutional problem. With 90,000 flights a day I can imagine plenty of people making mistakes during maintenance and flight checks because they're tired, having trouble with at home with the family, etc. but that's why we have so many levels of review and confirmation, checking to make sure it all goes according to plan. If the airline (the asset/floor managers specifically) don't enforce a culture that takes safety and aircraft operation seriously, no amount of reviewers will help them and when things fall apart, they do so in spades.

It's not really a question of "what's the chance that this will break in 30 years." It's a question of the part's function, the added complexity/failure points it adds to the design, and the chances that the added complexity will exacerbate flaws in management when it all goes haywire.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by ekianjo on Thursday March 13, 2014 @11:06PM (#7396743)
> I can imagine plenty of people making mistakes during maintenance and flight checks because they're tired, having trouble with at home with the family, etc. but that's why we have so many levels of review and confirmation, checking to make sure it all goes according to plan. If the airline (the asset/floor managers specifically) don't enforce a culture that takes safety and aircraft operation seriously, no amount of reviewers will help them and when things fall apart, they do so in spades.

If that was really the case, planes would be failing every single day and air crashes would be as common as train wrecks and car accidents. It's far from being the case, so it says a lot as to how reliable planes are made to be, and how serious the maintenance is done on planes. Besides, companies have no incentive to skip on safety checks because they know a crash would have immediate, and serious impact on their image and direct sales of tickets.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by mseebach on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:17AM (#7390742)
I don't think the 9-sigma is calculated per operation cycle, I think it's per maintenance cycle which are from a few times a year to every 5 years, depending on the type.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aircraft_maintenance_checks

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by Blahah on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:18AM (#7390423)
He does reference the case of Helios Airways Flight 522[0], where a similar situation happened as a result of human error (leaving the pressurisation system set to manual).

0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helios_Airways_Flight_522

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by mootothemax on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:44AM (#7390502)
He does reference the case of Helios Airways Flight 522[0], where a similar situation happened as a result of human error (leaving the pressurisation system set to manual).

Plus, it's possible that the pilots had too much faith in the "9 sigma" system, hence misinterpreting the numerous warnings the aircraft gave them.

Numbers prove us wrong every day.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by ekianjo on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:23AM (#7390444)
This was not the same place (737 is damn old in design, from the 70s, 777 was designed in the 90s), this was not an international flight (security standards for international flights are stricter), so I'm not sure he even tries to compare both of them. Why not reference a Cessna incident as well ?
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by mootothemax on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:49AM (#7390517)
Edit: deleted hostile, snarky content.
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by hueving on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:51AM (#7390673)
>Can you explain which one it is?

Did it cross your mind that it could be a combination of them? Drop the accusatory tone when you don't understand the content.

International flights have higher standards due to extended distances from emergency landing sites. An old plane is not exempt from the check standards, but the age certainly means that there is an increased probability of failures.

>If so, at what airframe age, or travel standard, or aircraft size does that kick in?

Again, sarcasm is really unhelpful when it's just a result of you lashing out at a comment you didn't understand.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by mootothemax on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:21AM (#7390752)
Did it cross your mind that it could be a combination of them? Drop the accusatory tone when you don't understand the content.

Do you not see the irony in writing an accusatory reply to me? ;-)

To your main point, I understand the content; I do, however, resent people boldly stating "that can't happen, it's too unlikely," only to then say "Oh, right, yeah, if you exclude old planes, domestic flights and blah blah blah blah blah."

I do concede that it would be more helpful if I was less of an arse about it though.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by wilg on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:37AM (#7390631)
I think you're being unfairly hostile and snarky here. This isn't a good way to get your point across.
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by mootothemax on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:22AM (#7390755)
I think you're being unfairly hostile and snarky here. This isn't a good way to get your point across.

Thanks for calling me out on that, you're right.

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by WalterBright on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:45AM (#7390656)
The 737 entered service in 1968.
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by jonah on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:24AM (#7390446)
Do we know for a fact that it disappeared from military radar?

Also, how low of an altitude would it have to fly to avoid radar? Maybe they dropped down to a thousand feet and changed course?

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by ekianjo on Thursday March 13, 2014 @03:42AM (#7390497)
> Do we know for a fact that it disappeared from military radar?

We only know what we are told, when it comes from military sources...

Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by alexeisadeski3 on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:04AM (#7390563)
This is in contrast to non-military sources, wherein we know even what we are not told?
Re:Missing Airplane Flew On for Hours by evan_ on Thursday March 13, 2014 @04:14AM (#7390582)
This is in contrast to sources which make information readily known, or may be compelled by courts or the public to make information known.