News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by JulianMorrison on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:18AM (#7385717)
Revolution is a tool of limited usefulness, and violent ones very often put something back in that is just as bad as what they ejected (see also: the KGB).
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by bananas on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:24AM (#7385759)
It's more complicated than that.

   ----->[ good times ]---->[ hard times ] ---> [fascism] --\
      ^                                                     |
      \-------------------[revolution] <--------------------/
Revolution merely starts the cycle again. We'll always end up with the KGB, Stasi, NSA, GCHQ, CIA etc so you have to deconstruct society regularly to flush it out.

We're stuck in a pretty long loop at the moment just verging on hard times.

Edit: the "good times" above is optional.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:36AM (#7385838)
Luckily, our founding fathers built in a way to achieve the same effects as a revolution without any violence.

If you were to start an armed insurrection, the government would be totally justified in ending you. Not a smart decision given today's level of technology. It was through sheer luck that the American revolution worked at all: the British commanders were so incredibly incompetent that they checkmated themselves.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by CodeMage on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:41PM (#7386675)
Hasn't there been enough evidence that the system the founding fathers built in has been compromised to the point of irrelevance?

What you have today is an illusion of the freedom and the "equal and impartial justice under the law".

http://www.popehat.com/2013/12/23/burn-the-fucking-system-to...

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by a3n on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:25PM (#7387692)
You're probably right. I think the Feinstein/CIA spying episode currently unfolding shows that the intelligence services have flipped the fuckit bit, and they don't even try to make it look like they're subject to Congressional oversight. They do still say they're subject, which I guess is something; they just don't try hard anymore to hide what they do.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by whatevsbro on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @06:21PM (#7388787)
> They do still say they're subject, which I guess is something

Nope, it's meaningless. What else are they going to say?

"It's exactly what it looks like! We just don't give a fuck about you or your rights, and in fact, we're an important part of the police state springing up all around you. When you're thinking of rebelling, remember we know where you live, where you are, and pretty much everything else about you! Stay in line, peasant!"

That would be fairly accurate, but they're not going to say it. Doesn't the propaganda just keep going anyway, even in North-Korea?

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Houshalter on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:35AM (#7390796)
No, there isn't. Democracy might not be great, but it is orders of magnitude better than not-democracy. The main function of democracy is to keep true tyrants out of power, and it's very effective at that.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by collyw on Thursday March 13, 2014 @08:46AM (#7391389)
I would call the system in UK, US more of an elected dictatorship than a democracy, as the politicians are not representing anyone other than their corporate buddies.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by coldtea on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @02:56PM (#7387516)
>I, for one, continue to be excited about our drone overlords.

Genuine question: why do hackers and obviously smart persons believe in this cargo-cult "founding fathers" concept? As if some guidelines set by some 18th century guys are the be all end all in running a state or even mean much after centuries of "interpretation" and changing conditions (including technology).

Case in point 1: most of the things people now enjoy, from women's voting to the abolishment of child labor, to work safety laws, to the end of seggregation, were achieved by long, hard, struggles, protests and even martyrs (just like in Europe, for example), and not by some "founding fathers" decree.

Case in point 2: an armed population then was a major counterbalance against a corrupt government, being effective almost at the same level as the government's forces (as evident in tons of revolutions and stuggles around Europe for example). Today? Not so much. So this naive belief on the "right to bear guns" for this purpose is mostly BS cargo-cult.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Crito on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:29PM (#7387711)
One of the values of a constitutional democracy is supposed to be that it reduces the impact of the "tyranny of the majority". That is to say, that it reduces the likelihood that a simple majority of people will trivially be able to oppress minority populations. This works by setting up a base set of rules that cannot be violated even if a majority of people in the democracy want to. In order to change or amend these rules, a much higher bar must be met.

However this idea of restrictions placed on a democracy to keep the majority from oppressing minorities is worthless without actual rules. How do you perform the initial population of this set of specially privileged rules then?

Think of it like a problem of bootstrapping trust. A pure democracy cannot be trusted (as a pure democracy trivially allows/enables the oppression of minorities), but non-pure democracies must be conceived and implemented somehow. Can you trust a constitutional democracy that was created by a pure democracy? Arguably no, since the pure democracy cannot be trusted. Can you trust a constitutional democracy that was created by a small set of arbitrary people? Again arguably no, since arbitrary people pulled from the general population wouldn't be any more trustworthy than a pure democracy. Can you trust a constitutional democracy created by a small set of particular people? If you trust those particular people, then perhaps you can trust the constitutional democracy created by them.

People want to trust their government, which leads to them wanting to trust in broad terms the general concepts and ideas that this particular founding group had.

Personally I think it's all shit. A constitutional democracy does not resolve the tyranny of the masses, it only pretends to. Democracy itself is nothing more than "might makes right" combined with a primitive notion of MAD (with anarchy and civil war being the boogieman, rather than nuclear war). Constitutional democracy is good for little more than lying to ourselves to make ourselves feel better about democracy.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Noted on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:49PM (#7388626)
Since you seem to have thought about this quite a bit, do you happen to know something you think works better?
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Crito on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @07:55PM (#7389231)
There are a few interesting proposals that I've heard over the years, but to answer your question truthfully, no. I've grown to accept that this isn't a situation I can resolve, only a situation I can hope to survive.

I view the current situation as not unlike being locked in a hotel room. In the main room is a hungry tiger. In the bathroom, is a pissed off cobra. You're locked in there so you have to pick your poison, but the last thing you want to do is mistake "the worst choice, but better than the alternative" with a satisfactory situation. I don't have a better suggestion than democracies, but that sure as hell doesn't mean that I trust democracies. I'll sleep with the cobra (with one eye open), but I sure as hell won't praise the merits of sleeping with a cobra just because that tiger looks hungry.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by stalcottsmith on Thursday March 13, 2014 @12:05AM (#7389997)
I think belief in the "founding fathers" comes down to a faith in systems design or the idea that there exists in theory a system which some sufficiently brilliant folks may devise which addresses the enduring human problem of "how do we all live together and get along" in some optimal way. The American system bequeathed to us by the so called founding fathers and refined over more than two centuries was an experiment that its participants and sponsors have largely portrayed as ideal, or at least flawed but superior to others, and always improving.

When a "geek" or systemically-thinking person wakes up politically, having realized that much is going deeply wrong, the first thing he or she is likely to do is to consult the founding documents which most of us were taught in civics class or for our various merit badges comprise the guide and inspiration for our civil governance. Seeing obvious departures from the design, it is not hard to seize onto the idea that to correct things we merely need to return to the design and follow the rules. Indeed that might improve things.

The difficulty of the various struggles to implement substantial changes is hardly an indictment of the system laid out by the founding fathers. Conservatism is the rule. It is wise to temper the passions of the people for radical changes which they may press to address temporary needs. The ultimate success of campaigns to extend suffrage, abolish child labor, end slavery and segregation, and even to rollback prohibition testify to the effectiveness of the system devised. It presumably worked as intended in those instances. It failed to prevent a war between the states, the death of 600,000 men, and much other injustice in more recent times.

One can find much wisdom and value in the writings, thinking and dialog that went on at the founding of the United States and surely a measure of nonsense too. It seems clear however leaders of that time sought to grapple with the problems of governance and cooperation sincerely and with a great deal of intellect and ability. They treated these issues as matters of vital importance in a way that seems quaint and removed from our decadent era -- that is unless you live in one of the many countries lacking material comforts, safety and political stability.

The problems they sought to address have not changed much since then. Human beings are what they are, technology not withstanding.

America is and remains an experiment on many levels. Ben Franklin's remark coming out of the constitutional convention about "A republic, madam, if you can keep it" is relevant today. This surveillance business could be the end of it. So could imperial overstretch and fiscal profligacy precipitating a collapse. Its also possible that the very different demographics of the country two and a half centuries after its founding render it simply ungovernable in the way or fashion imagined by the founders.

With particular regard to the Constitution and its merits, I believe I paraphrase Lysander Spooner in saying, it either has failed to prevent tyranny or in fact provides for it. If it is so, then the verdict would be the same either way. I am not certain I have better proposition but I do not have a blind faith that in order to cure our ills all we need to do is exhibit greater fidelity to the Constitution.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No_Treason

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by bananas on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:43AM (#7385866)
Firstly, your "founding fathers" - ha now there's a joke. Do you think anyone respects those amendments? Nope. If they thought that, you wouldn't be stocked up with weapons.

And we all know how effective that technology is at ending all those pesky terrorists with their zip guns and IEDs...

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by diydsp on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:54AM (#7386348)
Don't be defeatist.

A key problem I see, that I used to have, and learned from my mistake, is that the checks and balances system works.

Yes, you see the executive branch overstepping its bounds. Lots of people getting picked up. However, the judicial branch is finding the charges untenable.

It's not easy nor automatic, and costs a lot of time and research and arguing, but those amendments are still pretty damn strong. Arguments directly to them are handled in the Supreme Court all the time.

There are some dings against the 4th as of late, but don't give up and invest the time and research and arguments. Put your focus on the judicial branch and increase their power to put down bad behavior by the executive branch.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by killerpopiller on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @05:21PM (#7388486)
..you mean realist?

also, Brennan was sworn in on the consitutions without the bill of rights

http://www.theguardian.com/world/us-news-blog/2013/mar/08/jo...

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:50AM (#7385903)
And we all know how effective that technology is at ending all those pesky terrorists with their zip guns and IEDs...

Those people have been indoctrinated since birth to see us as evil invaders. Some of their religions have baked in the idea that it's good to die in order to kill invaders. And we've sometimes acted like an evil invader. (See Blackwater atrocities, etc.) It's an invalid comparison because our population isn't motivated in the same way.

It's easy to become disheartened with the current state of affairs, but history has shown that ignoring reality doesn't work. Setting aside the question of ethics, the reality is that an armed revolution in America probably can't happen. And besides, there are plenty of other options to explore.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by ds9 on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:44PM (#7386692)
"Those people have been indoctrinated since birth to see us as evil invaders ... our population isn't motivated in the same way"

It doesn't take religion or "indoctrination since birth" for people to see an invading army as evil - it just takes an invasion.

If your country were occupied by foreign armies, you might want to fight back too - or at least you shouldn't be surprised if others do.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Zigurd on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @02:01PM (#7387175)
Calling the people who have a beef against us for occupying their country "those people" and thinking they are in any deep way different from us is a big red flag for lack of understanding. That kind of thinking goes a long way toward explaining how we could blow a couple trillion dollars fighting people who haven't got a single aircraft, artillery piece, or armored vehicle.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by a3n on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:32PM (#7387732)
" And we've sometimes acted like an evil invader. (See Blackwater atrocities, etc.)"

Blackwater!? That we were there at all was an invasion based on a lie and a tragedy of convenience. 9/11, strong connection to Afghanistan and a Saudi/Yemen family ... let's invade Iraq! I think we're still searching for the real weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iraq_and_weapons_of_mass_destr...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plame_affair

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by fit2rule on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:10PM (#7386457)
There isn't a time since WW2 when America wasn't viewed as an evil invader. It really depends on whether you've got the business end of a weapon pointed at you or not.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:39AM (#7385845)
Actually its been remarkably effective in other countries, have you been reading the news? Our own soldiers have not been terribly effective at pacifying unrest, and the locals have nothing but rifles etc.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by sillysaurus3 on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:44AM (#7385873)
It's kind of interesting to think about. Remember the hullabaloo just after the Boston bomber lit off the bomb but wasn't caught yet? Imagine all of that societal rage focused on a small group of people who have started an armed conflict and killed a few policemen, and you can imagine how quickly that group will be annihilated.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by unethical_ban on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:16PM (#7386503)
When I think about Dorner or the Boston bombers, I think about how much chaos they caused, and the fact that they evaded regional manhunts for days while accomplishing their goal. To contrast your observation: Imagine what a group of dedicated, intelligent agents could do to stir things up.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by samstave on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:30PM (#7387719)
And now you know exactly why the NSA is doing what it is doing: to protect the oligarchy from exactly an uprising against it from within.

There is no terrorist. The system, the agents of the USG have won the coup on freedom.

They now exist only to preserve their power, and this is the reason why apologists for the deep state are worse than fools

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:46AM (#7385886)
Yeah, you suppose one person - easy to find and contain. But a diffuse population of unrest? Impossible.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by insuffi on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @02:07PM (#7387209)
I'm really, really trying not to be snarky or offensive here, but does anybody else think people using the phrase "founding fathers" sound like a part of a cult?
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by a3n on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:35PM (#7387747)
It's a phrase that we in the US grew up with. It means something in our mythology.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by chris_mahan on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @01:00PM (#7386797)
George Washington was a British commander too, as a Colonel in the British Army.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by samstave on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @03:25PM (#7387688)
We need a tax revolution. Every single citizen should refuse to pay taxes until a rebuild of the system is done.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by gknoy on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @12:57PM (#7386778)
I think you might want to add an intermediate state, of [ Possibly Very Bad Times ] as a possible consequence of revolution before returning to Good Times. It's not a quick fix, not a panacea.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by dllthomas on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:36AM (#7385839)
It should also be noted that revolution sucks majorly.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Houshalter on Thursday March 13, 2014 @05:28AM (#7390779)
I don't know if history supports the assertion that [revolution] leads to [good times]. I mean maybe on average, and maybe in the long run. However it seems to me the suffering the original government caused is dwarfed by the suffering of a violent revolution. Also that things don't improve as much as expected after the revolution, and that it can just end up a worse government, or lead to more conflict.
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by canvia on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @01:05PM (#7386830)
Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by Spooky23 on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:14AM (#7386033)
Bureaucracy survives revolutions, and often flourishes, as the bureaucats know how to get things done and more importantly how to exert control. Security orgs especially.

Consider Mr. Putin's past as an example.

If you work with government, you'll observe this first hand. The second echelons of management that are "professional" staff run the day to day operations, and can often bend or break political directives.

Re:How the NSA Plans to Infect “Millions” of Computers with ... by venomsnake on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @11:26AM (#7386128)
Just a nitpick. It was Cheka(ЧК) and NKVD that were the scary secret police in the bad years of USSR. KGB as an agency didn't exist yet.