Re:Call for acid-bath stem-cell paper to be retracted
by codelap on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:38PM
(#7380809)
I'm not even going to go into why the correlation between influence and retraction rate exists, that should be blatantly obvious to any with a background in any of the sciences. Also, we want retractions, it means science works.
Re:Call for acid-bath stem-cell paper to be retracted
by cjensen on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:59PM
(#7380964)
Retractions are good in when the original paper was the best efforts of its authors. This kind of big-news nonsense paper is far less forgivable.
Re:Call for acid-bath stem-cell paper to be retracted
by pcrh on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @03:34PM
(#7381606)
What I find surprising about this is that the work was apparently conducted by separate groups at Riken, Japan, and Harvard, USA. It would take a fair degree of negligence/incompetence/subterfuge for a basic error such as that proposed to occur (i.e. there were no stem cells produced by this method).
Apparently the paper was in review for 9 months, which suggests at least two back-and-forth discussions between reviewers and authors. If there was that degree of misbehavior suggested, I would probably give the editors and reviewers a pass. Their job is not to detect outright fraud.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3187237/figure/F...