News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:09PM (#7374624)
Users only need that on Android because the OS doesn't manage power consumption of apps adequately.
Re:iOS 7.1 by cheald on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:49PM (#7374901)
It's somewhat disingenuous to say that the OS doesn't manage power consumption adequately; it defers to apps to let them decide what resources they need and when, which permits for a hell of a lot more flexibility than iOS (remember when Pandora wouldn't play music in the background for approximately forever?), at the cost of a misbehaving app chewing up more battery than it should.
Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:54PM (#7374931)
It's not disingenuous at all. What you describe is the user managing power consumption rather than the OS.
Re:iOS 7.1 by cheald on Monday March 10, 2014 @03:17PM (#7375079)
That's incorrect. The OS still does plenty of power consumption management, but it allows apps to tell it when they want the device to stay in a high-power state, because often you need that for legitimate functionality. It also allows the user to be the ultimate arbiter of power management because apps get it wrong sometimes. To conflate "doesn't impose tight restrictions on resource usage" with "doesn't do power consumption management" is silly.
Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @03:36PM (#7375198)
Nope. This a straw man - nobody said android "doesn't do power consumption management".
Re:iOS 7.1 by cheald on Monday March 10, 2014 @03:46PM (#7375249)
The claim was "the OS doesn't manage power consumption of apps adequately". My counterclaim is that it's perfectly adequate (when apps manage their locks well, the OS management of power consumption works just as you'd expect) but that Android simply defers judgement for what is an acceptable lock to the app (and the user) rather than imposing restrictions that save power at the cost of functionality. It uses a cooperative strategy, rather than a restrictive strategy.

If what you meant is "Android allows apps to consume power when iOS wouldn't", then yes, you're right. That's quite a far cry from "Android doesn't manage power consumption adequately".

Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @04:03PM (#7375351)
Sorry, more straw man. You have taken that claim out of context.

Android forces the user to do power management where iOS does it for the user. If the user is involved where they don't have to be, that is inadequate.

Nothing you have said contradicts that.

Re:iOS 7.1 by npizzolato on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:19PM (#7376351)
The stated claim seems entirely in context. And in fact, your restated argument is still rebutted by the post you're replying to. You can't just say "straw man" or "out of context" and then provide no explanation to those claims. Well, obviously you can, because you have been, but it makes your arguments fall flat.

I would restate the grandparent's claim to further argue, but clearly that's an effort in futility.

Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:23PM (#7376371)
It's not rebutted. Nowhere does he address the point that android makes the user manage the power where iOS does not. Instead he simply attempts to reframe the debate into the usual old saw about Apple's approach being restrictive vs Android.

This simply does not rebut the idea that Android is making the user do the work, whereas iOS is doing it for the user. It just tries to make it sound like a good thing rather than a failing.

Re:iOS 7.1 by cheald on Monday March 10, 2014 @07:50PM (#7376483)
Your assertion that Android makes the user manage power is so far off base that it's difficult to speak to. It permits the user do, but neither expects nor demands it. The average Android user has no need or desire to proactively manage their power usage by killing tasks or whatnot. You're tilting at windmills here.

When exactly did you last use an Android device?

Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @09:36PM (#7376883)
What is the value of permitting it if it's unnecessary?
Re:iOS 7.1 by cheald on Monday March 10, 2014 @10:00PM (#7376975)
Surely it hasn't escaped your notice that it's rather par for the course for Android to give users the ability to do things they way they want, whether necessary or not.

Android doesn't presume to dictate acceptable feature sets for applications; as a result, sometimes apps will do things that the user did not expect or want (which may still in fact be a valid feature of the app, or may just be a bug), and then it provides tools to allow users to identify and correct the problem if it is unacceptable for their use case. This is the pathological case, though, and not the norm. The general assumption is that the user's preferences trump the OS's, which is a large part of the reason that so many people like Android to begin with.

Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @03:16PM (#7381507)
Of course it hasn't. You are precisely stating my point.

Android requires the user to do more work because it manages less of the experience itself and offers needless choices.

The reason so many people like Android is because it is cheap, widely available, and can be tailored to the carriers wishes. No serious commentator believes that it's because the majority of people want to manage power consumption manually.

Re:iOS 7.1 by therobotking on Monday March 10, 2014 @05:15PM (#7375737)
His argument is not a straw man and Android does not force the user to do power management, as you claimed. It is an optional.
Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @05:38PM (#7375855)
Optional if you want good battery life, sure.
Re:iOS 7.1 by untog on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:17PM (#7374675)
An iPhone app is capable of sitting in the background tracking your location with battery draining GPS, too.
Re:iOS 7.1 by zimpenfish on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @06:58AM (#7378478)
Location tracking doesn't drain your GPS. I have at least 4 apps running using location tracking on my iPhone (albeit with the help of the M7) and can go 6+ hours only losing 20% of battery life (implying 30 hours of use.)

The key, of course, is that the phone was in my pocket for 95% of those 6 hours. Actually using it drains far more battery than all those location tracking apps combined.

Re:iOS 7.1 by gress on Monday March 10, 2014 @02:21PM (#7374706)
Only navigation apps are allowed to do that.