News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by wldlyinaccurate on Saturday March 08, 2014 @04:47AM (#7364761)
Is it just me or does HN appear to have had an influx of aviation enthusiasts?
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by mschuster91 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @05:06AM (#7364788)
Certainly something different than the daily "my framework foobar is the next successor to angular"-kind of posts. I'm actually happy for a bit of... rather unusual content.

As for the article: it's a pity. The US could fly to the moon with less computer power than a dumbphone, put people in things like the SR71 (how did they actually put enough processing power for all the flight computers in a plane back then?!)... and now?

Space Shuttle's been retired, no near-time replacement. No SR71 (or anything that can be seen as a replacement), and stupid Republican teabaggers caring more about their pockets instead of the population. Seriously, America what's wrong with you?

We Germans needed the Marshall plan after WW2, maybe it's needed the other way round this time...

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by michaelfeathers on Saturday March 08, 2014 @10:39AM (#7365434)
Oddly, I think it's a side effect of the way that technology works. When we humans want to do something we find a way and usually it is extreme and capital intensive. Afterward, we find more economical and less extreme ways of doing it.

The Colosseum in Rome still exists because the only way to do it was to do it in stone and stone lasts forever. Since then we've built millions of arenas that won't last as long because we've used economic forces to develop just-good-enough structure. Likewise, the SR-71 has been replaced by the just-good-enough surveillance satellite.

There's another aspect too. Sometimes we do things just to see that we can. Going to the moon is in that category. If there was a compelling reason to go back we would've. The Concorde, one could argue, was in the same category - we had to have the thrill of taking commercial flight into the supersonic realm, but we found that they economics were such that the thrill of going supersonic and getting there a few hours earlier were not enough to support a market.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by jordanb on Saturday March 08, 2014 @12:02PM (#7365652)
The SR-71 was a hack, where the goal was to use 1960s technology to make an areal camera platform that could photograph targets protected by SAMs.

The original design brief was that it should be a stealth U2, but as the A-12/SR-71 project developed it became clear that that wasn't possible with the technology of the time, but that they could make a platform that flew so fast the SAMs wouldn't have time to lock, launch, and intercept.

There were suborbital spy satellites available before the A-12 even flew: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corona_%28satellite%29

The problem was that the cost of the keyhole program was incredible, you needed a whole launch platform plus a whole recovery mission every time you wanted to take a picture. So the SR-71 was a cost-saving measure versus Keyhole.

Currently the us military can get the information that the SR-71 could provide more easily and with less danger and cost.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by michaelfeathers on Saturday March 08, 2014 @04:51PM (#7366509)
Saw this about a planned successor called the SR-72. I wonder whether it is a serious project?

http://theaviationist.com/2013/11/01/sr-72-unveiled/

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by dragonwriter on Saturday March 08, 2014 @10:47AM (#7365458)
> The SR-71 has been replaced by the just-good-enough surveillance satellite.

Given that the primary motivation for the SR-71 (and, before it, the A-12) was to have a platform wasn't vulnerable to interception like the U-2, I think satellites aren't merely "just good enough", they are far better in that key respect.

They might be worse at "be where we want on demand", but if that's the overriding concern, there's all kinds of other platforms (drones, U-2). The problem with the SR-71 is that it is highly optimized for survivability through speed, but the speed it has doesn't do enough for survivability to be worth the cost given the other alternatives available.

> There's another aspect too. Sometimes we do things just to see that we can. Going to the moon is in the category.

Well, if you ignore the Cold War geopolitical context of the space race, sure, going to the moon was "just to see that we can".

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by dredmorbius on Saturday March 08, 2014 @08:11PM (#7367052)
The Colosseum in Rome still exist

The Colosseum (and much Roman construction) was built with stone but also concrete. The composition of Roman concrete is such that it's much more durable than most modern concrete, due in part to material properties not well understood until recently.

There's also a survivor bias built into structures which have survived the test of time: by definition, what's lasted are the structures which have lasted.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by davidw on Saturday March 08, 2014 @10:19AM (#7365391)
> Certainly something different than the daily "my framework foobar is the next successor to angular"-kind of posts. I'm actually happy for a bit of... rather unusual content.

I'm often extremely critical of off-topic political content, but think that "unusual" content that highlights some interesting bit of the world is great! It definitely fits "intellectually gratifying" far more than politics, or the latest "outrage story".

I'm happy to read well-written articles about things that are new and interesting to me.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by raverbashing on Saturday March 08, 2014 @08:19AM (#7365074)
"how did they actually put enough processing power for all the flight computers in a plane back then?!"

I'm not sure about the SR-71 but not all "computers" (or better, control devices) were digital.

PID controllers are "trivial" in analog electronics (which were already small at that time) as well as other types of controllers.

Several studies on chaotic movement comes from this time, as well as things like this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lyapunov_stability

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by TheLoneWolfling on Saturday March 08, 2014 @01:10PM (#7365835)
> PID controllers are "trivial" in analog electronics

Agreed. A couple of op-amps / capacitors / resistors and there you go.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by keeperofdakeys on Sunday March 09, 2014 @08:04AM (#7368232)
A plane doesn't need flight computers, it just needs control systems that react to inputs. These kinds of systems can be totally mechanical, totally digital, or a mixture of both. In the 60's, many of these systems would have been mechanical, with the digital circuitry operating at a higher level to provide the pilots with operational control.

You also have to remember that many of the cycles on a modern desktop are wasted, dealing with the gui, and lots of abstraction layers. Most embedded control systems are much simpler, and are closer to the baremetal, so they don't need GHz of computing power.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by richardw on Saturday March 08, 2014 @09:08AM (#7365180)
> No SR71 (or anything that can be seen as a replacement)

The SR-72 would be a pretty impressive effort, if realised.

http://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/news/features/2013/sr-72.ht...

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by mschuster91 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @02:19PM (#7366033)
Too bad that thing is unmanned. For sure, it massively reduces the complexity (no life support, no need for high-temperature-stable glass, more agility in flight due to much higher g-force tolerances)... but just imagine flying it!
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by 001sky on Saturday March 08, 2014 @10:25AM (#7365400)
You forgot about the f-35. Oh, wait.

That explains where (alot of) the money went.

That and all that NSA crap.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by dm2 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @06:39AM (#7364928)
Software developers and entrepreneurs like problem solving and advanced technologies. Stories about aviation and other seemingly unrelated topics could spark ideas as to how to improve something or inspire a different way to solve a problem.

Nothing wrong with day-dreaming. Many of us aspire to be like Elon Musk or Richard Branson, and they certainly spent their fair share dreaming about what's possible with the latest technologies.

It's also interesting to get different groups of peoples perspective on different subjects. If you posted this question on multiple sites dedicated to a subset of the population (developers, entrepreneurs, moms, croquet enthusiasts, stock-car racing enthusiasts, sales-people, 5th graders) it would be interesting to see the different responses, and to see how much group-think there would be depending on how the first few comments sounded.

Some news topics are inappropriate for HN in my opinion. The current news topic about the missing airplane doesn't really need to be here unless there are people whose only source of news is HN.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by milesf on Saturday March 08, 2014 @12:23PM (#7365709)
Thanks for that insight. I was asking about the influx of aviation stories on another thread and was downvoted into the basement.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by ericd on Saturday March 08, 2014 @07:21AM (#7364989)
Heh the initial articles probably kicked off some wikipedia crawls, and people probably unearthed other interesting aerospace articles as a result.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by dm2 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @09:54PM (#7367247)
The List of Lists and List of Lists of Lists usually results in me having to block myself from Wikipedia for the day.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Lists_of_lists

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_lists_of_lists

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by ericd on Sunday March 09, 2014 @03:58AM (#7367839)
Haha oh lord. Wikipedia is dangerous enough as it is without lists of related topics.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by anigbrowl on Saturday March 08, 2014 @05:19PM (#7366613)
It's the weekend, quite a few people do like aviation, and the SR-71 is 'futuristic' by most people's standards; arguably the single coolest vehicle ever built.

In the mid-70s an SR-71 was deployed to the UK and of course it was a sensation in that part of the world. Uncharacteristically, I bullied my mother into collecting breakfast cereal box coupons so I could get a snap-together plastic model of the plane.

Also, it's much more of a hacker's plane than the 'waterfall' approach of things like the F-35. The fact that you start the engines by setting off a small explosion on a special truck surely appeals to a lot of people here.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by Fixnum on Saturday March 08, 2014 @12:13PM (#7365685)
It could be related to StackOverflow displaying "Hot Network Questions" in a sidebar, some of which are from the aviation StackExchange, combined with the usual phenomenon of upvoted stories attracting similar submissions.

Incidentally, I find this sidebar extremely distracting; maybe it's time for a plugin/script to fix it.

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by ricree on Saturday March 08, 2014 @07:01PM (#7366915)
They've been here on and off for a long time. For example, issue 8 of Hacker Monthly back in 2011 had an article on the SR-71 as its cover story.

http://hackermonthly.com/issue-8.html

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by verandaguy on Saturday March 08, 2014 @08:36AM (#7365115)
The ST-71 is the result of groundbreaking engineering which flies three times higher than most other aircraft and goes so fast that it needs protection from heat even that high up in the atmosphere. And it looks awesome.

What's not to like?

Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by mdellabitta on Saturday March 08, 2014 @10:13AM (#7365376)
The cesium in the fuel and exhaust wasn't all that great.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by Shivetya on Saturday March 08, 2014 @07:25AM (#7364993)
I am in software because aviation engineering was more than I wanted to handle at the time. I needed to be less challenge adverse in my younger days and that is one bit of advice I give to the children of friends who ask we what I do.
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by Tloewald on Saturday March 08, 2014 @08:22AM (#7365085)
I'm not really an aviation enthusiast. I like planes. But isn't anyone with any interest in things technical an SR71 enthusiast?
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by bobowzki on Saturday March 08, 2014 @04:49AM (#7364764)
Certainly seems like it
Re:SR-71 In-Flight Breakup by brodo on Saturday March 08, 2014 @08:16AM (#7365072)
Could also be us military astroturfing.