News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by jere on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:37PM (#7361539)
>We recognized a public interest in establishing some core facts about Bitcoin and better informing those who might invest money in it.

Bullshit. Revealing who Satoshi is doesn't give you one shred of information to help you decide whether or not to invest in Bitcion.

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by tlb on Friday March 07, 2014 @01:17PM (#7361795)
There are some values of Satoshi that would make some people change their minds: if it were an NSA operation, or a neo-Nazi group, or Scientologists, or Intellectual Ventures.

Personally, I try pretty hard to not use things created by assholes, even if the things themselves are good. (You can't avoid things made by people with abrasive personalities, but I don't think I regularly use anything made by a genuine asshole.)

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by owenjones on Friday March 07, 2014 @02:09PM (#7362085)
Linus Torvalds is generally accepted to be pretty abrasive, at least, do you use anything created by him?

I try not to learn anything about any creator whose work I admire, they will unfortunately generally disappoint.

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by sqrt17 on Friday March 07, 2014 @02:53PM (#7362358)
abrasive != asshole

The rough tone on lkml (supposedly) reflects the gap between people who want to make something that's nontrivial and used by many people and the smaller number of people who are actually able to do so. Setting yourself up as this kind of gatekeeper means you have to be non-likable towards a lot of people even if you're a perfectly nice person.

Conversely, someone can be an asshole while showing spotless behaviour to the people they meet.

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by owenjones on Friday March 07, 2014 @03:00PM (#7362403)
I was just struck by the improbability of using "nothing made by an asshole."

Drive a Volkswagen? Or a Daimler, Chrysler, BMW, or Mercedes Benz?

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by Houshalter on Friday March 07, 2014 @01:28PM (#7361837)
But that's the entire point of bitcoin. It's decentralized. It doesn't matter who had the idea, they don't have any more control over it than anyone else.
Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by npizzolato on Friday March 07, 2014 @05:16PM (#7363106)
Given the amount of bitcoins Satoshi allegedly owns, he would be able to exert more influence on the bitcoin market than anyone else.
Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by thaumaturgy on Friday March 07, 2014 @02:57PM (#7362386)
But the article didn't talk about his values (because he wouldn't talk about them).

It was just a tabloid exposé of a private individual.

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by lolwutf on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:53PM (#7361659)
Well, not really.

Whoever Satoshi is does control an amount of BTC that could significantly shift the market if they suddenly did something with it...

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by jere on Friday March 07, 2014 @03:36PM (#7362582)
An analogy to clarify my point: this would be like having to learn about Steve Jobs to decide whether or not to invest in Apple in 2015.
Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by thrush on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:54PM (#7361666)
I guess it could be helpful knowing if it's a good-hearted civilian versus a tech savy mafioso.
Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by jere on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:58PM (#7361683)
Other than the fact that the guy owns perhaps $1 billion (surprise: he's not the only one), how is this illuminating?

It's been open source for 5 years and, by design, Nakamoto has no control over it.

Re:Newsweek's Statement on the Bitcoin Story by pohl on Friday March 07, 2014 @03:50PM (#7362656)
That's a good question. I'm on the fence. If you look at the design of an artifact and try to tease out clues to the intentions of the designer, that's very interesting to me.

Recently there was an essay by Charlie Stross buzzing around, fueled by a particularly contentious passage that suggested that BitCoin looked as if it were designed as a weapon against central banking and tax collection. A good chunk of the techno-nerd community denied it with the standard observation that it's just a descentralized protocol, etc.

So that conversation was very much like "This knife was designed to make fillet cuts". Response: "No, it's just a long sharp blade with an attached handle".

And I came away from that thinking "really, doesn't the design of this artifact suggest a little more about its intended purpose?"

And then this article comes out and suggests that the anthropological instincts of Charlie Stross vis-a-vis the design intent behind BitCoin may not have been so off the wall after all. And so that superficially feels somewhat illuminating to me, as someone who would not feel entirely comfortable throwing my weight behind something like that - despite how brilliant and cool BitCoin is on a purely technical level.

I also wonder - if we entertain for a moment the hypothesis that Charlie Stross is on to something - does the fact that Nakamoto no longer has any control over it imply that it would no longer behave as designed?