It would be hard to see what is controversial about this proposal if that weren't present. What, is AT&T complaining about more subscription minutes being used?
Number portability in the US as it is now only works if your new billing address is in the same zip code as your old number, and usually doesn't work at all when you're trying to port out of a VoIP provider or in to a PoTS line.
That some organizations' LNP processes are so dysfunctional as to make it a de facto reality - of that I have no doubt.
http://www.localcallingguide.com/lca_prefix.php?npa=404&...
You can do an NPAC dip on it and find that it's not ported, so it really is being originated by bandwidth.com's facilities.
There's nothing "virtual" about any of this.
There are numerous SIP softphones for the iphone/touch, so this means you can essentially do free VoIP.
Why it only works with Gizmo SIP numbers is unclear. Seems like it should work with any SIP number, including one you host on your own servers.
I think people want some honesty, especially from a company that uses slogans like "Think Different".
Isn't the answer already contained in your question? The real situation is that developers know that they are walking a fine line with applications that "threaten their platform". No big surprise there.
I get a feeling that banning Google Voice was an attempt to be more consistent, as some have blamed Apple for cronyism in relation to Google.
You signed up for a highly proprietary and controlled walled garden when you got an iPhone. I did too. When you ran into some limitations you didn't like, you jailbroke it and loaded some things Apple and/or AT&T didn't want you to load.
If you don't like this whole paradigm, why get an iPhone? Why not get an Android or something else? For that matter, why does Google bother releasing an iPhone app; why not build the Android into a handset that is tightly coupled/integrated with Google Voice? Seems like that would be a fine marketing coup for the former.
I'm just not sure what there is to whine about here. Of course enhanced voice application services aren't going to be allowed on the phone because they are perceived as encroaching on possible or actual carrier revenue streams. Of course you can't put applications on it that make a "dumb pipe" of the carrier's data network in order to deliver voice. If you don't like this set of circumstances, pursue a solution by competitive means, not legislating it; vote with your feet and quit buying iPhones until the exclusive distribution contract with AT&T expires, and thusly encourage Apple to diversify its retail blend to include other network operators with more liberal approaches.
Really - what, do you expect that a de facto contractually sanctioned monopoly (AT&T) is going to act in the spirit of the public welfare or consumer choice when it perceives a conflict of interest? Seriously?
Neither the courts nor the FCC should be looking at this. Consumers just need to take their wallet elsewhere.
EDIT: I very much concur with the poster above who speculated that AT&T's 3G network doesn't have the bandwidth to handle a large amount of relatively constant (at a certain baseline) voice traffic generated by something as popular as GV. Anybody who deals with mobile issues routinely can tell you that AT&T's 3G network is positively the worst in the land, and oversubscription in many MSAs is unbearably high. You want 3G bandwidth, go with Sprint, or maybe T-Mobile.