Number portability in the US as it is now only works if your new billing address is in the same zip code as your old number, and usually doesn't work at all when you're trying to port out of a VoIP provider or in to a PoTS line.
That some organizations' LNP processes are so dysfunctional as to make it a de facto reality - of that I have no doubt.
http://www.localcallingguide.com/lca_prefix.php?npa=404&...
You can do an NPAC dip on it and find that it's not ported, so it really is being originated by bandwidth.com's facilities.
There's nothing "virtual" about any of this.
There are numerous SIP softphones for the iphone/touch, so this means you can essentially do free VoIP.
Why it only works with Gizmo SIP numbers is unclear. Seems like it should work with any SIP number, including one you host on your own servers.
It would be hard to see what is controversial about this proposal if that weren't present. What, is AT&T complaining about more subscription minutes being used?