News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by bergie on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:11AM (#7354545)
The original Badros and Borning paper on Constraint Cascading Style Sheets from 1999 explains pretty well why something like GSS is needed: http://www.cs.washington.edu/research/constraints/web/ccss-u...

iOS developers have the power of using constraints for their layouts. Why not give the same to web development?

As for fluidity, this is something GSS can provide very easily with the conditionals. Imagine being able to do media query-style rules, but not only for the screen size but also for sizes of other elements. "If the image is bigger than X, change the layout so-and-so".

A little example: open the toolbar layout demo (http://gridstylesheets.org/demos/apple/) in a browser window, and resize that around. See how the button that prefers to be in the center, but even more strongly doesn't want to overlap with the other buttons behaves.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by bbx on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:20AM (#7354614)
> iOS developers have the power of using constraints for their layouts. Why not give the same to web development?

Because the web is meant for documents first, not applications.

The example who linked to is a nice demo, and I understand how the GSS is meant to be used. But for all the fancy CSS techniques that hit the HN frontpage (and that are usually frowned upon because there is no "practical" use case), there's probably one just as suitable for this particular situation.

A somewhat related example, with just a few JS lines: http://toki-woki.net/lab/fluid-corners/

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by coldtea on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:48AM (#7354823)
>Because the web is meant for documents first, not applications.

That train has left the station long ago.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by balls187 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:37PM (#7356053)
> That train has left the station long ago.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B-DpRcxK_N8

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by stormbrew on Thursday March 06, 2014 @06:22PM (#7357244)
> Because the web is meant for documents first, not applications.

Which is, ironically, why something much better than CSS is necessary. Right now you simply can't have rich presentation and a presentation independent document because CSS just doesn't actually give you that. Need to re-arrange your document's presentation with CSS? You'll have to move your html around to make that happen. Need a grid layout? Throw a bunch of stupid classes all over your html for your ridiculous CSS framework to latch onto. To rearrange them? Switch them around.

A richer presentation layout will help the web be for documents first, not hinder it. And more so than trying to pretend that it's still 1994 and no one's ever tried to do anything remotely complex on the web yet.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by rimantas on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:41AM (#7359860)
http://csszengarden.com/ have been there for years…
Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by andybak on Saturday March 08, 2014 @09:20AM (#7365217)
Can you explain how that rebuts the parent's point? I can't see it myself.
Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by bergie on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:24AM (#7354652)
While we clearly disagree on whether the web is a viable app delivery platform, there is no reason why documents couldn't look beautiful on the web either.

Compare a nicely designed magazine or a book to a typical website. Which one is more readable? The reason why so much of the web is not nice to read is because complex layouts in CSS are hard.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by munificent on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:08PM (#7355468)
Most books don't have complex layout. What they have is extremely high quality typography and careful attention to how the text appears on a specific page. Book designers tweak prose to avoid rivers (a series of whitespace on successive lines that happen to line up with each other), widows (the final line of a paragraph appearing on its own at the beginning of a page), orphans (the first line of a paragraph appearing on its own at the beginning of a page, or when the last line of a paragraph contains only a single word), and hyphenation.

The web, which doesn't have well-defined pages or even page sizes, precise control over typography, or designers who agonize over how the actual text appears in the context of the layout, lacks all of those. Typography is slowly getting better, but text layout algorithms are still relatively primitive.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by emn13 on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:51AM (#7359893)
Most books have trivial layout and typography - simple, successive paragraphs with a few very minor embellishments such as the occasional large header, page-breaks before chapters, and page numbers in the footer. Preventing widows and orphans is definitely not the norm - just browse your local library or bookshelf. I seriously doubt people worry much about rivers, too.

Books with diagrams and side-notes tend to have more complex layouts, sure - and that's most educational books. Maybe there these typography issues are given more attention, but it's pretty clear that the typical paperback has demonstrated they aren't that important to readers (which isn't a judgement, it's just the way it is), so I wouldn't be surprised if almost no books worry about these issues anymore, beyond perhaps using software which addresses them insofar as they can be automatically.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by dangayle on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:06PM (#7355446)
> Because the web is meant for documents first, not applications.

Where have you been for the past decade? The web is the world's largest app platform, and it's not going away any time soon.

Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by rimantas on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:44AM (#7359873)
I don't know about the person you replied to, but I have been developing for that very web for the past decade and a half. I agree about web not going away any time soon, and I am not sure about it being the largest app platform, but of one I am sure: it is a lousy platform for the applications. So I do not want it to go away, just to go home. (and let's not confuse the web with the internet).
Re:Grid Style Sheets – CSS polyfills from the future by rco8786 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:03PM (#7355416)
> Because the web is meant for documents first, not applications.

What year is it?