News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by sounds on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:52AM (#7353616)
If you're so comfortable with journalism, I'd like to interview you. But first please provide:

• Full names and home towns of your children and your wife

• Picture of your house – include a clear photo of your car's license plate

• Your home town, so anyone can locate you on Google Maps

• Your work history

• Your net worth

• Your health history

• Any notable personality traits you have, so the whole world can comment on them

Seriously, put up or shut up.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by arrrg on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:19AM (#7353755)
Did I do anything of note that would make any of this information interesting to the public? I think I did not. If you want to put the work in and find all that out you are free to.

I never once said that everyone should actually provide journalists with that information just like that. They still have to put the work in. Do that if you want to, but I don’t think you will find anything interesting.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by john_b on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:42PM (#7355258)
So a person loses their right to privacy when enough strangers take an interest in them?

Nakamoto barely provided Newsweek with any information at all. The rest was obtained (possibly illegally?) by snatching his email from a website he had done business with. After that, she pretended to have an interest in trains to spark a conversation and get initial information. She then stalked him and interviewed his family.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by anigbrowl on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:29PM (#7355601)
You don't have a right to privacy. Perhaps you should, and I've argued in favor of a constitutional amendment to that effect, but in the meantime privacy is just a polite social fiction.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by john_b on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:39PM (#7356065)
It's more than a polite social fiction. It's a moral requirement for many of the rights guaranteed by the US Constitution to have any meaning. E.g. try exercising your right to an attorney when the prosecution logs all your communications. Or try exercising your right of assembly to discussion union membership while your employer monitors the meeting. If Americans give up on privacy and decide it's not worth fighting for, they will eventually cede the rest of their rights as well. There are simply too many powerful interests with strong incentives to create a world without a right to privacy.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by anigbrowl on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:03PM (#7356213)
And the legal scope of those situations is correspondingly narrow. I'm not against a right to privacy, which is why I said I'm in favor of a constitutional amendment to make it explicit. I'm saying that you don't have a comprehensive right to privacy now. Moral rights are what you want, legal rights are what you actually have.

I don't thinkt eh right to privacy is entirely unilateral; if it were, journalism could not exist, and the Constitution also forbids the government from abridging the freedom of the press - which includes the freedom to inquire as well as to publish. I personally would narrow the scope of press freedom if I were drafting constitution 2.0, because I believe publishers often exploit the economic asymmetry between themselves and their subjects to the detriment of ordinary people in a manner that the framers of the constitution were unable to envision, but there you go.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by john_b on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:45PM (#7356455)
> " Moral rights are what you want, legal rights are what you actually have."

This sounds like a purely philosophical disagreement, so I won't pursue it much. From a practical perspective, I partially agree with you. A right without any teeth to back it up isn't much use in practice. In constitutional forms of government, it's the law that provides the teeth (as law ultimately devolves into a question of how and when force can be used, and against whom). But a more cynical perspective is that the teeth are all that really matter, and the moral arguments are all justifications for getting teeth in the first place. It's that latter, more cynical perspective that I am opposed to.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by wpietri on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:15PM (#7356283)
> So a person loses their right to privacy when enough strangers take an interest in them?

Depends on why strangers take an interest in them. I think it is reasonable to say that Nakamoto has made himself a public figure [1], so journalists should be able to research them within the confines of the law.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_figure

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by polymatter on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:49AM (#7353922)
If I understand your comment, you believe you are ok with sounds posting that list of sensitive private information, but only if he "put the work in" to find it. I guess thats the only reason you don't post all of that information publically yourself. Your information is clearly interesting to the public, look a member of the public specifically asked for it.

How about if I compensate you, is that a reasonable substitute? How much would you charge in exchange for publishing every item on that list?

I suspect you will find that there is some information that you'd rather not divulge on the open internet, where there is no shortage of crazies. Some of that info would be useful for identity fraud as well.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by arrrg on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:59AM (#7353987)
No, you didn’t understand me.

A. You have to put in the work and actually find stuff out. That’s what journalists do.

B. You have to report on something relevant and interesting to the public. Some random person who didn’t do anything of any note is not relevant. Publishing identifying information on them is unethical. Publishing identifying information on someone hugely influential is very much ethical.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by MSM on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:21AM (#7354627)
> Publishing identifying information on someone hugely influential is very much ethical.

How can you even say that? It's easy to say that if (assumption) you haven't done anything "hugely influential", but I think the feeling would be different if this article was about you.

It's plain disrespectful. The guy obviously wants to be left alone or he wouldn't have stopped emailing, stopped answering the phone or called police when the reporter showed up.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by weavejester on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:32AM (#7354711)
So if someone does something of note, they give up their right to privacy, even if that could compromise their own safety?
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:55PM (#7356890)
That's basically what keeps the paparazzi in business, yes. There's a reason the First Amendment rights were listed first, as well, which is the same reason the Guardian has been doing much of their Snowden coverage out of their New York office; press freedom is a big deal, even when that's inconvenient for you...
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by weavejester on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:56PM (#7358267)
Since we're talking ethics, rather than legality, do you believe it's ethically sound to post someone's personal details, and then make (possibly false) claims about them that may compromise their safety?
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:06AM (#7358598)
> Since we're talking ethics, rather than legality, do you believe it's ethically sound to post someone's personal details, and then make (possibly false) claims about them that may compromise their safety?

I don't think it's ethically sound to post his address, license plate information, city, etc. Especially since it leads to crazy media car chases and other sorts of paparazzi-style insanity that I wouldn't wish on anyone, let alone a guy who just wants to be left alone.

I'm also partial to arguments based on safety. It was one of the many reasons I was opposed to what Bradley Manning did, for instance.

However the risk to those affected by Manning was much larger than the risk to Dorian, and in any event I can't remember many people on HN saying before not to post stories about rich people since the unwashed thugs might stick a shiv in them and rob them.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by weavejester on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:31AM (#7360380)
Thanks for your honest answer. I'm of the opinion that it's legal (first amendment, etc), but rather unethical, especially since the evidence isn't conclusive.

Regarding safety, currency stored in banks tends to be less susceptible to theft via coercion. If someone breaks into a house, holds a person at gunpoint, and demands their bank details, they probably won't be able to successfully transfer a few million dollars out without triggering some internal check. On the other hand, you could easily do that with bitcoins, assuming that the private key hasn't been locked up in a vault, or the transaction secured with multiple keys.

I still feel it's an unlikely scenario, but it seems that claiming someone has $400 million in untraceable digital currency is going to impact their safety more than claiming they have $400 million in a bank, or in shares.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:11PM (#7363600)
> If someone breaks into a house, holds a person at gunpoint, and demands their bank details, they probably won't be able to successfully transfer a few million dollars out without triggering some internal check.

While that's true I suppose, whose fault is it for designing a system that is so much more susceptible to "rubber-hose theft"? It seems to me that this threat model would apply equally to anyone who gets rich via Bitcoin, not just Nakamoto, and it's an inherent side effect of refusing to allow banks to act as a trusted third party.

You can't have your cake and eat it too. Should investigative journalism be forbidden from here on to anyone who has enough Bitcoin? Because if it's true that being rich will get you physically robbed then how many Bitcoin startups have founders and officers that are in mortal peril based on their Bitcoin holdings? Surely we can't apply a blanket "no investigate" order across them all.

Rather I believe that, if this is a viable threat, that it's an unintended consequence which is essentially inherent to the new marketplace Nakamoto created, which is something that anyone publically known with Bitcoin riches will have to cope with in the future.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by weavejester on Saturday March 08, 2014 @05:35PM (#7366654)
It's not too difficult to protect Bitcoins from "rubber-hose theft". The simplest solution is to keep the private key to the majority of the wealth in a bank vault, or several.

If Newsweek got it right, then Satoshi has a number of options for securing his wealth, assuming he still has the private keys. But if Newsweek got it wrong, there's nothing Dorian Nakamoto can really say, other than to deny the story.

Consider if Newsweek ran a story about a secretive millionaire who supposedly has millions in gold stored in his basement. If the subject of the investigation does have millions, but they are stored more sensibly, he could release a statement saying that, yes, he has gold, but its stored in banks, not in his basement. But if Newsweek are wrong, they've compromised the security of an innocent individual.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by howeyc on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:15AM (#7354095)
Who decides what is "anything of note" or who is considered "highly influential"
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by buttsex on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:32AM (#7354246)
Society? People have always wanted to know who Nakamoto was in real life and would consider creating Bitcoin something of note. Any news story about Bitcoin in the past couple years have included something about the mystique of Nakamoto.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mbillie1 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:22AM (#7354639)
The number of page hits the article gets? Come on - Bitcoin is news, and it's been made news by people like us. Don't be too surprised or appalled when the general media tries to latch on to the publicity train.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by droopybuns on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:55AM (#7354886)
I'm sorry, but the journalists I have met do not do A.

They conceive of a narrative and find totems that can support their position.

You are espousing ideals that are taught in school, but rarely achieved in the real world.

That whole theme of unethical in B happens most of the time.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by milesskorpen on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:39PM (#7355230)
... but they clearly did A in this case. That's why we're having this conversation.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Amezarak on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:23AM (#7354159)
Most of that information is already available on the open Internet, given someone's full name, which many people use (or don't go to great effort to hide) on the Internet.

Given my full name, you can figure out, in about ten minutes, where I live, pictures of my house and my car (thanks, Google), the amount of property taxes I pay and the value of my house, my approximate net worth, my family, my academic history, partial work history, and many other details I would personally prefer the Internet to not know. All this is easily available on open public Internet sites.

And that's me. I make a concerted effort to remain pseudonymous on the Internet. I don't have a Facebook. I think you'd be surprised what people can easily find out about you if they want to.

What I do find interesting is the dichotomy between what I perceived to be the HN majority opinion in the story about license plate tracking and this story. In the former, it seemed to me that most people declared that privacy was basically dead and we should get over it; it was perfectly legitimate to collect public data regardless of whether the aggregation of that data led to information that many people would consider an invasion of privacy. Indeed, many commenters justified this point of view by saying that, essentially, data collection didn't really introduce any new problems, it just made it easier to get caught lying (e.g. having an affair) which is your fault since you shouldn't be doing it anyway.

But here many people (perhaps it is entirely a different set of people) clearly feel that the opposite is true: individuals, even those who may be involved in very public projects, have a powerful right to privacy. Or is it just that we feel its OK for companies and individuals to buy and sell information but less OK for the media to publish the same information wholesale? If so, why? At least when the media publishes my information, I know what you know. If people are buying and selling my information, I don't know what they know about me, I don't know what they're doing with that information, I don't know if its accurate, and I don't know how that affects decisions that companies and governments make about me.

I especially find the argument that we shouldn't publish the information about Satoshi because it puts him at risk interesting. I think most of us dismissed the same arguments when it came to informants identified in the Wikileaks documents.

I don't buy the "seeking attention" argument: many celebrities and people in positions of power aren't seeking attention and fame - it's a side effect of the job, or something they have done. The case is no different for them than it is for Satoshi.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by judk on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:06AM (#7354031)
Well let's hope that everyone else in the world becomes as uninteresting and uncontroversial as you, so they enjoy the comfort of de facto privacy. So what if all human progress grinds to a halt?
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by saraid216 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @02:08PM (#7355866)
> I think I did not.

Neither did Nakamoto, if you read the article.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by JabavuAdams on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:10AM (#7353707)
This is not constructive, and extremely naive.

Journalism exists in part to put the powerful under the microscope. They have many more resources to hide their activities and to defend their interests than average folks, and don't need to be protected from public scrutiny.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by polymatter on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:32AM (#7353827)
And if she is wrong?

Maybe he doesn't have access to his million dollar fortune. Maybe he lost the keys. Maybe someone else used his name and he is the Satoshi but not the creator. He is certainly not living as someone with hundreds of millions in the bank. In what way did he lose any right to be protected from public scrutiny (assuming anyone does have that right - I'm not sure they do)?

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by JabavuAdams on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:44AM (#7353891)
By making something that's used by vast numbers of people to channel huge amounts of money.

Journalists need to be able to go after stories like this because otherwise our society will be much worse. They have editors. They have review boards. We're not talking about 4chan or reddit lynch mobs here.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by polymatter on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:33AM (#7354253)
And if she is wrong?

Maybe he is the wrong guy. How is he going to prove he didn't invent Bitcoin? Especially if he has done classified work. He clearly doesn't want attention. He couldn't have made that more clear. And he still has a right to a private life. I don't agree with your suggestion that creators don't have rights.

I am not suggesting to stop journalists investigating who people are. But this is clearly someone who does not want attention. This could easily turn into a 4chan or reddit lynch mob. You only need a few Mtgox victims who want to enact revenge. Or criminals hoping of forcing him to pay hundreds of millions in blackmail. To a possibly innocent person.

To be clear, this story could have been done without printing his whole address, car number plate, unblurred pictures of himself and his family etc.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by anigbrowl on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:32PM (#7355622)
Then he can sue and expect a substantial payout.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by res0nat0r on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:24PM (#7356340)
> He is certainly not living as someone with hundreds of millions in the bank.

Thats because he doesn't have hundreds of millions in the bank. He has it in a random internet conceived currency. I'd seriously like to see him (or anyone for that matter) try and realize $1MM in Bitcoin in actual USD.

Good luck with getting your 1000 payouts of $1000 at a time spread over the course of 2 weeks per payout.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by zecho on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:50PM (#7358237)
"The whole reason geeks get excited about Bitcoin is that it is the most efficient way to do financial transactions."
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by verroq on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:59AM (#7353654)
He's a public figure/celebrity ever since Bitcoin blew up. Take any celebrity and you can easily fill out this list.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by sounds on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:09AM (#7353700)
Fine. Your skills give you the power, with a little effort, to invade someone's privacy.

Because he's famous, you're more likely to pick on him.

A journalist has the ability to take that to a whole new level by really shining a spotlight on it.

Just because it's easy doesn't make it right.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by verroq on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:51AM (#7353932)
I doubt that he's in much trouble with his 400m
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by judk on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:08AM (#7354041)
The whole point is that it paints a huge target on his back. And he isn't even using that 400m to do anything deserving of vigilante/criminal attacks, and no one knows if he even really has it
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Amezarak on Thursday March 06, 2014 @10:33AM (#7354256)
I did a quick Google search and found plenty of information about Bill Gates, including pictures of his house.

In fact you can do this with just about anybody. How and why is he at more risk than any other multimillionaire for whom all this information is public?

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Crito on Thursday March 06, 2014 @11:43AM (#7354780)
Bill Gates uses his money. That means that he can use some of his money on security.

He would be in much more danger if he neither used his money nor kept his money in institutions that would raise alarms to authorities if you tried to force him to withdraw all of it.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:57PM (#7356909)
Nakamoto could use his money too, if he's worried about security. Whether he does or not isn't up to Newsweek.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Crito on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:54PM (#7357158)
You assume he could. He may not actually still have access to it.

This situation isn't really comparable to the general public learning that somebody may or may not have a few million in investments and savings accounts. It is closer to the general public (excluding the police) learning that somebody may or may not have a few kilos of coke stashed somewhere in their home.

This hypothetical bitcoin wealth, and the hypothetical coke wealth differs from hypothetical 'traditional' wealth in that they can be burglarized or extracted via torture without attracting outside attention.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by mpyne on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:59PM (#7358039)
The blockchain is visible to all... of course it would attract outside attention.

But only if Nakamoto were actually able to spend it! If he's not able to spend it then he can't hire security I guess, but that would also put him at much lower risk of being burglarized for goods he can't give up. The important thing would seem to be making it clear he doesn't have access (that is, if he doesn't).

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Crito on Friday March 07, 2014 @12:17AM (#7358635)
Taking the wallet would not attract attention. Only transferring the coins would, and that could be done hours, days, weeks, hell even years after you've finished beating Satoshi with a wrench in his basement. You could be on step "Getaway" before the rest of the world was notified that something was going on.

Stealing the fortunes of conventional multi-millionaires however necessarily involves interacting with the outside world at the time of the theft. Unless they are drug dealers anyway... there is a reason that drug dealers get hit by thieves so often, and it isn't only because the thieves know they will hesitate to contact police.

If he can no longer access the coins (either because he intentionally destroyed the keys, or because he neglected backups), then proving that to be the case would be damn near impossible. In this hypothetical case, Satoshi may very well believe that he has a better chance of making it unclear that he is actually Satoshi.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by Amezarak on Friday March 07, 2014 @11:38AM (#7361172)
Generally, kidnapping and torturing a suburbanite and/or his family attracts some attention.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by masmullin on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:31PM (#7355172)
I doubt that he even has that bitcoin anymore. I expect that he lost the coin and thus is bitter and doesn't want to talk about it.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by npizzolato on Thursday March 06, 2014 @12:56PM (#7355356)
What makes you say that? It seems wildly speculative (at least, far more than the opposite opinion of believing he likely still has the coins he's believed to own).
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by masmullin on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:09PM (#7356244)
Yup, it is wildly speculative. Seems just as likely a speculation as any other towards why he hasn't sold/spent the coins yet though.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by jmpe on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:58AM (#7360178)
Wildly?

When you develop software based on your own novel framework, wouldn't you need to do several test-runs, performance runs, sanity runs in the process? Do you keep all the intermediate debug data? I know I don't. In this case bitcoins would be part of the intermediate data.

Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by izolate on Thursday March 06, 2014 @09:56AM (#7353973)
I'm all for the "fuck celebrities and their privacy wishes" attitude, but only when it's those who actively choose to become famous. Satoshi didn't ask for any of this, so I highly respect his right to privacy. Furthermore, he's not famous, he's infamous. I wouldn't wish his current position upon my enemies.
Re:The Face Behind Bitcoin? by arrrg on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:23PM (#7355567)
Yo, demo9898, that was hilarious. I sadly can’t respond directly to you since your haphazard summary of what I said in the past on this site is marked dead.

Most of the stuff you list that I explicitly said about myself is spot-on (mostly because I explicitly said it) or at most slightly out of date, but all the inferred stuff is garbage. I’m pretty sure I could be identified with what I said here. Maybe. Probably. You, however, were running down all the wrong paths. Doing it properly would require some more amount of work.

I guess that shows there is more to investigative journalism than reading a bunch of stuff someone wrote somewhere pseudonymously. And I’m still not sure why anyone would actually be interested in me and would want to publish anything about me. It’s not like I invented Bitcoin.

(Also, man did I say some aggressive bullshit in the past. Sorry about that. People change, you know, or at least recognise that their past opinions were bullshit. I think that would be about the worst thing: Pointing out dumb things I said in the past. That really stings. But it’s all public anyway, so I don’t care too much. Humans aren’t perfect.)

You can keep it up if you want to.