News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by jiggy2011 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:18AM (#7352527)
They're not charging to "distribute" firefox as a product in this instance, they are simply charging for the service/time to install it so I don't think this applies, it wouldn't be any different from geek squad etc charging to install firefox on a PC (IANAL).
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by markild on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:52AM (#7352622)
That sounds like semantics.

Couldn't you say the same for any service where you _actually_ distribute it as well? "I'm not distributing it, I'm simple charging for the service of easy installation".

(I'm also not AL, though...)

Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by jiggy2011 on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:37AM (#7352766)
Software licenses are almost entirely about semantics. :) I think the difference would be between saying "I will give you this DVD containing a copy of firefox but you must agree to my $16 installation charge" vs saying "for $16 I will on your behalf obtain firefox from the mozilla foundation and perform the service of installing on your computer".
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by peterpostle on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:20AM (#7352706)
I've never understood the complaint that something is "just semantics", or "you're arguing semantics".

If someone can't argue based on the meaning of the words in a piece of text, what else can they argue about? The grammar? The spelling? Surely we _only_ want arguments based on semantics!

Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by MatthewWilkes on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:54AM (#7352818)
The meaning of the sentence as a whole. "Just semantics" is used when you hinge your argument on the subtleties of meaning of one word.
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by iopq on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:38AM (#7352957)
Lexis and code generation, I guess
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by tehwalrus on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:12AM (#7352877)
It's getting distributed as well, when they ship the machine. Note that the trademark policy applies to Firefox in binary form on any medium, including a hard drive.

(this wouldn't apply to other laptops that come with preinstalled Ubuntu, for example, since there is no specific charge to add Firefox.)

Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by MatthewWilkes on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:52AM (#7352815)
They're charging to install it on something that they then distribute. The distribution contains Firefox.

Installing it on a computer somebody already owns isn't distribution, you can charge for hours there, but installing it on something in the factory is different.

Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by alkonaut on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:17AM (#7352890)
If the problem is the binaries being installed and shipped, that can be easily circumvented by dell installing a downloader stub that simply downloads and installs Firefox for the customer when the computer is first started. The charge would be for the setup of that automatic installer process.
Re:Dell UK is charging £16.25 to Install Firefox, Mozilla de... by scott_w on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:54AM (#7352998)
Nope, you're still distributing, just in a more elaborate way to try and evade the trademark agreement, which courts don't look too kindly on.