News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by rjbwork on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:10AM (#7352500)
I don't mean to be patronizing, but I may come off that way: why have you not been holding the vast majority of your BTC in your own local and triply (or more) backed up wallet, and liquidating to USD/other fiat in small pieces when you need to? I don't get how people can lose their entire stash of coin to these types of things.

I don't even own any BTC.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by oelmekki on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:36AM (#7352578)
I have to agree with that, even if it's very hard and is on the edge of blaming the victim. I feel for people losing everything, but really, don't keep your stash at exchanges.

Those are meant for trading, not as main account. To make a comparison with fiat money, would you throw your main bank account at trading ? Chances are you would have a main bank account and a secondary one for trading that would only contain money you're ok to lose. To push the metaphor further, would put your whole money at trade in an obscur online bank that was created just a few time ago ?

The main strength of cryptocurrencies is that they are decentralized. You're supposed to have your stash on your main computer. Each time people try to use a centralized online wallet instead, shit happens.

This sounds quite weird as it feels like keeping one's money under his bed, but really, it was how it was meant to work. Again, I feel for victims here, but please, be smart about it : recommend to anyone owning crytocurrencies to hold them on a local wallet, with backup for keys encrypted on a thumbdrive. Explain to them what happened to you.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by mcv on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:24AM (#7352720)
> I have to agree with that, even if it's very hard and is on the edge of blaming the victim. I feel for people losing everything, but really, don't keep your stash at exchanges.

The main reason that's unsafe, is because the exchanges themselves are unreliable amateur outfits.

Keeping the wallet on your own decive sounds smart, until you realize that your own device isn't very secure either, and every bit as much an amateur environment as the worst exchanges. Your PC can be stolen, or compromised by trojans and viruses (and you can bet they'll be targeted if lots of money is stored there), and you can lose your money in a hardware crash. Backups help, but every backup is also a new way someone else might get access to your wallet.

> To make a comparison with fiat money, would you throw your main bank account at trading ? Chances are you would have a main bank account and a secondary one for trading that would only contain money you're ok to lose. To push the metaphor further, would put your whole money at trade in an obscur online bank that was created just a few time ago ?

No, the proper metaphor here is to have your money in a bank, or to have it at home in a pillow. Most people have their money in a bank, and well-regulated banks are pretty safe. (The recent banking crisis was due to lack of regulation allowing banks to take crazy risks.)

What we need is well-regulated, safe bitcoin banks and exchanges.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by oelmekki on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:35AM (#7352758)
> Keeping the wallet on your own decive sounds smart, until you realize that your own device isn't very secure either, and every bit as much an amateur environment as the worst exchanges.

You can't compare both. Am I saying that with a local wallet you have absolute security from everything possible in present and future ? Obviously not. But it's certainly not as easy (and that's an euphemism) to steal money put on 1M people computers than on one or a bunch of servers.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by mcv on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:21AM (#7352899)
Criminals can reach a lot of computers with viruses, trojans, botnets, that sort of stuff. And if they know that a significant number of PCs contain very real money, you can bet they're going to try a lot harder than they have so far.

The more attacks can be distributed, the less the advantage of distributed wallets. And then it comes back to real security.

So far, real banks seems to be pretty good holding on to our accounts. Even if they squander our money on risky speculation, at least our accounts aren't being emptied on a massive scale. If bitcoin wants to truly challenge traditional money, then its financial service providers need to be held to the same standard.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by Bjartr on Thursday March 06, 2014 @08:42AM (#7353566)
That's what paper wallets are for.
Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by mcv on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:04AM (#7352668)
> why have you not been holding the vast majority of your BTC in your own local and triply (or more) backed up wallet

My guess is: convenience. In practice, convenience often beats security, and it's very convenient to trust your bitcoins to an exchange that offers a nice interface to trade them with others or exchange them for money.

Also: the vast, vast majority of people know nothing whatsoever about security. A currency that requires detailed security knowledge is only going to be used by security experts and fools.

(Disclaimer: I have bitcoins and I'm not a security expert.)

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by oelmekki on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:28AM (#7352734)
I see your point, obviously, but well, we could also consider it would be more convenient to never lock house door and to let car keys ready to use in car :)

There is indeed a huge problem with the sync thing in cryptos wallet apps. But there are apps that fix that by only downloading part of blockchain, like the dogecoin android wallet or electrum for bitcoin. This is what we should advocate, and stress that any online wallet is a risk of loss.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by mcv on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:31AM (#7352745)
> it would be more convenient to never lock house door and to let car keys ready to use in car

True, but those implications are easier to understand and manage for most people. They can open an unlocked door, so they understand that anyone can. And when they lose the key to their house, at least the house is still there.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by tomelders on Thursday March 06, 2014 @05:40AM (#7352963)
I was. And i was backed up. The backup was mitigated by the embarrassing technical snafu that I mentioned, the other losses occurred when bitcoins were being held in escrow byt third parties. Those third parties were either shut down by the feds, hacked or the service owners plain just absconded with the funds.

I wasn't a bitcoin millionaire, I only had a modest amount and I never bought in when they were super cheap, but that still added up to a sizeable chunk of cash.

Bottom line, there's a lot of stuff that can go wrong, and there's no safety net when it does.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by sosborn on Thursday March 06, 2014 @03:21AM (#7352535)
> liquidating to USD/other fiat in small pieces when you need to?

Just a hunch, but the meteoric rise in value probably prevents most people from simply cashing out.

Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by rjbwork on Thursday March 06, 2014 @04:43AM (#7352788)
Why? Isn't the demand for the existing coins what drives the rise in value? Logically there should be demand for one's sale of the coins at that point right?
Re:Bitcoin Bank Closes after $600,000 Theft by sosborn on Thursday March 06, 2014 @01:52PM (#7355755)
What I mean is that when the value keeps going up there is psychological barrier to cashing out. The thought is that it will keep going up so if I cash out now I'm missing out.