News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should biologists study computer science? by jacquesm on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:23AM (#734336)
This is a bit like the welder and the diver question, is it easier to teach a welder how to dive or a diver how to weld ?

For divers and welders the answer appears to be that it is easier to teach welders to dive than the reverse, even if both are far from trivial activities.

For biologists and computer scientists the answer is probably that it is easier to teach programmers to do biology than the reverse.

(good) Programmers have something universal about the way they apply themselves to problems and that way generalizes to problems in a different domain.

Re:Should biologists study computer science? by queensnake on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:41AM (#734392)
I admit I don't have much to go on, but it seems like biology is a full load of study, whereas at least undergraduate 'computer science' ie programming can be picked up by a smart person almost incidentally. I've seen that done, and I think it /is/ done more often than the other way around. As for writing /good/ code, that can come from practice and aesthetics. But knowing biology (or another science) takes real study.
Re:Should biologists study computer science? by plinkplonk on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:48AM (#734402)
I think (please correct me if I am wrong, always glad to learn) that one key difference would be that learning computer science would (mostly) need books ,the internet and the time and willingness to buckle down, while a proper study of biology would involve serious lab work, with a need for costly equipment and instructions.
Re:Should biologists study computer science? by jerf on Friday July 31, 2009 @10:57AM (#734534)
Casual programming can be learned incidentally, but there is a degree of skill that can not. If you want to build large programs that actually stand a chance of being correct, or performant, you really can't just "incidentally" pick up that skill. That's in the "10 years to mastery" class (and 12 years in I'm still learning, honestly).

That said, does biology really need that? Maybe the incidental skill is enough for most biologists. There is definitely a core set of tasks that biologists would need computer scientists for, though. (And for once, probably actual computer scientists and not just "good programmers".)

Re:Should biologists study computer science? by p_h on Friday July 31, 2009 @01:27PM (#734880)
The ease of learning biology depends on the level of abstraction you're aiming for. I had a summer job working in a proteomics lab during my computer engineering undergrad. My basic background knowledge of the relation between genes and proteins was good enough for me to contribute to published research. Of course you also need to learn the details of whatever experiments you're studying, but that's not too hard to pick up. Basically, progammers don't need to memorize all the amino acids to effectively contribute to bio research. You learn the details of whatever bio niche you're studying, and the rest is problem solving, analyzing and programming.
Re:Should biologists study computer science? by Retric on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:54AM (#734414)
Modern biology is so specialized that learning the tools for some area is often far simpler than the track people take getting a PHD.
Re:Should biologists study computer science? by Estragon on Friday July 31, 2009 @08:16PM (#735732)
That's pure ignorant bigotry, although it might be well-received in a crowd of programmers who also know nothing of what biological research is like. You've got to keep in mind that the main task in biology is inference of biological structures and processes. This is complicated by a number of factors: (1) Biological systems are typically way more complex than computer systems. (2) They are comprised of components which are way too small to see in action or manipulate, so all inferences are from second-order effects presumed (often inaccurately) to arise from the subsystem under study. Designing a biology experiment to cope with these difficulties is an exceptionally difficult skill to master. Compare that to programming, where the central task is the construction of a procedure using well-understood components, the states of which can easily be queried.

Claiming that computer scientists would have an easier time learning biology than the reverse is like claiming that chess is a more sophisticated game than go because the lines of tactical analysis are often longer. It ignores the relative complexities of the systems, and the fact that you can usually say more about the simpler system, and usually say it more elegantly.

Incidentally, I am not a biologist. I am a mathematician who has moved into statistical genetics. However, my last postdoc advisor was a formally trained biologist who taught himself statistics and computer science, and has made his career in bioinformatics. But he could hold his own in both those fields.