News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by lallysingh on Friday July 31, 2009 @07:04AM (#734145)
I'm feeling pretty disillusioned about my iPhone recently. I'm basically waiting for a sufficiently-captivating Android device. I'm curious to see what the Hero will be like, once I have a chance to hold it and they've had a chance to smooth out (and speed up) the software stack.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by kirse on Friday July 31, 2009 @11:12AM (#734567)
I've owned my trusty Nokia N95 (8gb) since late '07 - before the original iPhone came out, and it's been funny to watch the evolution of comments on HN... It's like a bunch of people bought into the iPhone hype and have slowly come to realize they're left with a subpar phone that provides poor service. Not to mention the iPhone has actually gotten better since it's initial release, so that tells you even more.

And here I am, still taking 5 megapixel pictures and quality VGA video with my 2-year-old N95-8gb, something the iPhone still can't do. Sure, it's a bit thicker, but I get 3G, crystal-clear reception with AT&T, and get my Google Voice.

All one has to do is browse GSMArena or PhoneScoop to realize how far behind the iPhone is to the majority of phone manufacturers. Apple does UI extremely well, but they've largely proven that they're really just the next Motorola RAZR... A cutsey little fashion phone that breaks often, performs poorly, and hardly gives the end-user what they're really looking for.

Just looking at phones like the Samsung i8910 (which does 720p HD video) helps one realize how far behind Apple is on the phone-tech curve:

http://www.gsmarena.com/samsung_i8910_omnia_hd-review-380.ph...

Re:I Quit The iPhone by dkarl on Friday July 31, 2009 @11:58AM (#734663)
What the iPhone taught me is to ignore cell phone reviews that dedicate most of their space to listing specs and features. Whoever wrote this review is not experiencing the phone the way I would, or the way any typical user would. Does he really need to tell us that the calculator has "a very limited set of functions" but that "Luckily, you can find third-party alternatives?" What kind of readers does this guy have that he's not afraid of losing them to boredom at this point?

Another case in point: I found the section about the web browser buried on page six underneath a larger section devoted to audio quality, which includes frequency response graphs and a table of audio measurements. And when it comes to the web browser, it says it "would have used somewhat more user-friendly interface" and "could certainly use a bit of fine tuning." It describes how to bypass the "unresponsive" and "slow" zoom feature by tapping a text section to zoom it but notes that it "is sometimes a hit and miss thing as the web browser fails to fit the text on screen." If you ask me, you don't want to use this review to illustrate that Apple is "behind" on cell phone technology.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by kirse on Friday July 31, 2009 @12:40PM (#734759)
What kind of readers does this guy have that he's not afraid of losing them to boredom at this point?

The kind of readers this "guy" has are the 2+ million unique people that visit per month (see compete.com chart) who are actually interested in every nook and cranny, pro and con, detailed form and function, and in-depth overview they need to make an logic-based, informed, $700 decision. First-version phones can be notorious for having major problems, and those issues need to be discovered before blowing a grand buying one.

All the iPhone taught you to do is ignore the negatives of balanced phone reviews, because the majority of your comment is

1) attacking the layout of the review and

2) restating a few pre-release issues of which the iPhone had plenty itself

What do you expect from a review? That it'll hide all the problems and only tell you the positive features of the phone? I certainly wouldn't trust a review website that does that.

As I said before, I bought a Nokia N95 back in 2007 that had 8gb, GPS, 3G support, Google&Nokia Maps, music player, FM radio, 5 megapixel camera, and VGA video support. I also get Google Voice, and while there aren't as many Symbian apps in total, let's just say I don't feel like I need iFart Mobile. Oh yeah, did I forget to mention I can easily take my phone to any GSM carrier I want? I think I also forgot to mention I can do basic tasks you'd expect a phone to do, like MMS and choosing the sound for your alarm clock.

If there's any phone that's behind on tech, it's the iPhone. Not only do you get subpar performance, you're also locked into a little cage where Apple decides what you get to do, and to me that's not a phone for a hacker.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by dkarl on Friday July 31, 2009 @01:36PM (#734904)
There were phones before the iPhone that had better feature lists and superior technical specs. They weren't better phones -- they were utter crap, in fact -- so don't expect that kind of comparison to be persuasive. Listing every technical spec and looking in every nook and cranny is just a distraction that shows that the reviewer doesn't understand what makes a phone good or bad. For instance, to expand on my example of the web browser, consider the amount of space he gives to the calculator and alarm clock (combined 9 lines of text and 5 screenshots) vs. the web browser (15 lines of text and 6 screenshots.) That's just poor allocation of time and attention.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by OmarIsmail on Friday July 31, 2009 @03:57PM (#735230)
If you're willing to hack around in a phone, then a jailbroken iPhone offers very similar software functionality. At that point your tradeoff is polished user interface versus a better camera and FM radio.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by kirse on Friday July 31, 2009 @04:42PM (#735330)
Being a mobile nerd, I fully agree with you =)

However, dkarl is arguing his point from "the way any typical user would" As a "typical user", if he's easily annoyed by how an in-depth phone review is structured, I could hardly imagine the litany of complaints he would come up with when the typical user was subjected to the mess of software and hacks required just to enable a few basic features that one can get from a $20 candybar.

I think the majority of our disagreement comes from the difference in the type of users we are. I'm a power user and have owned 7 phones prior to my N95 in the past 5 years. Dkarl seems to just want a basic fashion-phone and does not really care about having a bleeding-edge mobile device.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by Skeuomorph on Friday July 31, 2009 @05:39PM (#735446)
Except the “typical user” will never succeed at typically using those supposedly basic features on that $20 candy bar.

Your mom can and will use every feature on the iPhone.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by dkarl on Friday July 31, 2009 @06:18PM (#735529)
Even worse, users like me who do figure out how to use the features may not want to. Personally, I'm the kind of user who walked around for years saying, "I wish I had a web browser on my cell phone," when I did in fact have a web browser on my cell phone. It was just too crappy to be worth using. Apparently sometime when I wasn't paying attention "power user" was redefined to mean "feature freak," but given that definition I won't dispute my non-power user status.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by lallysingh on Friday July 31, 2009 @03:10PM (#735132)
Frankly my iPhone service has been substantially better than the Treo 650p I had before. Reception anywhere I go is full-signal, even in the elevators in my building.
Re:I Quit The iPhone by colinprince on Friday July 31, 2009 @11:44AM (#734631)
That's exactly why you haven't left the iPhone yet.

It's still the best phone for you. Sure, you're looking around, you'd be a fool not to.

But, as you've said, you're waiting for something better.

Apple has created a great phone and they're definitely going to try and stay on top.

By all means switch to the better phone when it comes out -- that's the best way to keep Apple and everyone else on their toes.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by adammarkey on Friday July 31, 2009 @08:22AM (#734232)
Unfortunately the Hero looks like it has some "lag" issues when navigating around the screen in the production models out in Europe right now. I hope it's a software fix to make it better, but I imagine we're going to have to wait for a faster processor to take advantage of that slick UI it has.

Also, T-mobile said that they won't be carrying the Hero because they are releasing the "myTouch" that Arrington was talking about in that article.

Let's hope someone gets on the ball in the US and gives the iPhone a run for it's money with Android. I think it will eventually happen, but we're probably going to have to wait another year.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by pxlpshr on Friday July 31, 2009 @09:22AM (#734332)
I still really love my iPhone but the Android is the second most attractive to me. Like you said though, the devices just haven't been that great yet.

My girlfriend has the Palm Pre and I don't think it's that great at all. It's extremely frustrating to use and the navigation is not that intuitive. My buddy also got the Palm and dropped it a 2 weeks later for the iPhone.

Re:I Quit The iPhone by pgebhard on Friday July 31, 2009 @12:05PM (#734681)
Those Pre keys are way too tiny. I didn't like how it felt after using it for a little bit, and I don't think I'd like it for a long time. I'm really glad Apple went the software keyboard route. It was definitely a smart idea (and it's much easier to type with, too, I feel).
Re:I Quit The iPhone by dasil003 on Saturday August 01, 2009 @12:56AM (#736002)
The G1 keyboard is pretty good. Given the amount of money I'm saving, and the fact that I can send emails twice as fast, I'm quite happy to put up with the little inferiorities.