News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by giarc on Monday March 03, 2014 @01:34PM (#7335451)
Keurig is free to do what they want, just as a consumer is free to choose whichever coffee maker they want.

Maybe this will blow up in their face, or perhaps given their market share it will all work out.

Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by HarryHirsch on Monday March 03, 2014 @01:44PM (#7335506)
This practice isn't what copyright was intended for when it was written into the constitution. The idea is that copyright is a time-limited monopoly to make money of immaterial property, it mustn't serve to lock out the secondary market for printer cartridges and coffee.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by superuser2 on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:40PM (#7335922)
There is no indication that copyright is the mechanism here. What copyright was intended for is not remotely relevant.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by mikeash on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:21PM (#7335784)
The way it should work is, Keurig should be able to do whatever they want in terms of DRM on their hardware, and other companies should be able to do whatever they want in terms of reverse engineering that DRM to produce compatible products.

I don't know if that's how the law actually is, but it sounds like it might be.

Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by Consultant32452 on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:53PM (#7336007)
With the DMCA it is illegal for competitors to reverse engineer the DRM to produce compatible products.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by AUmrysh on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:00PM (#7336056)
It's illegal for them to reverse engineer (and reimplement) hardware DRM for interoperability, but software DRM circumvention is protected by DMCA, only for the purpose of interoperability.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by PeterisP on Monday March 03, 2014 @03:30PM (#7336225)
In my jurisdiction, interoperability is a valid legal reason to ignore copyright restriction. Actually, I believe that none of the current global copyright agreements would prohibit anyone from distributing products that flagrantly circumvent that DRM, there's only the USA-specific DMCA.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by elliotz on Monday March 03, 2014 @01:46PM (#7335526)
> Keurig is free to do what they want, just as a consumer is free to choose whichever coffee maker they want.

The issue isn't whether Keurig should be free to add DRM to their product or not. The issue is whether they should be able to use the law to prevent competitors from circumventing that DRM. Printer manufacturers tried a similar stunt with adding DRM to printer cartridges and suing the makers of after-market cartridges for DMCA violations.

Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by kjjw on Monday March 03, 2014 @01:57PM (#7335604)
IIRC, the EU took a different view on printers and printer cartridges. Those can no longer be 'DRMed'. I don't see why they would take a different view with coffee machines.
Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by pasbesoin on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:02PM (#7335646)
To add to this, manufacturing and ultimately disposing of all these units carries costs that are not entirely reflected in their price. (Limited resources, pollution, etc.)

Designs that deliberately hinder their performance and perhaps artificially shorten their lifespan, may be viewed as against the public good -- especially if and as this becomes standard practice across a range of products.

Society may indeed decide that they are not "free to do as they please", in this respect. Just like your car is required to have adequate passenger restraint systems, and many other conditions that are "imposed".

Re:Keurig Will Use DRM In New Coffee Maker by mcherm on Monday March 03, 2014 @02:57PM (#7336032)
Ah, but the question is whether the consumer is free to choose whichever coffee maker REFILL they want.

The ethical and legal question is whether there's a good reason why Keurig should be allowed to forbid anyone else from manufacturing compatible refills (if they want to) or forbid customers from buying these refills (if they want to). As far as US law is concerned, do you think that prohibiting the manufacture of these compatible refills will "promote the progress of science and useful arts"? Because that is what Keurig is (effectively) claiming by relying on copyright law in this way.