Except they do allow them and apply this rule(s) at their whim.
The next excuse that's trotted out is that reddit isn't a democracy moderators can do that if they want to. Go make your own subreddit if you don't like it, etc.
Fine, what a shitty way to run a default subreddit. (little transparency, little accountability, etc.)
>And here's the last paragraph of The Incerpt aticle that makes clear it's opinion:
So what, you can find the same in a good portion of the content that remains on /r/news etc. The article is not an Op Ed, but if you like, read all but the last two paragraphs. Furthermore, the Intercept article[1] was rewritten[2] by other journalists to exclude "editorialized content" and also subsequently moderated.
Missing from much of the discussion on this is the irony that the story in question exposes gov't operations whose task is ongoing infiltration and manipulation of the media. Even if you're happy to defer to the mods' interpretations that the articles written to date regarding this particular news story are appropriately moderated; you must then concede that the rules are inappropriate if they manage to effectively exclude such a timely and appropriate news story.
[1] https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipula...
[2] http://www.examiner.com/article/snowden-government-infiltrat...
Yes, absolutely.
"Journalism is printing what someone else does not want printed: everything else is public relations." - George Orwell.
The sentence states that this cannot be justified by the government, which may be a fact. Or do you know of any justification? We could maybe even prove that this contradicts freedom of speech, and therefore cannot be justified.
(What I am trying to show here is that you can, to some extent, make an opinion into a fact and vice versa.)
Outside of a universally agreed upon objective morality, it's an opinion piece.
Nobody's asserting that premise. The question is whether /r/news should contain opinion.
When you have a website that gets visited by more than a hundred million users, this just won't do. Why are a few handful of anonymous random users dictating what is seen and not seen by millions and millions as "news? That makes no sense, something has to change.
There is something quite different about "news"... from, say, "biking". Most subreddits can stay as-is, but r/news and other subreddits would probably do better with officially picked staff.
That restores the proper incentives and controls to the system while maximizing free speech and experimentation.
And maybe just a little bit ironic given the subject matter?
I'd hardly call any of this convenient. It's simply the way reddit filters content.
And here's the last paragraph of The Incerpt aticle that makes clear it's opinion:
>Whatever else is true, no government should be able to engage in these tactics: what justification is there for having government agencies target people – who have been charged with no crime – for reputation-destruction, infiltrate online political communities, and develop techniques for manipulating online discourse? But to allow those actions with no public knowledge or accountability is particularly unjustifiable.