Also, what's with the condescending sneery tone?
The discussions end up being so worthless that I now flag every education related post on HN because it's just not worth the time here.
Is the university system (excepting "third level institutions" apparently) just a scam perpetrated against its students?
I think it's debatable whether great teaching or access to great minds is more important, and probably varies depending on the student and what stage of their education they're in. But either way, for the access to work at all, it has to really be access; receiving a dry lecture on introductory material from a great mind doesn't really give you access to that mind. But sure, the best students will seek out projects that give them real access, and those experiences will probably be incredibly valuable.
There is definitely a huge value in the university system just putting you in the right place to learn surrounded by the right people to learn from, but I hate the disrespect for actual teaching that I sometimes see when people talk about universities.