But I can still take seriously the notion that people assume they understand something just because they've observed it from the outside.
The agenda of ensuring children have access to life-enhancing educational opportunities?
>They can make a candidate, and they can break a candidate. //
You mean a political candidate? You really think that the combined voice of a group of teachers can do that against the weight of media conglomerates, other unions, rich lobbyists and other political groups? Any examples?
Presumably under your assertion the education system in the USA is the one that the teaching unions have won by political action and the politicos and business people are looking on powerless to influence it?
He was having trouble with bullies and the school did nothing about it. They pretty much gave up on teaching spelling completely. We found out that our school is a "magnet school" for behaviorally disturbed "special" kids from other districts so kids in the rich school and kids in the poor school where communities complain a lot get to enjoy a safer environment because the rural school gets all the psychotic kids.
I gave up on them when the superintendent gave a "town hall" where he told the mother of a "special" kid that he was a partner in his education and he told me I should just butt out because he was the expert and there's a new paradigm and homework is obsolete and because I don't have a phone number to call to get Albany breathing down his neck.
F the teacher's unions.
Ultimately teachers as a professional class deserve a union. We see in other places and countries that the unions do not serve as an impediment to a quality public education, so we have to ask ourselves what is really going on with current systems and unions that make the situation so shitty (esp. in New York state).
For instance, they opened a charter school in our district which seems to be an honest effort to provide a safe (bullying free) environment for the high school and there have been two people associated with the union who have just been consistently hateful trying to shut it down.
I'm in the UK, I've known quite a lot of teachers one way or another and observed the actions of teachers union workers and unionised teachers. Here - and limited to my anecdotal data - whilst the union supports the teachers it is supporting them in their primary function as teachers for children. The goal of the union is to enable the teachers to perform as professional teachers rather than merely supporting them as wage earners. Activities of the teachers unions I know of include - as you surmise - the basic functions of support for employees but much of the focus is on sharing best practice, lobbying for the best possible educational system, supporting teachers in other countries and similar.
My overriding experience is that teachers are concerned with enabling children's education.
Analogising, it's like the IoP (http://iop.org) is for physicists and supports them in their careers but it does that in order to advance physics, because that is the primary focus of physicists.
Yes, the combined voice of a group of teachers can make a significant difference. Why? Well, they're affiliated with other unions, to start. Further, as most are state employees, their ability to strike impacts public opinion regarding state government.
They've also got a lot of power because they are with your kids 6-7 hours a day.
They understand how political they need to be to keep the status quo, and are (at least in my and everyone else I know's experience) more focused on supporting the existing system for long term members than creating a better system for learning.
Did you steal this from one of their pamphlets?
Are you implying that teachers unions only agenda is to help students and not self preservation?
Sorry, I cant take this seriously. The teachers unions are one of the most politically powerful entities in the US. They can make a candidate, and they can break a candidate. They can pass and tank ballot measures...even ones completely unrelated to their jobs. They can protect drunkards and criminals from getting prosecuted, let alone fired. They are fine forcing their agenda down our throats, but they cant take a little pushback?