News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is by lawnchair_larry on Thursday February 27, 2014 @07:25PM (#7316425)
That would only be the case if someone does it by logging in to your iCloud account, which applies to none of these attack scenarios. Even then, it only notifies the owner of that account, not the party who is sending messages to unverified keys.

If you're spoofing the keyserver, it's invisible to Apple. If you're the FBI and serving a warrant on Apple, Apple does not send the message telling you that "FBI's MacBook Pro has logged in to your iCloud Account."

Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is by siglesias on Thursday February 27, 2014 @07:46PM (#7316513)
Pardon my ignorance not being a security expert, but given that all endpoints here (software and hardware) are Apple-controlled, just how trivial is spoofing a keyserver? Genuinely curious.
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is by nitrogen on Thursday February 27, 2014 @08:10PM (#7316592)
Assuming (perhaps incorrectly) that Apple does not use certificate pinning for their iMessage servers, and the adversary controls a trusted CA (likely for secretive government agencies), and the adversary controls a router somewhere between the device and Apple (also likely for government agencies), it's very trivial.

It's a simple matter of redirecting traffic using something like iptables.

Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is by MacsHeadroom on Thursday February 27, 2014 @08:46PM (#7316721)
Even more trivial if the iOS device is managed. by an Enterprise Admin, who can tell the device to trust any arbitrary certs without the user ever knowing.
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is by fpgeek on Thursday February 27, 2014 @09:26PM (#7316890)
Based on the quarkslab link upthread, Apple wasn't using certificate pinning for iMessage at least as recently as October 2013. Even worse, also as of that article, Apple was sending the AppleID and cleartext password over this MITM-vulnerable SSL connection as part of iMessage login.