> (which, while unlikely, isn’t inconceivable)
Not only do I think it's not unlikely, I actually think it's pretty much a certainty that Apple has a backdoor in their code. After the slides detailing how easy it is for NSA to break into Apple phones I'd be simply shocked if they hadn't inserted such a vulnerability.
Sounds to me like the author is applying a nice coat of white wash.
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is
by nemothekid on Thursday February 27, 2014 @07:14PM
(#7316364)
After reading a post by a Google engineer on this issue, I'm going to err on the side of believing that Google, Apple, and others aren't actually actively inserting back doors into their code.
https://plus.google.com/108799184931623330498/posts/SfYy8xbD...
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is
by michaelt on Thursday February 27, 2014 @08:08PM
(#7316590)
By all accounts, these secret court orders often come with gagging clauses - which would likely extend to even gagging one employee from telling another. For all I know the guy next to me could be under a secret court order forcing him to insert backdoors.
Of course, as there's no way to disprove this hypothesis, and there's no proof of it, you can still err any way you like :)
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is
by brisance on Friday February 28, 2014 @10:52AM
(#7319397)
So why would Apple voluntarily issue an update to fix the problem if they were gagged under a secret court order?
Re:Apple Explains How Secure iMessage Is
by anfedorov on Thursday February 27, 2014 @08:24PM
(#7316643)
After the slides detailing how easy it is for NSA to break into Apple phones I'd be simply shocked if they hadn't inserted such a vulnerability.
The slides pertained to physical access to an iOS 6 device, which was publicly known as insecure before the NSA revelations:
http://apple.slashdot.org/story/13/08/01/2024212/iphone-hack...
That is, assuming, that there isn't some code in the app that allows Apple to request that the app send your private key up to the server. It's conceivable that in order to comply with law enforcement, for example, that Apple could just tell the app to send up your private key so that it can decrypt any message they have stored.
There's also no way to verify that your messages have, in fact, been removed from their services.