Re:GPL FUD round N+1
by 321abc on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:49PM
(#731162)
"I think I get why people don't like the GPL -- it forces them to do something, whereas other licenses don't. If you use GPL'd code, your code has to be GPL, there is no option."
"When you hear that the GPL is viral and can force proprietary code to become GPL... you'll know that isn't true.
If you steal GPL code... a forced release under the GPL can't be imposed on you.
You do have a choice under the GPL license: you can stop using the stolen code and write your own, or you can decide you'd rather release under the GPL. But the choice is yours. If you say, I choose neither, then the court can impose an injunction to stop you from further distribution, but it won't order your code released under the GPL."
Unfortunately, that's not true.
From http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20031214210634851
"When you hear that the GPL is viral and can force proprietary code to become GPL... you'll know that isn't true.
If you steal GPL code... a forced release under the GPL can't be imposed on you.
You do have a choice under the GPL license: you can stop using the stolen code and write your own, or you can decide you'd rather release under the GPL. But the choice is yours. If you say, I choose neither, then the court can impose an injunction to stop you from further distribution, but it won't order your code released under the GPL."