News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GPL FUD round N+1 by jrockway on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:03PM (#731037)
I think I get why people don't like the GPL -- it forces them to do something, whereas other licenses don't. If you use GPL'd code, your code has to be GPL, there is no option. If you use BSD code, you have the option of making your code free, or you have the option of not doing that.

I read a book called "Predictably Irrational" that documents this effect. The author set people up with a computer game where the goal was to run around and collect as many points as possible. Bags would randomly appear, you would collect them, and that would get you the points. Different rooms had different rates of points appearing, and some rooms would produce higher value objects, etc. He tried a variety of scenarios to see how people would behave; one involved a door to another room (which might have more earning potential than the current room) that you could travel through at the cost of a certain number of points. If you didn't go through the door, it would eventually disappear. He found that people, even after finding that the room that the door led to was worthless, would still waste time and points to keep the door open. Nobody wanted to let an opportunity, even a poor one, pass.

I think this explains the (predictably) irrational hatred for the GPL; it makes doors close, and that is something we are apparently hard-wired to hate. Even though we know we are never going to make our free app proprietary, we want that option.

Re:GPL FUD round N+1 by gabrielroth on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:20PM (#731079)
You're kind of stacking the deck here. It's true that a programmer who knows for certain that she's never going to make her code proprietary would be behaving irrationally to insist on keeping an option she'll never use.

But that's a rare case. What about the more numerous programmers who don't know for certain? If they choose to keep the proprietary option open by eschewing GPL-licensed code, that could be perfectly rational, depending on the value to them of the GPL-licensed code they're declining to use.

And what about the programmers, like Daniel Jalkut, who work on proprietary commercial projects? Of course he'd prefer for other projects to use liberal licenses that would allow him to make use of them. That's the opposite of irrational; it's just straightforward incentives.

Re:GPL FUD round N+1 by antonovka on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @06:17PM (#731213)
I think this explains the (predictably) irrational hatred for the GPL; it makes doors close, and that is something we are apparently hard-wired to hate. Even though we know we are never going to make our free app proprietary, we want that option.

I write libraries as well as applications, and I know that I'll use those libraries for both free and non-free applications, as the occasion requires. Accordingly, I do not want to pollute the libraries with GPL restrictions, and thus avoid all GPL and LGPL code (even the LGPL restricts how I can link against the code, requiring dynamic libraries, and how I distribute the code).

I don't consider this irrational; the paycheck that allows me to devote many many hours of my life to open source software comes entirely from software sales.

Consumers don't purchase "services" for desktop software, and the enterprise services I do provide are purchased by companies who ... sell software.

Re:GPL FUD round N+1 by 321abc on Wednesday July 29, 2009 @05:49PM (#731162)
"I think I get why people don't like the GPL -- it forces them to do something, whereas other licenses don't. If you use GPL'd code, your code has to be GPL, there is no option."

Unfortunately, that's not true.

From http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20031214210634851

"When you hear that the GPL is viral and can force proprietary code to become GPL... you'll know that isn't true.

If you steal GPL code... a forced release under the GPL can't be imposed on you.

You do have a choice under the GPL license: you can stop using the stolen code and write your own, or you can decide you'd rather release under the GPL. But the choice is yours. If you say, I choose neither, then the court can impose an injunction to stop you from further distribution, but it won't order your code released under the GPL."