Re:A rescue plan that might have saved space shuttle Columbia
by oofabz on Wednesday February 26, 2014 @11:01PM
(#7310332)
The ISS is definitely expensive and doesn't produce much tangible return. But they are up there doing research 24/7, and have been for more than ten years.
I still like it a lot better than the alternative, which is to have nothing. Wikipedia says we have spent $150 billion on the ISS. That's very expensive but it's cheaper than a war and only slightly more expensive than the TSA. At least the ISS has a net positive impact.
Re:A rescue plan that might have saved space shuttle Columbia
by Tloewald on Thursday February 27, 2014 @08:50PM
(#7316738)
Slight correction: they are up there doing "research" 24/7.
The alternative to the ISS is not nothing; and it's hard to demonstrate that it's a net positive. I'd happily agree that the TSA is a negative, but "better value for money than the TSA" is hardly an awesome rallying cry.
E.g. one of the highest profile achievements of the shuttle program was repairing Hubble. But without the shuttle program Hubble would simply have been replaced (more cheaply). IIRC it turns out that the US air force had (and presumably still has) several superior telescopes sitting in warehouses in case they need to replace a spy satellite in a hurry.
And of course the single biggest achievement of the shuttle program is the ISS which is an utter boondoggle.