This is a rather bold request. So to back it up he says the entire fate of bit-coin depends on this.
There is only a single line about preventing a run on mtgox, because (a) trading will only start when mtgox is (mostly?) re-capitalized and has most people's bitcoins. And the prevention of a run on mtgox is pretty straightforward and non-controversial ... just limit the amount of withdrawals.
I am pretty sure this document is the real thing. But one thing I cannot yet decide is whether he stole all or some of the coins or really lost them. The idea that he lost over 700K of coins over the years without noticing is very hard to believe. On the other hand if he did steal the coins, and now is asking for the community to donate them back to him, then he has an immeasurable amount of chutzpah.
..that "too big to fail" really is not about jobs or anything like that, but about maintaining faith in the currency.
The problem remains that the bailout didn't just manage to shore up faith in the currency and banking system, but grossly enriched many of the same bankers who'd, if not caused the crisis, played a major role in precipitating and enlarging it.
It mirrors "too big to fail" startlingly well.
"The unrest started when Economy Minister Domingo Cavallo introduced restrictions to the withdrawal of cash from bank deposits, intending to stop the draining of deposits that had been taking place throughout 2001 and had reached the point where 25% of all the money in the banks had been withdrawn." People had were previously gradually withdrawing money over time.; no 'bank run' had occurred. The Corralito occurred, which among other political factors lead sections of the populace to riot. Read the article.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2001_riots_%28Argentin...
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/customers-tur...
Riots Hit Cyprus Bank After Accounts Frozen
http://www.endalldisease.com/riots-hit-cyprus-bank-after-acc...
Panic of 1837
Moreover, the panic unleashed a wave of riots and other forms of domestic unrest. The ultimate result was an increase in the state's police powers, including more professional police forces.[17][18]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panic_of_1837
Baltimore bank riot
The Baltimore bank riot of 1835 was a violent reaction to the failure of the Bank of Maryland in 1834. The riot, which lasted from 6-9 August, was aimed at the homes and property of a number of former directors of the bank, who had been accused of financial misconduct and fraud
I'll give you the others, however. The fact that two are from over a century and a half ago however seems to support my implication that bank runs don't necessarily lead to riots (and more specifically, that not bailing out banks won't necessarily lead to riots).
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/December_2001_riots_%28Argentin...
I'm reminded of the Federal Reserve calling in every major Wall Street bank CEO and demanding that they chip in to help rescue the imploding hedge fund Long Term Capital Management, lest it take down the entire market.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long-Term_Capital_Management
First time I'm ever seriously considering just cashing out all my coins...
Longterm things like colored coins are looking good for Bitcoin, plus exchanges not run by complete assclowns
Because preventing one at this point is impossible.
If they have truly lost almost everything (2000 BTC remaining), they have nothing, and those USD funds are probably frozen or to be frozen in various investigations. On the contrary, I find this document incredible because it actually envisages keeping mtgox open under new management. That's not going to be possible. Because of massive trust issues with anyone willing to go near this company, at best it's going to close down in an orderly fashion. Putting more money into it now is a lost cause, and without an audit by outside accountants, why should anyone trust them, no matter who the CEO is?
If they actually have lots of USD (I am doubtful), the best outcome for them is a precipitous crash in the bitcoin price down to almost zero, at which point they can pay out all their customers in bitcoin easily by purchasing new bitcoin and walk away with millions of USD. They seem to have done their best to engineer this by being completely opaque about their situation, but I suspect that's just incompetence and panic.
If they don't have accessible funds in USD, and have lost their BTC (as seems likely), no-one will get anything and the company will be wound up. Payouts have been glacial or nonexistent for months, so something has been badly wrong for quite some time.
The best bet for customers now is to apply to financial authorities immediately to have the company shut down and investigated.
Wiping their tweets and leaving it to now to shut down the website then showing a blank page shows you what level they are operating on - I suspect they have no appreciable assets available and are running on fumes, if not they would be acting in a far more rational manner and reassuring customers.
They will not survive this panic and this will end badly when the financial authorities step in.
http://blog.coinbase.com/post/77766809700/joint-statement-re...
Edit: and now the MtGox website is totally down.
Mt Gox failing doesn't surprise me. The number of people stepping up and saying this is a hoax or fake does surprise me.
Over 2 months ago I responded to a poster on another bitcoin story who said they had waited over 5 months for their withdrawals. That means Mt Gox has not been solvent since at least last summer.
How can there be a run on a bank you can't get your money from? While the recent freezes of USD and BTC withdrawals were only recently announced it appears that you couldn't really get your money out before either.
I'm going to take a guess. An investor received this document, was appalled and published it.
If I was an investor in Mt Gox and received a document like this, which is clearly an admission of very illegal activity, I would publish it publicly and forward it to the FBI. I don't think there will be a gox.com, but I do think someone will end up on an Interpol list in a few days. Mt Gox wasn't run by people who should be celebrated, it was run by criminals who knowingly took monetary deposits for their insolvent for-profit business.
But Mt. Gox isn't a business. It's an unregulated exchange, so there's really no point in taking for granted that they would meet some standard of professionalism which by definition they don't have to.
I meant Mt.Gox isn't a business in the sense that businesses, typically, have regulatory frameworks they have to follow, and standards to meet. Particularly when they deal with currency.
Maybe I should have said there's no reason to expect them to act like professionals.
Sure you would, just not a licensed one.
The document states their USD assets are $22.5M liquid and $10.5M seized/locked ($33M total) and USD liabilities of $55M.
How is this $22M deficit possible when the balance sheet on page 8 (look for the non-redacted version in this thread) shows a positive income for both the 2012 and 2013 fiscal years?
If it's a hoax, then it's well done. I would guess it's something done by an investment banker who knows how to write documents up like this. But the write up is far too melodramatic for me to believe this was written by someone actually involved in the situation.
"At the risk of appearing hyperbolic, this could be the end of Bitcoin, at least for most of the public." "This isn’t about saving MtGox anymore."
Why is there only a single line on preventing a run on MtGox? That to me would be the most pressing issue once MtGox opened up the floodgates.