Over time, the old and small homes in my grandparents' area became the bottom of the barrel for family living, which means they attract the poorest segments of society -- 90% of students in my school are native speakers of other languages (primarily Spanish), whose parents came to the area to make a living mostly as unskilled laborers who haven't moved up the ladder very far since arriving. At their income levels, many of them can't even afford this low-end housing -- so they end up with multiple parts of an extended family sharing a single house. This creates problems of various kinds for my students.
I have no doubt that some of these families would benefit from very small, truly affordable housing -- housing that fits their circumstances (low income, limited job prospects, sometimes no support network), instead of the circumstances my grandparents grew up under (the GI bill, family support, a manufacturing and export economy whose primary competitors were ravaged by the war.)
I also lived in Europe for a time, where homes tend to be smaller than than in the U.S. But the problem I have with articles like this one is that it is a poverty mentality solution, which helps keep poverty alive. It is not proposing policies which remove the incentives that are causing new housing to be 2000 sf or more. It is not making it more feasible for "normal" people to get a small place. It proposing tiny houses specifically for very poor people who are currently homeless. This is not a good way to solve the problem. That approach is basically how welfare began -- by defining the needy population as "poor, single moms" -- and it actively grew the population of poor single moms. This makes problems more entrenched. It is not a "solution."
Thanks for your great comment.
In Europe, a lot of "welfare" type programs are designed to help women or pregnant women or children or families regardless of income level or marital status. In the U.S., such aid is almost always tied to some criteria proving you "need" it. So you can't get help until a) you already screwed up and b) you are willing to fill out forms testifying that you are a screw up. This has substantial negative psychological impacts that I don't think you see in Europe (yes, I lived in Europe for a time and have read books and articles comparing European policies to American ones in this area).
In the U.S., welfare -- which requires a woman to be both a mother and unmarried to qualify -- actively discourages "shotgun weddings" and changed the social contract so that having babies out of wedlock is now much more acceptable than it was when the system was conceived. At the time, it was inconceivable that women would choose to intentionally have babies out of wedlock. This is no longer true in the U.S.
So, that is how welfare in the U.S. grew the population of "poor, single moms" -- by actively encouraging out-of-wedlock births. Single moms are typically poor. Families with two parents are usually better off.
Have an upvote.
It seems you can talk well in this area and appear to be eloquent enough to describe complex situations, so it begs the question.
I have a serious medical condition, as does my oldest son. I have been advised that people like me do not get well. I have figured out how to get us well, but it all came out of my pocket, leading to a lot of debt.
I had a job with a Fortune 500 company. At some point, I was evicted from my apartment, not due to inability to pay but because I had done things like removed carpeting without permission because that made more sense than staying ill. After getting a notice of eviction, I chose to not look for another apartment because it was clear to us that the apartment was part of why we were still ill. After three days sleeping in a tent amidst trees, I woke up feeling better than I had in years. I submitted my notice that I was quitting my job and I left on foot to cross the country and return to a climate I knew I would do better in.
Since then, I have focused on getting well and trying to develop an income that does not keep me sick. I have made good headway on getting well and I am beginning to make headway on an income that does not keep me ill. I would like to get off the street soon. I am nearly well enough that I think more conventional housing would no longer be an automatic health disaster for me and my sons. I don't yet know how to solve that problem, either financially or logistically. I really need to go straight from homeless to homeowner. Renting leaves me too little control over my home life to keep myself well given my medical situation.
I previously wanted to be an urban planner. I think the poor quality of a lot of the housing stock in this country contributes to health problems, as does our car-centered lifestyle. I have lived without a car for several years now. It is something fairly challenging to pull off in the U.S. (I now live in San Diego county, which has good public transit, but I was someplace without that when I gave up my car.)
I think the path forward to get people healthier in this country is more complicated than just making sure they can "afford" to see a doctor. I have not seen a doctor in several years. If you are healthy, it matters a lot less whether or not you can "afford" a doctor.
But have an upvote and thank you for commenting.
My diagnosis is very recognized. But I have also been told "people like you don't get well" by a specialist. So the choices I have made to get well in defiance of that are not recognized as legitimate choices. Thus I didn't bother to argue with my landlord and I accepted that taking care of myself likely would lead to eviction. It took 18 months but it did lead to eviction.
I wasn't trying to imply homeless == stupid, I apologize if it came off that way.
I understand homelessness is multifaceted and for some, even though intelligent, classic employment opportunities are not available/desirable for a whole host of reasons.
The impression I got from your question wasn't that homeless people were incapable of intelligence, but rather that you thought intelligence was the exception, rather than the rule. This becomes a problem when, say, a rags-to-riches story comes around and people conclude not that this one person got a lucky break, but that this one person decided to stop being as stupid as the others. This in turn suggests that nothing is actually broken and homelessness is less an indicator of societal malfunction and more a casual nuisance.
I'm a student in New Zealand, and almost all students here have that sort of accommodation (we call them 'flats'). I actually really enjoy this arrangement, and would go as far as to say that it's close to the optimal living arrangement for unmarried people. You get all the benefits of friendship and community (almost a pseudo-family), while also paying less for rent, utilities, and food.
However, your post was phrased in a way that implied that this was a sub-optimal solution. Could you expand on your reasoning?
To be clear, I'm not trying to say that you're wrong; your post was insightful so I assume you've got good reasons for feeling the way you do.
What works in other countries does not necessarily work in the U.S. We tend to have low population density and, as a culture, much more strongly value our independence.
Just one concrete example: A three bedroom apartment may come with one or two assigned parking spaces. If three unrelated adults live there and each has their own car, at least one of them will have to routinely park in "guest" parking. Further, in some places, it is quite hard to arrange this at all. The leases are generally intended for a family, subletting may not be acceptable, etc.
In many other countries, living without a car, walking and using public transit, etc. are far more feasible.
There are other issues, I am just trying to come up with something concrete to give as an example of why this does not readily translate from your country to mine. They don't have the same infrastructure, culture, etc. So the same living arrangement in two different places is not necessarily equal in quality of life.
However (just because I found it mildly amusing), you may be interested to know that the United State's population density is actually twice as large as that of New Zealand! In fact, New Zealand's population density is approximately equivalent to that of the U.K and Japan in 500 A.D.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_populati...
A little googling suggests that most kiwis live in relatively dense urban areas. I find your wording confusing and perhaps we mean two different things but my general impression is that cities in New Zealand are generally more "urban" than where most Americans live.
I'm not sure how easy it is to get ahold of ebooks in your current situation, but if you have a chance take a look at Matt Yglesias's The Rent Is Too Damn High, in which he addresses similar themes albeit from a different perspective.
I'm curious though, are you in SF still (you mentioned SFSU). I ask because, at least outside of SF, or at least in some parts of the country there are apartments built for roommates. They usually have 2 master bedrooms each with their own bathroom accessible only from that bedroom. They share the living room, dining room, and kitchen. SF seems to have none of that, mostly because there's so little new construction. It's mostly 2 or 3 bedroom places with 1 bathroom left over from 60-120 years ago.
I only really know LA, OC and SF but there's plenty of places built for roommates in LA and OC.
Not quite the same as boarding houses but still also not built for nuclear families.
In previous life, I wanted to be an urban planner. As part of that, I took a class on Homelessness and Public Policy at SFSU. I am currently homeless and have been for over two years.
So, some thoughts in brief:
Current housing stock, financing, and policies in the U.S. is very skewed towards housing for "the nuclear family" and is rooted in things that happened when our soldiers came home from WWII. In the decades since, our demographic has diversified thus this type of housing stock, financing infrastructure and policies no longer fit our needs. Ironically, the result is we no longer have a lot of the options that were once fairly common here, like SRO's and boarding houses, which were better suited to single people with limited incomes. You increasingly see things like 3 (or more) roommates sharing a three bedroom apartment designed with the nuclear family in mind.
Yes, smaller houses would be nice. Post WWII, the average new home was around 1200sf. In 2000, the average new home was over 2000sf and housed fewer people and had more amenities. This is driven in part by tax policies that encourage those who can afford a house at all to buy the largest house they can afford. Meanwhile, homelessness is on the rise because it is increasingly hard to afford housing at all.
I have commented on this in various places over the years. I could probably write a good blog post on it. But most people seem to think this entrenched history is irrelevant. So I see little reason at this time to put much effort into laying it all out.