News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by nextweek2 on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:21PM (#7292399)
I thought the USA was the model of capitalism. However it appears the opposite, monopolies run rampant. The free market is killed rather than encouraged.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by bryanlarsen on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:41PM (#7292561)
Infrastructure is the quintessential example of a natural monopoly. Free markets encourage natural monopolies. A non-free market is required to avoid natural monopolies.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by seventytwo on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:59PM (#7292664)
What are you talking about? Monopolies ARE capitalism run rampant.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by praxeologist on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:06PM (#7292717)
Nonsense. Leftists conflate "state capitalism", cronyism or corporatism with real, free-market capitalism. Internet monopolies like Comcast or TWC enjoy are state-granted monopolies, not "natural monopolies" (which have never existed).
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by dragonwriter on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:16PM (#7292784)
> Nonsense. Leftists conflate "state capitalism", cronyism or corporatism with real, free-market capitalism.

Leftists -- specifically, socialists -- created the name "capitalism" as a name for a real system which existed in the developed world in the 19th Century, in which the economic order was actively managed to favor the interest of the capital-holding class. The idea that this was system had something to do with "free markets" was part of the propaganda of defenders of that real, very much crony, system in response to that critique.

Its kind of weird to call the real thing which actually existed that "capitalism" was coined to refer to as anything other than real capitalism, while referring to amorphous, ill-defined, fantasy as "real capitalism".

"State capitalism" is a different thing entirely -- it usually shows up in critiques by leftists, particularly non-Leninist socialists, of Leninist(incl. Stalinist/Maoist)-style "Communism".

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by doyoulikeworms on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:27PM (#7292844)
ITT: pedantry
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by coldtea on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:36PM (#7292910)
The actual nonsense is the existance of the mythical " real, free-market capitalism", that nobody has ever seen in practice.

The "free market" that does exist is based on subsidies, bailouts, state protection, monopolies, a huge army, bullying, and resource grabbing (and past 300+ years of colonialism).

Heck, the "free market" is even more mythical than the laughable "really existing socialism".

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by kbolino on Monday February 24, 2014 @05:12PM (#7293768)
The free market does not exist because the government stands in its way. To then go on to chide free market advocates for actions they do not support is disingenuous at best.

Businessmen are not interested in ideology, if they can use the government as a cudgel against their opponents, or a crutch to sustain them in hard times, they will.

Every time the government's power over the economy has been expanded, advocates of the free market have pointed this fact out and been ignored.

You can't break my spine and then blame me for being paralyzed.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by coldtea on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @03:15AM (#7296293)
>The free market does not exist because the government stands in its way

So people should quit talking about it as it existed.

Not to mention that the same could (and WAS) said for communism ("it didn't exist because party bureucrats got in the way").

>You can't break my spine and then blame me for being paralyzed.

No, but I can point out that the unicorn pony you frequently talk about doesn't exist and never did in human history.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by kbolino on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @08:46PM (#7302192)
At various places and times throughout history, conditions of a largely free market have existed. It is not a "unicorn pony" (isn't that redundant and/or contradictory?). However, such conditions do not exist in most of the world now, and I don't see anywhere praxeologist or myself claimed otherwise.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by cdash on Monday February 24, 2014 @05:58PM (#7293988)
No one broke your spine, it never existed and never will. It is imaginary.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by kbolino on Monday February 24, 2014 @07:04PM (#7294250)
Pretty sure my spine is real. Perhaps you meant to unpack that analogy first?

The "free market" is simply what exists absent interference. It ceases to exist when a single player or group of players asserts force over the others. The purpose of government is to reduce the effectiveness of violence as a strategy.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by jbooth on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:10PM (#7293429)
Not to mention, taking an econ 101 supply and demand graph based on a quote 'widget factory' (actual textbook quote) and applying those ideas about marginal cost to utility economics where you build the grid once and then charge on subscription. Unironically. Earnestly, even.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by Aloisius on Monday February 24, 2014 @03:05PM (#7293093)
> not "natural monopolies" (which have never existed).

Tell that to Standard Oil or The American Tobacco Company.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by thatswrong0 on Monday February 24, 2014 @08:56PM (#7294720)
Do 10 minutes of research on Standard Oil. Not a great example.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by Aloisius on Monday February 24, 2014 @10:36PM (#7295270)
I suggest spending more than 10 minutes of research on it. Standard Oil is quite literally the textbook example of a natural monopoly.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by talmand on Monday February 24, 2014 @03:14PM (#7293144)
Based on my own non-expert personal musings on the subject, I would say that natural monopolies can and do exist in capitalism. It's just that under normal circumstances they would be difficult to sustain over a certain period of time based on several factors. Without some mechanic (often political) in place to prevent a new form of competition or technological progression from developing in the market, then a natural monopoly would likely be reduced by natural market forces.

If you look throughout just American history you can various examples of this. Big, strong companies that eventually fade away to disappear because of failure, lack of vision, or whatever other decisions that held the company back.

It's just that there is very few examples of a true free market, except for maybe on a local level, so that we'll likely never know for sure.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by arg01 on Monday February 24, 2014 @08:36PM (#7294630)
But of course no one advocates capitalism as an actual philosophical goal, they advocate that it's the best way to distribute our limited resources to get the most out of them. So if you accept the existence of natural monopolies it's hard to defend that the inefficiencies of regulating a monopoly to better capture externalities aren't less than the inefficiencies of personal profit maximizing behavior by the private entity with the monopoly.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by lkbm on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:18PM (#7292797)
Given that network effects and economies of scale are real things, on what grounds to you claim that natural monopolies don't exist?
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by logfromblammo on Monday February 24, 2014 @04:10PM (#7293427)
Natural monopolies do exist, it's just that not all businesses claimed to be natural monopolies actually are.

If you can, imagine a watershed. The river, along with its tributaries, covers the most efficient downhill route from every point in the watershed to sea level. The natural monopoly on precipitation drainage is everywhere you see flowing water. Installing a second river does not work. Wherever you try to put it, the natural tendency is for the second river to drop right down into the original watershed. You end up with just one river again.

If you turn that idea into a graph, replace the ocean with the Internet, the power plant, the potable water and sewage treatment facilities, the highway system, or some other common resource, and replace raindrop targets with homes and businesses. There is only one optimal routing for roads, pipes, wires, and fibers. The surface path following that route is the natural monopoly. You can cram an awful lot of stuff on top of it if you wanted.

Once poles are up and tunnels in place, the hard part is over. If a second cable company runs a second cable, that's not a waste. The customer can now buy either of two cable service packages, or both. If there's already a hamster tube up on the poles connecting the house to the municipal rat supply, and someone wants to run another for squirrels, that's not a waste. People might not want their rats and their squirrels from the same tube.

So when people say cable and phone service are natural monopolies, they are wrong. It's the space those wires run through.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by praxeologist on Monday February 24, 2014 @06:36PM (#7294139)
The analogy with a river doesn't work at all. Rivers don't act or engage in exchange. I see what you are saying on the most optimal path for water to flow, but that is then equivocating on "monopoly".
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by logfromblammo on Tuesday February 25, 2014 @01:24PM (#7299378)
Monopoly is a single seller of a good or service. There is an economic definition that must be met for a "natural monopoly" to exist, which depends on the marginal cost of producing additional units and the fixed cost of maintaining the capital. Basically, just as you don't typically see two different rivers draining the same watershed, you don't see multiple firms serving the same natural monopoly market. That doesn't mean that it never happens; it just means that any challenger to the incumbent either displaces them entirely, acquiring their capital in the process, or goes out of business and yields its capital to the incumbent.

The lowest energy state of the natural monopoly is a single firm. Excited states can also exist, and are necessary for transitions to occur, but these states are less economically efficient. Customers see higher prices, and firms see lower profits. But given that a monopoly is in itself inefficient, it can still be worthwhile for a challenger to attempt to displace the incumbent, especially if they can operate at lower costs.

In a truly free market, the switch could be accomplished by an initial investment of sufficient size. In the context of the analogy, huge machines dredge a new channel for the river. For a time, water flows in both channels, but in the end, one dries up and you are left with one river again.

Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by Consultant32452 on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:45PM (#7292579)
If you read the article it's plain to see that the monopolies are enforced and encouraged by the currently existing regulations. There is no free market in ISPs in the US.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by res0nat0r on Monday February 24, 2014 @02:32PM (#7292876)
You mean natural monopolies?
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by rhizome on Monday February 24, 2014 @01:34PM (#7292508)
Monopoly is the apotheosis of capitalist desire, competition is merely the measuring stick.
Re:Why Super-Fast Internet Is Coming Super Slowly by alexeisadeski3 on Monday February 24, 2014 @03:50PM (#7293349)
>I thought the USA was the model of capitalism.

You mean to tell me that the NYT has been lying to me all these years?